<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE ThML PUBLIC "-//CCEL/DTD Theological Markup Language//EN" "http://www.ccel.org/dtd/ThML10.dtd">
<?xml-stylesheet type="text/xml"
    href="http://www.ccel.org/ss/thml.html.xsl" ?>
  <?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl"
    href="http://www.ccel.org/ss/thml.html.xsl" ?>
  <!-- Copyright Christian Classics Ethereal Library -->
<ThML>
<ThML.head>

<generalInfo>
 <description>In 19th century schools of theology in Continental Europe, it had become fashionable to
 be skeptical about any traditional doctrine about the Bible. Many academic theologians
 denied the divinity of Christ, and others claimed that Paul’s letters were forgeries.
 Ramsay, while he used some of the same critical methods as his academic peers, was
 nevertheless able to counter their arguments effectively. Having spent years in Asia
 Minor studying the missionary journeys of Paul and the Apostles, Ramsay had become an
 expert on the New Testament’s historical documents. He argues that Luke, the author of
 the Acts of the Apostles and the Gospel of Luke, was as reliable an historian as any other
 in the first century. Thus in answer to the question, “Was Christ born in Bethlehem?”
 Ramsay answers: “Yes. We can trust Luke’s Gospel.”

 <br /><br />Kathleen O’Bannon<br />CCEL Staff
 </description>
 <pubHistory />
 <comments />
</generalInfo>

<printSourceInfo>
 <published>1898</published>
</printSourceInfo>

<electronicEdInfo>
  <publisherID>ccel</publisherID>
  <authorID>ramsay</authorID>
  <bookID>bethlehem</bookID>
  <workID>bethlehem</workID>
  <bkgID>was_christ_born_in_bethlehem?_(ramsay)</bkgID>
  <version />
  <series />

  <DC>
    <DC.Title>Was Christ Born in Bethlehem?</DC.Title>
    <DC.Creator sub="Author" scheme="short-form">W.M. Ramsay</DC.Creator>
    <DC.Creator sub="Author" scheme="file-as">Ramsay, William Mitchell, Sir (1851-1939)</DC.Creator>
    <DC.Publisher>Grand Rapids, MI: Christian Classics Ethereal Library</DC.Publisher>
    <DC.Subject scheme="LCCN">BS2650</DC.Subject>
    <DC.Subject scheme="lcsh1">The Bible</DC.Subject>
    <DC.Subject scheme="lcsh2">New Testament</DC.Subject>
    <DC.Subject scheme="lcsh3">Special parts of the New Testament</DC.Subject>
    <DC.Subject scheme="lcsh4">Pauline Epistles</DC.Subject>
    <DC.Subject scheme="ccel">All; </DC.Subject>
    <DC.Date sub="Created">2005-10-24</DC.Date>
    <DC.Type>Text.Monograph</DC.Type>
    <DC.Format scheme="IMT">text/html</DC.Format>
    <DC.Identifier scheme="URL">/ccel/ramsay/bethlehem.html</DC.Identifier>
    <DC.Source />
    <DC.Source scheme="URL" />
    <DC.Language scheme="ISO639-3">eng</DC.Language>
    <DC.Rights>Public Domain</DC.Rights>
  </DC>

</electronicEdInfo>


<style type="text/css">
p.normal	{ text-indent:.25in; margin-top:9pt; text-align:justify }
p.continue	{ text-indent:0in; margin-top:9pt; text-align:justify }
p.center	{ text-align:center; margin-top:9pt; margin-bottom:9pt }
</style>

<style type="text/xcss">
<selector element="p" class="normal">
  <property name="text-indent" value=".25in" />
  <property name="margin-top" value="9pt" />
  <property name="text-align" value="justify" />
</selector>
<selector element="p" class="continue">
  <property name="text-indent" value="0in" />
  <property name="margin-top" value="9pt" />
  <property name="text-align" value="justify" />
</selector>
<selector element="p" class="center">
  <property name="text-align" value="center" />
  <property name="margin-top" value="9pt" />
  <property name="margin-bottom" value="9pt" />
</selector>
</style>


</ThML.head>


	<ThML.body>

    <div1 title="Title Page" progress="0.19%" id="i" prev="toc" next="ii">

<h1 id="i-p0.1">WAS CHRIST BORN IN <br />
BETHLEHEM?</h1>
<h4 id="i-p0.3">by </h4>
<h2 id="i-p0.4">Sir William Ramsay</h2>

</div1>

    <div1 title="Preface" progress="0.20%" id="ii" prev="i" next="iii">
<h2 id="ii-p0.1">PREFACE </h2>
<p class="normal" id="ii-p1">UNDERSTANDING that a certain criticism implied a sort of challenge 
to apply my theory of Luke’s character as a historian to the Gospel, I took what 
is generally acknowledged to be the most doubtful passage, from the historian’s 
view, in the New Testament, <scripRef id="ii-p1.1" passage="Luke 2:1-4" parsed="|Luke|2|1|2|4" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.1-Luke.2.4">Luke 2:1-4</scripRef>. Many would 
not even call it doubtful. Strauss (in his <i>New Life of Jesus</i>) and Renan dismiss 
it in a short footnote as unworthy even of mention in the text.</p>
<p class="normal" id="ii-p2">This passage, interpreted according to the view which I have maintained 
— that Luke was a great historian, and that he appreciated the force of the Greek 
superlative (in spite of the contradiction of Professor Blass and others) — gave 
the result that Luke was acquainted with a system of Periodic Enrollments in Syria, 
and probably in the East generally. I looked for evidence of such a system; and 
it was offered by recent discoveries in Egypt. The confirmation afforded to Luke 
was explained in the Expositor,</p>

<p class="normal" id="ii-p3">April and June, 1897. Realizing better in subsequent thought the 
bearings of the Egyptian discovery, I have enlarged these two articles into an argument 
against the view that Luke sinks, in the accessories of his narrative, below the 
standard exacted from ordinary historians. At the risk of repeating views already 
stated in previous works, the second chapter attempts to put clearly the present 
state of the question as regards the two books of Luke, without expecting others 
to be familiar with my views already published.</p>
<p class="normal" id="ii-p4">The names of those scholars whose views I contend against are 
hardly ever mentioned. The scholars of the “destructive” school seem to prefer not 
to be mentioned, when one differs from them. I have learned much from them; I was 
once guided by them; I believe that the right understanding of the New Testament 
has been very greatly advanced by their laudable determination to probe and to understand 
everything, as is stated on p. 33; but I think their conclusions are to a great 
extent erroneous. It might, however, be considered disingenuous if I concealed that 
the weighty authority of Gardthausen, the historian of Augustus, is dead against 
me, p. 102.</p>
<p class="normal" id="ii-p5">My best thanks are due to Professor Paterson, who has discussed 
many points and cleared up my views in many ways; to Mr. B. P. Grenfell, who read 
the first proof of chapter 7, and enabled me to strengthen it; and, at last, to 
Mr. F. G. Kenyon; to Mr. A. C. Hunt; to Mr. Vernon Bartlett; and to Mr. A. Souter.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="ii-p6">The language of the book has profited much by my wife’s care in 
revision.</p>
<p class="normal" id="ii-p7">It would be impossible — and only wearisome to the reader if it 
were possible — to trace the origin of every thought expressed in the following 
pages. Where I was conscious, at the moment of writing, that I was using an idea 
suggested by another, I have said so; but as regards the New Testament, one learns 
in the course of years so much from so many sources that one knows not who is the 
teacher in each detail.</p>
<p class="normal" id="ii-p8">The relation between the almost identical solutions of the Quirinius 
difficulty, proposed nearly simultaneously by M. R. S. Bour and myself, is explained 
in chapter 11.</p>
<p class="normal" id="ii-p9">W. M. RAMSAY.</p>
<p class="normal" id="ii-p10">POSTSCRIPT. — I hear, Oct. 2, that Messrs. Grenfell and Hunt have 
found a household-enrollment paper a little older than AD. 50. The date is lost, 
but the same officials are mentioned in it as in a document of the 6th year of [Tiberius], 
where the names of Claudius and Caligula are impossible. Hence the paper belongs 
to the census of AD. 20, and proves conclusively my theory as to the origin of the 
Periodic Enrollments from Augustus. Much of the argument in chapter 7, printed when 
the Periodic Enrollments were traced with certainty only as far back as AD. 92, 
is now confirmed so completely, that part of it is hardly necessary.</p>

</div1>

    <div1 title="Part I — Importance of the Problem" progress="1.57%" id="iii" prev="ii" next="iii.i">



<h1 id="iii-p0.1">PART 1 <br />
IMPORTANCE OF THE PROBLEM</h1>

      <div2 title="Chapter 1. Luke’s History: What It Professes to Be" progress="1.59%" id="iii.i" prev="iii" next="iii.ii">
<h3 id="iii.i-p0.1">CHAPTER 1 <br />LUKE’S HISTORY: WHAT IT PROFESSES TO BE</h3>

<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p1">AMONG the writings which are collected in the New Testament, 
there is included a History of the life of Christ and of the first steps in the 
diffusion of his teaching through the Roman world, composed in two books. These 
two books have been separated from one another as if they were different works, 
and are ordinarily called “The Gospel according to Luke” and “The Acts of the Apostles”. 
It is, however, certain from their language, and it is admitted by every scholar, 
that the two books were composed by a single author as parts of a single historical 
work on. a uniform plan. After a period of independent existence, this History in 
two books was incorporated in the Canon, and its unity was broken up: the first 
book was placed among the group of four Gospels, and the second was left apart.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p2">Professor Blass has pointed out a trace of this original 
independent existence in the famous manuscript which was presented by the Reformer 
Beza to the University of Cambridge. In that manuscript the name of John is spelt 
in two different ways, the form Joanes being almost invariably used in Luke and 
Acts, and Joannes in the Gospels of Matthew, Mark and John.<note n="1" id="iii.i-p2.1">Exceptions — one in Luke, two each 
in Matthew, Mark and Acts, seven in John.</note> That slight difference in orthography leads us back to the time of some old copyist, 
who used as his authority a manuscript of the History of Luke, in which the spelling 
Joanes was employed, and different manuscripts of the other Gospels containing the 
spelling Joannes. Probably the spelling Joanes was that employed by the original 
author; and it is adopted in Westcott and Hort’s edition throughout the New Testament, 
except in <scripRef id="iii.i-p2.2" passage="Acts 4:6" parsed="|Acts|4|6|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.4.6">Acts 4:6</scripRef> and <scripRef id="iii.i-p2.3" passage="Revelation 22:8" parsed="|Rev|22|8|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Rev.22.8">Revelation 22:8</scripRef>.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p3">This historical work in two books is attributed by tradition 
to Luke, the companion and pupil of Paul. We are not here concerned with that tradition. 
Since all scholars are agreed that the same author wrote both books, we shall use 
the traditional name to indicate him merely for the sake of brevity, as it is necessary 
to have some name by which to designate the author; but we shall found no argument 
upon the authorship. Like Professor Blass, I see no reason to doubt the tradition; 
but those who do not accept the tradition may treat the name Luke in these pages 
as a mere sign to indicate the author, whoever he may be.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p4">The point with which we are here specially concerned is 
the trustworthiness of this author as a historian. Many facts are recorded by him 
alone, and it is a serious question whether or not they can be accepted on his sole 
authority.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p5">This is a subject on which there prevails a good deal of 
misapprehension and even confusion of thought. There are many who seem to think 
that they show fairness of mind by admitting that Luke has erred in this point or 
in that, while they still cling to their belief in other things, which he and he 
alone, records, on the ground that in those cases there is no clear evidence against 
him. But it must be said that this way of reasoning is really mistaken and unjustifiable: 
it refuses to make the inference that necessarily follows from the first admission.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p6">While human nature is fallible, and any man may make a 
slip in some unimportant detail, it is absolutely necessary to demand inexorably 
from a real historian accuracy in the essential and critical facts. We may pardon 
an occasional instance of bias or prejudice; for who is wholly free from it? But 
we cannot pardon any positive blunder in the really important points. If a historian 
is convicted of error in such a vital point, he ceases to be trustworthy on his 
own account; and every statement that he makes must gain credit from testimony external 
to him, or from general reasons and arguments, before we accept it. Especially must 
this be the case with the ancient historians, who as a rule hide their authorities 
and leave us in the dark as to the reasons and evidence that guided them to formulate 
their statements. There may be — there always are — many facts which the poorest 
chronicler records correctly; but we accept each of these, not because of the recorder’s 
accurate and sound judgment in selecting his facts, but because of other reasons 
external to him. If there is in such a historian any statement that is neither supported 
nor contradicted by external evidence, it remains uncertain and is treated as possibly 
true, but it shares in the suspicion roused by the one serious blunder.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p7">If we claim — and I have elsewhere in the most emphatic 
terms claimed — a high rank for Luke as regards trustworthiness, we must look fairly 
and squarely at the serious errors that are charged against him. If the case is 
proved against him in any of these, we must fairly admit the inevitable inference. 
If, on the other hand, we hold that the case is not proved, it is quite justifiable 
and reasonable, in a period of history so obscure as the first century, to plead, 
as many have done, that, while we cannot in the present dearth of information solve 
the difficulty completely, we are obliged, in accordance with our perception of 
the high quality of the author’s work as a whole, to accept his statement in certain 
cases where he is entirely uncorroborated. These must for the present rank among 
the difficulties of Luke. There are difficulties in every important Greek author, 
and each difficulty is the scholar’s opportunity.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p8">But it must be the aim of those who believe in the high 
character of Luke’s History, to discover new evidence which shall remove these difficulties 
and justify the controverted statements. The progress of discovery has recently 
placed in our hands the solution of one most serious difficulty and the justification 
of one much controverted statement; and the following pages are written with the 
intention of showing what is the bearing of this discovery on the general question 
as to the historical credibility of Luke.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p9">The whole spirit and tone of modern commentaries on Luke’s 
writings depend on the view which the commentators take on this question. In some 
cases the commentator holds that no historical statement made by Luke is to be believed, 
unless it can be proved from authorities independent of him. The commentary on Luke 
then degenerates into a guerrilla warfare against him; the march of the narrative 
is interrupted at every step by a series of attacks in detail. Hardly any attempt 
is made to estimate as a whole, or to determine what is the most favourable interpretation 
that can be placed on any sentence in the work. There is a manifest predilection 
in favor of the interpretation which is discordant
with external facts or with other statements in Luke. If it is possible to read 
into a sentence a meaning which contradicts another passage in the same author, 
that is at once assumed to be the one intended by him; and his incapacity and untrustworthiness 
are illustrated in the commentary.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p10">But no work of literature could stand being treated after 
this fashion. Imagine the greatest of pagan authors commented on in such a way; 
any slip of expression exaggerated or distorted; sentences strained into contradiction 
with other passages of the same or other authors; the commentary directed to magnify 
every fault, real or imaginary, but remaining silent about every excellence. There 
have occasionally been such commentaries written about great classical authors; 
and they have always been condemned by the general consent of scholars. Even where 
the bias of the commentator was due to a not altogether unhealthy revolt against 
general over-estimate of the author under discussion, the world of scholarship 
has always recognized that the criticism which looks only for faults is useless, 
misleading, unprogressive, and that. it defeats itself, when it tries to cure an 
evil by a much greater evil. Scholarship and learning sacrifice their vitality, 
and lose all that justifies their existence, when they cease to be fair and condescend 
to a policy of “malignity”.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p11">In this discussion it is obviously necessary to conduct 
the investigation as one of pure history, to apply to it the same canons of criticism 
and interpretation that are employed in the study of the other ancient historians, 
and to regard as our subject, not “the Gospel according to Luke,” but the History 
composed by Luke. The former name is apt to suggest prepossession and prejudice: 
the latter is purely critical and dispassionate.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p12">In estimating the character and qualities of an author 
we must look first of all to his opportunities. Had he good means of reaching the 
truth, or was his attempt to attain thorough knowledge of the facts made in the 
face of great difficulties? An historian ought to give us a statement of his own 
claims to be received as trustworthy, or an estimate of the character of the evidence 
which he had at his disposal.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p13">Luke has not failed to put clearly before his readers what 
character he claims for his history. He has given us, in the prefatory paragraph 
of his Gospel, a clear statement of the intention with which he wrote his history, and of the qualifications which give him the right to be accepted 
as an authority. He was not an eye-witness of the remarkable events which he is 
proceeding to record, but was one of the second generation to whom the information 
had been communicated by those “who were from the beginning eye-witnesses and ministers 
of the word”. The simplest interpretation of his words is that he claims to have 
received much of his information from the mouths of eye-witnesses; and, on careful 
study of the preface as a whole, it seems impossible to avoid the conclusion that 
he deliberately makes this claim. Any other interpretation, though it might be placed 
on one clause by itself, is negatived by the drift of the paragraph as a whole.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p14">Thus Luke claims to have had access to authorities of the 
first rank, persons who had seen and heard and acted in the events which he records. 
He makes no distinction as to parts of his narrative. He claims the very highest 
authority for it as a whole.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p15">In the second place, Luke claims to have studied and comprehended 
every event in its origin and development, 
(<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.i-p15.1">παρηκολουθηκότι ἄνωθεν 
πᾶσιν ἀκριβῶς</span>)  i. e., to have investigated 
the preliminary circumstances, the genesis and growth of what he writes about. Exactness 
and definiteness of detail in his narrative — these are implied in the word 
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.i-p15.2">ἄνωθεν</span>: investigation 
and personal study implied in the word <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.i-p15.3">
παρηκολουθηκότι</span>:
tracing of events from their causes and origin — implied in
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.i-p15.4">ἄνωθεν</span>: 
such are the qualities which Luke declares to be his justification for writing a 
narrative, when many other narratives already were in existence; and he says emphatically 
that this applies to all that he narrates.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p16">The expression used clearly implies that Luke began to 
write his narrative, because he was already in possession of the knowledge gained 
by study and investigation; as he begins, he is in the position of one who already 
has acquired the information needed for his purpose. This is implied in the perfect
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.i-p16.1">παρηκολουθηκότι</span>. 
The rendering in the Authorized and the Revised Version does not bring this out 
quite clearly: from the English words — “it seemed good to me also, having traced 
the course of all things accurately from the first,<note n="2" id="iii.i-p16.2">Better “from their origin”.</note> 
to write unto thee in order” — one might infer that the study and tracing of the 
course of events was resolved upon with the view of writing the history. But in 
the Greek that meaning would require the aorist participle. With the perfect participle 
the meaning must be “as I already possess the knowledge, it seemed good to me, like 
the others, to write a formal narrative for your use.”</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p17">On this point, I am glad to find myself in agreement with 
Professor Sanday, who refuses to assume that Luke “began with the intention of writing 
a history, and accumulated materials deliberately in view of this intention all 
through his career”. We cannot assume that, for the author, by implication, denies 
it. But we may safely assume that he had both the intelligent curiosity of an educated<note n="3" id="iii.i-p17.1"><i>Expositor</i>, Feb., 1896, p. 90.</note> Greek, 
and the eager desire for knowledge about the facts of the Saviour’s 
life, natural in a believer who rested his faith and his hopes on the life and death 
of Christ.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p18">Possibly some one may say that it is assuming too much 
when I speak of the author as an “educated” Greek. But any one who knows Greek can 
gather that from the preface alone. No one who had not real education and feeling 
for style could have written that sentence, so well balanced, expressed in such 
delicately chosen terms, so concise, and so full of meaning.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p19">In the third place, Luke declares his intention to give 
a comprehensive narrative of the events in order from first to last 
(<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.i-p19.1">καθεξῆς σοι γράψαι</span>). This does 
not necessarily imply a chronological order but a rational order, making things 
comprehensible, omitting nothing that is essential for full and proper understanding. 
In a narrative so arranged it stands to reason that, in general, the order will 
be chronological, though of course the order of logical exposition sometimes overrides 
simple chronological sequence (see chapter 10). Further, it 
is involved in the idea of a well-arranged History that the scale on which each 
event is narrated should be according to its importance in the general plan.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p20">Finally the account which Luke gives is, as he emphatically 
declares, trustworthy and certain 
(<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.i-p20.1">ἵνα ἐπιγνῷς 
. . . τὴν ἀσφάλειαν</span>).
His expression 
indubitably implies that he was not entirely satisfied with the existing narratives. 
He does not, it is true, say that explicitly; he utters no word of criticism on 
his predecessors, and he declares that they got their information from eye-witnesses. 
But his expression distinctly implies that he considered that some advance was still 
to be made, either as regards completeness, or as regards orderly exposition of 
the facts, or as regards accuracy. In all probability 
the fault in the existing narratives which Luke had especially in mind was their 
incompleteness. They embodied the tradition of eye-witnesses and ministers of the 
Word “from the beginning” 
(<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.i-p20.2">ἀπ᾽ ἀρχῆς</span>), which seems to imply “the beginning of 
the preaching of the Word”. We have to think of narratives in the form of the Gospel 
of Mark, with the opening: “the beginning of the Gospel of Jesus Christ” — narratives 
that commence with some such stage as the baptism. In contrast to these narratives 
Luke claims to trace the whole series of events from their origin, <i>i. e.</i>, 
from the higher or preliminary stage out of which they were derived 
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.i-p20.3">ἄνωθεν</span>).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p21">It seems beyond doubt that, in speaking of the origin, 
Luke has in view the narrative which he proceeds to give of the birth and early 
days of the Savior. Therein lay the most serious addition that he made to the narratives 
of his predecessors; and for that addition in particular he claims the same high 
character as for the narrative as a whole: he has it from firstclass authorities 
— exact, complete and trustworthy (see chapter 4).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p22">In view of the emphatic claim which Luke makes, that his 
whole narrative rests on the highest authority and is accurate and certain, it is 
obvious that we cannot agree with the attitude of those scholars, who, while accepting 
this whole History as the work of the real Luke, the follower and disciple and physician 
and intimate friend of Paul, are wont to write about the inadequacy of his authorities, 
the incompleteness of his information, the puzzling variation in the scale and character 
of his narrative according as he had good or inferior authorities to trust to. The 
writer of the preface would not admit that view: he claims to state throughout what 
is perfectly trustworthy.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p23">It may be allowed, consistently with his own claim, that 
his information was not everywhere equally good and complete. Thus, for example, 
he would naturally have heard much more about the facts of the Savior’s life, than 
about the events of the few years that followed upon his death: attention would 
be concentrated on the former, and the latter would be much less thought about or 
inquired into. But this view cannot be carried far without coming into contradiction 
with the profession of the preface. And, above all, those who admit that the Luke 
of the Epistles, the friend and companion of Paul, was the author of this History 
must not attempt to explain the account given by Luke 
of important events in Paul’s life, such as the Apostolic Council (<scripRef id="iii.i-p23.1" passage="Acts 15" parsed="|Acts|15|0|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.15">Acts 
15</scripRef>, by the supposition that the author was not acquainted 
with Paul’s account of the facts and character of that most critical event. He who 
had been Paul’s companion during the stormy years following that Council, when its 
decision was the subject of keen debate and rival interpretations, must have known 
what were Paul’s views on the subject.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p24">It is important to note that Luke in this preface distinguishes 
between the written accounts and the tradition of the eye-witnesses (<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.i-p24.1">καθὼς 
παρέδοσαν οἱ αὐτόπται</span>). So far as the actual word 
tradition, or Paradosis, goes, it might, and in many cases does, refer to written 
narrative; but in the present case the logic of the passage clearly implies a pointed 
distinction between tradition and written narrative. There existed when Luke wrote, 
on the one hand, oral tradition from eye-witnesses, and, on the other hand, many 
narratives written by those who learned from the eye-witnesses and put the tradition 
in literary form; but there were as yet no written narratives composed by eye-witnesses. 
This inference is drawn by Professor Blass, and is distinctly implied in Luke’s 
preface. Luke may have known Mark’s Gospel, and probably used it; but he did not 
know the other two Gospels.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p25">There can only be one conclusion, when the terms of Luke’s 
preface are duly weighed. Either an author who begins with a declaration such as 
that had mixed freely with many of the eye-witnesses and actors in the events which 
he proceeds to record, or he is a thorough impostor, who consciously and deliberately 
aims at producing belief in his exceptional qualifications in order to gain credit 
for his History. The motive for such an imposture could hardly be mere empty desire 
to be considered a true narrator. The man of that age, who was deliberately outraging 
truth, felt no such overpowering passion for the distinction of having attained 
abstract truth in history. He must have sought to put on the semblance of truth 
and authority in order to gain some end by conciliating belief in his narrative; 
he must have desired to gain credit in order that his party or his opinions might 
triumph. They who declare that the author belonged to a later age are bound to prove 
that there was some such intention in his mind.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p26">Hitherto every attempt to show that the historian had such 
an aim in view has ended in complete failure. With regard to Book I., the Gospel, 
the attempt is ludicrous; the narrative is so transparently simple and natural that 
hardly any amount of prepossession could read into it such aims. With Book II., 
the Acts, we are not here concerned. Elsewhere I have tried to show what a single 
eye the author has in that book to the simple statement of facts as they actually 
happened; it seems to me to be almost as transparently simple and natural as the 
Gospel.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p27">No rational theory, such as would for a moment be admitted 
in regard to an ordinary classical author, has ever been advanced to account for 
the supposition of deliberate imposture in the claims to credit advanced by Luke. 
If the author was an impostor, his work remains one of the most incomprehensible 
and unintelligible facts in literary history. One can imagine, for example, that 
Peter was written by a person who was so filled with the conviction that he was 
giving the views of his master, Peter the Apostle, as to express the letter in Peter’s 
name; the case might seem to him (from a mistaken point of view) to be not wholly 
unlike the expression of the old prophets, “thus saith the Lord”. That is a conceivable 
and rational hypothesis, though whether it be true or false we cannot say, and need 
not now inquire. No such rational hypothesis has yet been advanced to account for 
Luke’s far more elaborate, and therefore more deliberate, imposture.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p28">But this abstract and rather intangible argument must yield 
to the demonstration of hard facts. So much we freely grant. Now it is asserted 
that the historian whom we are studying has been guilty of such serious and gross 
blunders, when he touches on matters of general history, that his information cannot 
have been so good as he pretends, and therefore he must be claiming too much when 
he arrogates such an authoritative character for his History. We shall feel bound 
to accept that argument; and, if the blunders are demonstrated, we must accept the 
necessary inferences and abandon our championship of his accuracy and trustworthiness. 
But let us first examine the demonstration.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p29">We cannot investigate in this volume every “blunder” that 
is charged against Luke; but we shall treat one rather fully. If I may judge both 
from personal feeling, from conversation, and from many books, the “blunder” which most contributes to rouse prejudice against him as an 
historian, occurs at the very beginning, in that same episode on which he evidently 
lays such stress in his preface — the story of the Birth of Christ. In this story 
the enrollment or census of Palestine in the time of Quirinius is a critical point; 
and the doubt whether any such census as Luke describes was made, is the cause of 
important and far-reaching results. It is declared to be a blunder, or rather a 
complication of blunders; and if that be so, the entire story must be relegated 
to the realm of mythology, and the writer who mistakes fable for fact, and tries 
to prop up his mistake by an error of the grossest kind, can retain no credit as 
an historical authority.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.i-p30">In conclusion, we shall briefly refer to one or two other 
typical so-called “errors” in Luke.</p>


</div2>

      <div2 title="Chapter 2. The Design and Unity of Luke’s History" progress="8.48%" id="iii.ii" prev="iii.i" next="iii.iii">
<h3 id="iii.ii-p0.1">CHAPTER 2<br />
THE DESIGN AND UNITY OF LUKE’S HISTORY</h3>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p1">AS has been stated, a historian may make a slip in some 
detail without losing claim to be trustworthy: no man and no historian is perfect. 
But he must not found his reasoning upon the error. Facts that are fundamental in 
his argument must be free from slip or fault. There must be no mistake on a critical 
point.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p2">If we consider Luke’s design, we shall see that the “error” 
which forms our subject affects the very life-blood of the work and the atmosphere 
in which the story moves. But every great work of literature like Luke’s History 
must be reinterpreted by each new age for itself; and it is more useful to describe 
what views are now held as to the plan and design of that History, than to sketch 
the design.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p3">The consummate literary skill shown in Luke’s work must 
impress every reader, who allows free play to his sense of literary effect. We feel 
that in this work we have to deal with an author who handles his materials freely 
and with perfect mastery. The unity of style and treatment in the narrative, its 
dramatic character, varying according to the country and the action and the character 
of every speaker, so Greek in Athens, so “provincial” in the Roman colonies Lystra 
and Philippi, so Hebraic in Galilee or by the Jordan, and so Lukan everywhere — 
this character and individuality, shown in numberless ways, make it clear that the 
author was no clipper-up of fragments from other writers, no mere scissors-and-paste editor of scraps, no mere second-hand composer, dependent on the accidental 
character of his “sources,” according to the elaborate and somewhat pedantic theories 
that have been fashionable recently in Germany, but are already becoming discredited 
there. Only a person who has blinded himself to literary feeling by the strength 
of a fixed prejudice, could fail to perceive the literary quality of this History, 
and to infer from it the real unity of the work.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p4">When a commentator on the text of Luke, observing that 
Luke “can be as Hebraistic as the Septuagint and as free from Hebraisms as Plutarch,” 
and that “he is Hebraistic in describing Hebrew society,” 
and Greek in describing Greek society, refrains from expressing any opinion as to 
whether this result is attained “intentionally or not,” that is a very proper reserve 
for a commentator to maintain. He is not called upon to determine in the preface 
to a commentary whether this varying character has been given intentionally to the 
work by its author, or has remained attached to it by chance, according as the character 
of the different documents on which Luke depended continued to exist in his completed 
work. But the literary judgment will not hesitate. Luke is so completely master 
of his materials, and handles the Greek language with such ease and power, that 
he must have intended to give his work the literary qualities which are observable 
in it. A rational criticism must always assume that an author intended to attain 
that delicately graduated effect which in fact he has attained.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p5">But the interval which separated the historian from the 
events which he records is an important element in estimating his design. Great 
literary power may tell against his trustworthiness, by helping him to hide the 
poverty of his materials; and that view has been maintained as regards Luke by writers 
of the type of Baur, Zeller and Renan. They argued that Luke was an able and beautiful 
but not very well-informed author, who lived long after the events which he records, 
at a time when all actors in those events had died, and when accurate knowledge 
of facts was difficult to acquire. In addition to the skillful arguments by which 
they showed up a series of internal discrepancies and improbabilities, the apparent 
discordance between the narrative (especially in the second book) and the general 
scheme and character of Roman Imperial administration in the Eastern provinces, 
seemed to many to weigh heavily against the idea that the book embodied a really 
trustworthy account of events.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p6">In the picture of Christian history during the first century, 
according to the accepted interpretation of Luke’s History, there was no apparent 
relation between the development of Christian influence and the existing facts of 
the Roman empire. The modern writers who professed to found their views upon Luke, 
after a few picturesque paragraphs about Roman proconsuls and armies and the march 
of the Roman eagles, plunged into Christian history, and the reader saw nothing 
more of Rome except when a Gallio or a Sergius Paullus obtruded himself on the scene 
with something of the air of a bad actor equipped in 
ill-fitting Roman dress. The life of the empire was wanting: that consisted, not 
in eagles and proconsuls, but in order and organization, and in the development 
and Romanisation of society.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p7">Those who studied Roman history first of all, and Christian 
history only in a secondary degree, were inevitably driven to the conclusion that 
a work, upon which was founded such a lifeless and spiritless picture of part of 
the Roman world in the first century, could not be a product of that century, but 
must have originated at a later date, when the life of the time described was no 
longer understood.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p8">But a most important part of Luke’s Second Book is concerned 
with Asia Minor and Greece; and any one who has gone through the long, slow process 
by which in recent years the lost history of Asia Minor has been in some degree 
recreated by the work of a number of scholars, and their studies Luke without prepossession, 
must observe, that his references to those lands have a marked and peculiar individuality 
— a certain matter-of-fact tone — which is utterly unlike the vague style of a later 
author, narrating the events of a past age with the purpose of showing their bearing 
on the questions of his own day. One feels that, in all that concerns Asia Minor, 
Luke is treating real facts with thorough knowledge.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p9">As knowledge of Asia Minor grew, one perceived that Luke’s 
statements explained some most obscure problems by setting in a new light the evidence 
that had long seemed unintelligible. Luke takes us right into the midst of the political 
development of central Asia Minor, when Roman organizing skill was treating one 
by one the successive problems of government amid a semi-Oriental population, regarding 
some districts as still too rude to be Romanised, and placing them under the educative 
care of dependent kings, treating others as already worthy of the honor of being 
incorporated in the Roman empire as fractions of a great province, and fostering 
among them a spirit of pride in the Imperial connection and contempt for the extra-provincial barbarians.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p10">It is a difficult thing to revivify and rearrange the details 
of that magnificent political work; and in some respects I erred in my first attempt<note n="4" id="iii.ii-p10.1"><i>The Church in the Roman Empire</i>, Pt. 1.</note> 
to recreate the picture of the Imperial scheme for Romanising the inner 
lands by gradually building them up into a great Roman province called Galatia. But the errors (though vexatious to myself 
as I gradually came to see more clearly) were not so important as to disturb materially 
the truth of the picture in its general effect. It had been given me, through intense 
longing after truth, to catch the main outlines correctly, and to understand that 
Luke’s brief references to the state of central Asia Minor plunged the reader into 
the heart of the conflict between Graeco-Roman forms of life and the amorphous 
barbarism of a Phrygian and Lycaonian population. In that state of the land, to 
be Phrygian or Lycaonian was to be unenlightened and non-Roman, to be Roman was 
to be a loyal member of the province Galatia. Such a state of things could not have 
been conceived or understood by a writer of the second century, when Rome had long 
been supreme over the whole of Asia Minor, and when the opposition between the contending 
ideas, Roman or Galatic on the one hand, native (<i>i.e</i>., Phrygian, Pisidian,
<i>etc</i>.) and non-Roman on the other, had ceased to be a real force in the country.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p11">But if this view which opened gradually before us was correct, 
then we had to abandon the current, generally accepted opinion, which. admitted 
no Roman conceptions in the terms relating to geography and political classification 
in Acts, which saw, for example, in the “Galatic Territory,” not a Roman province, 
but the country where Attalus, King of Pergamos, had confined the Galatae or Galli 
about 230 BC. We must regard Paul as a Roman, using Roman terms and forms, just 
as he accepted the Roman classification and system of administration.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p12">As it happened, this implied and necessitated a radical 
revolution in the interpretation of the book of Acts and of early Christian history 
as a whole. It meant that the connection and the conflict between Christianity and 
the Roman State did not begin in the second century, as was the almost unanimous 
opinion of the greatest authorities during the halfcentury preceding 1890 (when 
Neumann’s book carried back the beginning to the reign of Domitian, AD. 81-96). 
It meant that the conscious and recognized relations between the New Religion and 
the Roman Administration began when Barnabas and Saul stood before the Roman proconsul 
of Cyprus, when the latter, hitherto junior and subordinate to Barnabas, took the 
lead, and the supposed Hebrew wise man named Saul stood forth as the Greek Paul 
and impressed the Roman governor by declaring the principles of the new Catholic, 
world-wide religion. It meant that the first important 
step in the spreading of this Catholic religion was made, when Paul and Barnabas 
crossed Taurus from the secluded and unimportant Province Pamphylia, into the important 
Province Galatia — the province which embodied all that was Roman in Central Asia 
Minor, the province in which the Roman element was involved in the sharpest antagonism 
to the rude ignorance of an Oriental, priest-guided, ritual-loving native population 
— and planted their feet on the great highway of intercourse between the East and 
the West.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p13">Further, it now began to grow clear that some of the discrepancies 
which had been the mainstay of Baur’s and Zeller’s argument, were due to the stereotyped 
misunderstanding of the Roman side of early Christian history, Both the general 
character and many details of that history were distorted, when contemplated through 
the medium of the dominant theory.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p14">The life of the early Church lay in constant intercommunication 
between all its parts; its health and growth were dependent on the free circulation 
of the life-blood of common thought and feeling. Hence it was first firmly seated 
on the great lines of communication across the empire, leading from its origin in 
Jerusalem to its imperial center in Rome. It had already struck root in Rome within 
little more than twenty years after the crucifixion, and it had become really strong 
in the great city about thirty years after the apostles began to look round and 
out from Jerusalem. This marvelous development was possible only because the seed 
of the new thought floated free on the main currents of communication, which were 
ever sweeping back and forward between the heart of the empire and its outlying 
members. Paul, who mainly directed the great movement, threw himself boldly and 
confidently into the life of the time; he took the empire as it was, accepted its 
political conformation and arrangement, and sought only to touch the spiritual and 
moral life of the people, while he always advised them to obey the existing Government 
and conform to the existing laws of the State and of society, so far as they did 
not lead into direct conflict with Christian principles.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p15">But the formerly accepted interpretation of the Second 
Book of Luke’s History carried Christianity away into eddies and backwaters of the 
ocean of Roman Imperial development, and placed there the scene of the first great 
conflict between Judaistic provincialism and the world-wide Pauline conception of Christianity. It was blind to the true character 
of Paul’s work, which sought to spiritualize the life and educative development 
of the empire by affecting the main currents of its circulation and intercommunication; 
and it tried to distinguish the lines along which the new thought spread from the 
lines along which the life of the world was throbbing.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p16">The dominance of that interpretation produced a position, 
the analogue of which still exists in respect of some other questions. That theory 
led straight into a series of difficulties, for which no rationally satisfying solution 
could be found; and the scholars who treated Luke’s History were divided broadly 
into two classes. Some saw so clearly the unity, the power and the personal quality 
in the work, that they refused to be led astray by the serious difficulties in which 
they were involved on certain points. Others realized so strongly the difficulties, 
that they formed their judgment from them alone and ignored the quality of the History 
as a whole.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p17">The progress of discovery is indubitably tending to show 
that the scholars of the former class were, on the whole, in the right; but this 
should not blind us to the immense service rendered by those of the other class, 
who kept the difficulties clear before the world’s consciousness.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p18">Moreover, it must be admitted that the scholars who judged 
by literary feeling and the general quality of Luke’s History, were not always wise 
in their treatment of the difficulties. Instead of frankly acknowledging that the 
difficulties were inexplicable in our present state of knowledge, they sometimes 
attempted by ingenious special pleading to minimize them, and then claimed that 
the difficulties were solved. Their vigorous perception of the central and most 
important fact, <i>viz</i>., the first-hand directness of Luke’s style, made them 
so thoroughly convinced that the difficulties must be explicable, that they were 
almost blinded to the strength of the arguments against them, and sometimes thought 
they had explained difficulties, when they had merely shut their eyes to them.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p19">The result was that those who, like myself, had been accustomed 
only to classical Greek, and were too young to appreciate fully the literary quality 
of a writer in such an unfamiliar form of Greek, and who were determined to understand 
clearly and precisely every step in reasoning, were repelled by what seemed to us to be pure prejudice and unwillingness 
to admit reason, and were driven violently over to the opposite side; and it was 
a long and slow process to work back again to the side against which we had acquired 
such a strong prepossession.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p20">In such a state of mind it was natural to rest for a time 
in a theory of double authorship, that Luke’s History was partly excellent and partly 
second-rate (as I was almost inclined to do while writing <i>The Church in the 
Roman Empire</i>). One could feel that Luke’s Second Book was characterized by such 
singular accuracy in all details bearing on the society and the political organization 
of the Eastern provinces, that the author’s expression in many places could not 
have been framed without first-hand knowledge, and that his point of view was distinctly 
of the first century, or rather the pre-Domitianic type, as distinguished from 
that which was produced by the persecution of Domitian.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p21">But, on the other hand, parts of the History seemed to 
involve insoluble difficulties and discrepancies.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p22">Hence, while no distinct theory was stated in my treatise, 
yet the language used in it sometimes pointed towards a theory of dual authorship.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p23">But such ideas were utterly inconsistent with the unity 
of plan, the vigorous controlling intellect which revealed itself throughout Luke’s 
work; and the impossibility to stand still in such a halfway position, clinging 
to rival and inconsistent views, became rapidly manifest. It was not possible to 
introduce maturer views into the book already published, even in a new edition; 
for the sole merit that it possessed lay in its being perfectly unprejudiced and 
unfettered by any theory as to the composition of Luke’s History. After forming 
a definite opinion about that History as a whole, it was no longer possible to write 
as if one had no opinion. Therefore, the book had to remain as it was, with its 
defect of being not self-consistent in respect of Luke, since the want of systematic 
unity was the guarantee of its being the unprejudiced effort of a mind groping for 
truth.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p24">It became more and more clear that it is impossible to 
divide Luke’s History into parts, attributing to one portion the highest authority 
as the first-hand narrative of a competent and original authority, while regarding the rest as of quite inferior mold. If the author of one part 
is the real Luke, or any other person standing in similar close relations with the 
circle surrounding the apostles (particularly Paul), then that same person must 
be the author of the whole, and must have brought to bear on his whole work the 
same qualities which made one part so excellent. It may be that he found it more 
difficult to feel perfectly at home in the Palestinian part of his narrative than 
where the scene lies in the Aegean lands. It may be that in the parts intervening 
between the Resurrection or the Ascension (with which many, probably all, of his 
written authorities ended) and the beginning of Paul’s personal recollections, he 
found it harder to obtain perfectly satisfactory knowledge. But we cannot lay much 
stress on these causes of diversity in character. The History must stand as a whole, 
and be judged as a whole. If one part shows striking historical excellence, so must 
all; if any part shows a conspicuous historical blunder, we must be very suspicious 
of a theory which attributes surpassing qualities to another part.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p25">In regard to the Second Book of Luke, my arguments are 
set forth elsewhere,<note n="5" id="iii.ii-p25.1">Both in the pages of the <i>Expositor</i> 
in many separate articles, and in <i>St.Paul the Traveler and the Roman Citizen</i>.</note> 
and, while I feel conscious how imperfectly they have been stated, and how much 
better the work ought to have been done, I have nothing of consequence either to 
retract or to modify, though much might be added. After three years more of study, 
Luke appears more clearly than ever to me as one of the great historians.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p26">Such a view is unfashionable; and there is in some quarters 
a disposition to regard it even as a crime and a personal affront to the distinguished 
scholars who have thought differently. It is true that I have advocated a view diametrically 
opposed to their judgment, and that, if I be right, they have erred in a critical 
question of the utmost importance and interest. But I have not sought to give the 
discussion this personal application. It is not a crime to differ from another scholar 
as to the date and quality of any of the disputed classical works; and my desire 
has been to proceed in regard to Luke on the same lines as in the questions of extra-Biblical scholarship. One of the scholars whom I reverence most deeply in all Europe 
differs very strongly from my judgment as to the authority of the <i>Peutinger Table</i>, 
but the difference makes no change in my profound respect and admiration for him, 
and none in the great kindness which he has always shown to a beginner like me. 
Similarly there is no reason why Luke’s authority as 
a historian should not be treated as a justifiable subject for discussion. I entertain, 
and have always professed, great admiration for many scholars whose opinions I dispute 
on some points of Christian history, and from their learning I have gained much.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p27">It is a more serious evil that a disposition is sometimes 
shown to terrorize the investigator by the array of learned opinion on the opposite 
side, and to treat it as the necessary mark of a reasonable scholar in this subject, 
that he should be always searching for and finding proofs of the late date, and 
inaccuracy, and composite character of Luke’s History. It is comforting to certain 
minds to have some one whose opinions they can accept implicitly; and it would almost 
appear that a few of our English scholars attribute to the German commentators on 
the Bible that inerrancy which our parents or grandparents attributed to the text. 
They set up an idol, and condemn as an impious iconoclast him that sees the idol’s 
feet of clay, even while he reverences the image.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p28">But in matters of scholarship it is not safe to follow 
implicitly any scholar, however great he may be; and we appeal to fact and reason 
against the dogmatism which seeks to close the case, refuses to admit further argument, 
and brands as an “apologist” any defender of Luke’s character as a historian.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p29">Not long ago it was reckoned by many as essential to a 
respectable scholar that he should pooh-pooh Luke as a second-century writer. 
Now we are permitted, on the highest German authority, to date him in the first 
century. We are permitted also to speak of certain parts and scenes in the Second 
Book of his History as showing marvelous accuracy and great power of conceiving 
and setting before the reader a life-like picture of what actually occurred. But 
we are not permitted to infer that he is a trustworthy historian, and that the presumption 
is in favor of his accuracy, even in cases, where no clear external evidence corroborates 
his statements.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p30">We might ask whether it is a probable or possible view 
that the author can be so unequal to himself, that in one place he can show very 
high qualities as an accurate historian, and that in another place, when dealing 
with events equally within the range of his opportunities for acquiring knowledge, 
he can prove himself incompetent to distinguish between good and bad, true and false. He that shows the historic faculty 
in part of his work has it as a permanent possession.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p31">The power of vivid conception and accurate description 
in concise, wellchosen, pregnant language, which Luke admittedly shows in some passages, 
proves that he could estimate correctly the comparative importance of details, select 
the essential points, and skillfully group them. An author fixes a standard for 
himself at his best, and is most unlikely to sink below it. The true critic will 
recognize this, and will not rest satisfied till he has traced the same qualities 
throughout the work. That method of studying Luke has not yet been consistently 
employed in the light of modern historical, geographical and antiquarian knowledge. 
The attempt to carry it out consistently will be stigmatized by those who dislike 
its results as pedantic insistence on minute points of language and mere “Mikrologie”; 
but it must be made in the face of such prohibition.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p32">On this subject there are only two alternatives. It grows 
more and more clear that compromise — such as is common among those by whom it is 
esteemed fair-minded to accept as much as possible from the results of the destructive 
school — is impossible. The mind that is really logical and self-consistent cannot 
admit part of the so-called “critical” view — what ought to be called the uncritical 
view — and yet on the whole cling to the belief in real Lukan authorship. Luke’s 
History is of such a strongly marked character what are called the “gaps” or omissions 
in it are so distinct, or, in other words, the proportion of the parts in it is 
so peculiars — the insistence upon some facts and the summary dismissal of others 
with a bare word forms so prominent a feature of the work — that either the author 
had a distinct idea of plan and purpose and comparative importance, according to 
which his whole narrative was ordered and guided, or he was not the real Luke.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p33">Occasionally it is possible, with some plausible and deceptive 
show of reason, to maintain that the length at which some incident is narrated is 
due merely to the author’s possessing exceptionally good sources of information 
about it. Take for example, the long description of the voyage From Philippi to 
Caesarea. That description is given in the words of one who was present on the ships. 
It therefore rests on authority of the highest character; and it might plausibly 
be maintained that the exceptionally excellent nature 
of the information led the author to devote an exceptional amount of space to it.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p34">But if a believer in the Lukan authorship of the History 
attempts in a consistent way to carry out that theory, he is led into hopeless contradiction. 
Situations at which the real Luke must have been present are dismissed in the curtest 
way or omitted altogether, while others in which he was not present are described 
at great length. If the author so carefully chronicles the progress past Chios, 
and Samos, and Cos, and Rhodes, and Myra, and Cyprus, for the sole reason that he 
was present and knew what happened, why should he, after describing so carefully 
and minutely the progress of the Gospel in Corinth and Ephesus, or its comparative 
failure in Athens, which he had not seen, sum up in a word the two years in Rome, 
where he was present — years which must have been so full of important events and 
impressive preaching? Why should he omit the two years’ residence in Caesarea, except 
as regards two isolated scenes, and describe so much more fully the previous twelve 
days’ residence there? Why should events in which Paul and Luke were both keenly 
interested, and as to which they must have known each other’s views — why should 
such events be narrated at great length by Luke, and in a way which shows, on the 
accepted interpretation, utter ignorance of Paul’s views?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p35">No answer has ever been given to these questions. In truth, 
he who admits that theory must., if he is logical, go on, like Professor Harnack 
and Professor McGiffert, to deny that the real Luke was the author.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p36">But it is at once the special strength and the peculiar 
weakness of English scholarship that, even when it makes a mistake, it shrinks with 
a healthy and saving instinct from carrying out the mistake to extremes; it is not 
consistent with itself where to be consistent means to go further astray. With its 
practical sense it gains the chief result — truth in the main. It returns to the 
right path when its course is becoming clearly divergent; and often it returns before 
it has erred so far from the true path as to become completely conscious of its 
wandering. Hence, it disapprovingly regards him that remonstrates with it for its 
want of consistency, on the ground that “he hunts down the statements of his opponents 
into what seem to him to be their consequences”. In this country we are, perhaps, 
too apt to think that a scholar is responsible only 
for what he has explicitly stated, and not for the logical consequences of his views.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p37">On the other hand, it is at once the strength and the weakness 
of German scholarship that it is thoroughly and remorselessly logical, that it carries 
out its views with steadfast and unwavering consistency, that it works out every 
theory to its consequences, that it is always conscious where it has gone, and is 
never untrue to itself, even though it thereby sacrifices the real object of its 
pursuit. When it goes wrong it demonstrates its own error with absolute conclusiveness, 
for it never works round out of the straight line back towards the true path.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p38">A good example of the attempt at compromise and of the 
illogicality of such an attempt, is found in the main subject of our investigation 
— Luke’s story of the birth of Christ and the first enrollment of Palestine.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p39">The attack directed against the credibility of that episode 
has been strong, confident, almost triumphant in its tone.<note n="6" id="iii.ii-p39.1">See chapter 5.</note> 
The defense has been rather timid and hesitating; the introduction of Quirinius’s 
name has been abandoned almost universally as a demonstrated blunder; and even the 
reality of the “First Enrollment” has been championed by Luke’s advocates in a very 
reluctant and half-hearted way.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p40">But to make even one of these concessions is practically 
and logically to abandon the case, so far as Luke’s character as a historian is 
concerned. He who says that “Luke is in error in the name of Quirinius,” admits 
that, even when Luke had learned a fact from some authority, he could not keep himself 
free from a huge blunder in stating it.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p41">Beyond all doubt, the suspicion entertained about Luke’s 
History is due to the belief that, when he touches on general history, his references 
are usually demonstrably false, as contrary to historical record, and are rarely 
or never conclusively supported by other historians. He is the only Evangelist who 
has attempted to place his narrative in its proper relation to contemporary history; 
and when he tries to do so, almost every one, even most of his defenders, admit 
that he cannot do it without making errors.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p42">It is generally admitted that (as Canon Gore puts it) “the 
chronological data in <scripRef passage="Luke 2:1-52" id="iii.ii-p42.1" parsed="|Luke|2|1|2|52" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.1-Luke.2.52">Luke 2</scripRef>  
and <scripRef passage="Luke 3:1-38" id="iii.ii-p42.2" parsed="|Luke|3|1|3|38" osisRef="Bible:Luke.3.1-Luke.3.38">3</scripRef> were supplied by 
himself and not by his sources”. Luke gives us the 
result of his own investigations into the historical surroundings of the life of 
Christ. But if his investigations were of such a character that he confused the 
census of 8 BC. with that of 6-7 AD., and imagined that Christ was born “in the 
days of Herod the King,” during a census held about ten or eleven years after the 
death of Herod — when Herod was king, and yet when a Roman viceroy was organizing 
the new province of Palestine — of what value were his investigations, or his ideas 
about past history, or his evidence?<note n="7" id="iii.ii-p42.3">There are other impossibilities upon 
impossibilities which have often been stated, and are repeated in chapter 5.</note> 
What should we think of the historical qualities of a modern author who began an 
account of the life of Hereward the Wake by confusing between Edward the Confessor 
and William the Conqueror? The one case would be no worse than the other. The first 
attempt that the author makes to connect his subject with contemporary history shows 
hopeless ignorance of that history.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p43">It is no wonder in these circumstances that Luke’s History 
has fallen under suspicion so strong that the case in its favor has been generally 
considered weaker than that in favor of any other important book in the New Testament. 
When I ventured, in defiance of the general verdict, to argue that Luke is a real 
historian — and “the first and the essential quality of the great historian is truth” 
— even so conservative and so friendly a scholar as Professor Sanday found that 
my “treatment of Luke as a historian seems too optimistic”.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p44">But it is an essentially inconsistent position to fancy 
that we can accept three-fourths or nine-tenths of what Luke says as true, and 
reject the rest. Destroy a historian’s credit in one critical point, and there remains 
naught.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p45">The confounding of one census with another in this case 
would be one of the serious things, which condemn the would-be historian as hopelessly 
incapable of accuracy or sound historical judgment. His statements cease to have 
any value in themselves; we can in each case only seek for a source, and estimate 
the probability of the statement by the authority of the source, after subtracting 
the likelihood of some other blunder having been made by Luke in using his source.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.ii-p46">To judge how seriously this blunder affects the author’s 
character, how inevitable are the inferences which the logical mind must deduce 
from the blunder, we must glance at two preliminary points which will form the subject 
of chapters 3. and 4.</p>

</div2>

      <div2 title="Chapter 3. Luke’s Attitude Towards the Roman World" progress="18.31%" id="iii.iii" prev="iii.ii" next="iii.iv">

<h3 id="iii.iii-p0.1">CHAPTER 3 <br />
LUKE’S ATTITUDE TOWARDS THE ROMAN WORLD</h3>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p1">The reign of Augustus, as is well known, is enveloped in 
the deepest obscurity. While we are unusually well informed about the immediately 
preceding period of Roman history, and for part of the reign of his successor, Tiberius, 
we possess the elaborate and accurate, though in some respects strongly prejudiced 
account of Tacitus, the facts of Augustus’s reign have to be pieced together from 
scanty, incomplete and disjointed authorities.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p2">Moreover, obscure events in a remote corner of the Roman 
world can never even in the best attested periods be expected to come within the 
purview of Roman history. Such events are preserved to us only by some accidental 
reference or some local authority; and it is unreasonable to cast doubt on the local 
authority, either because he relates what is not related by the Roman historians, 
or because he regards things from a different point of view, and sees them in different 
perspective, and applies to them a very different scale of importance.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p3">The real value of these accidentally preserved local authorities 
is that they do <i>not</i> give the Roman point of view, but enable us to contemplate 
part of the Roman world, as it was seen by non-Roman eyes. What would we not give 
for a review of Caesar’s Gallic campaigns by a leading Gaulish Druid or chief, or 
for a criticism of Agricola by the chief bard of Boadicea or of Galgacus? Tacitus, 
indeed, has expressed the views of Galgacus, but we feel that it is Tacitus, not 
the British chief, that speaks.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p4">We should, undoubtedly, find in the words of the Gaul or 
the Briton a very different view from the official justification and. <i>Apologia</i> 
for his career published by Caesar, or the panegyric composed by Tacitus. We should 
certainly have considerable difficulty in reconciling the opposing authorities, 
and in striking a balance between the discrepant judgments and statements as to 
facts. But it would be sheer unreason to set aside as mere invention every assertion 
of the Gallic or British authority, which could not be established on Roman authority. Reasonable and sound criticism will apply the same standard 
to Luke’s history. It will not demand that he, a Greek of the wider Greek world, 
as distinguished from the narrower country of Greece proper, should look at everything 
through Roman spectacles, and express everything precisely as a Roman would do. 
It will rate his value all the higher, because he has not done that — because he 
shows us how Roman things were looked at by one who was not a Roman. It will be 
prepared to find differences of expression and description, even when the Greek 
and the Roman are looking at the same historical fact. To estimate Luke fairly, 
it will ask what was his attitude towards the Roman world. In answer to this question, 
one might say much; but even a brief chapter may be of some use.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p5">On the whole, Luke’s view has in essentials a strong Paulinistic 
character. He was disposed towards the Imperial government and political institutions 
very much as Paul was, and as the wider Greek world in general was. He accepted 
unreservedly the existing facts of society and organization. But there was a difference 
between them.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p6">Paul, as a Roman himself, spoke from the Roman point of 
view. Though he was a citizen of Tarsus and from that point of view a member of 
the Greek world, his Roman citizenship overrode his Greek citizenship, and he had 
beyond all doubt been educated from infancy to understand his position as a Roman.<note n="8" id="iii.iii-p6.1">Much might be said on this subject; 
but it belongs to a study of Paul’s life, and the proofs are found at intervals 
throughout his career. The subject is touched upon several times in <i>St. Paul 
the Traveller,</i> e.g., pp. 30 f., 225, 315.</note> His point of view is clearly and emphatically Roman. Those who talk 
of Paul as a mere Jew are blinding themselves to his real position and to the character 
of the Graeco-Roman world in his time.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p7">But Luke’s point of view was not the same. Luke is throughout 
his work a Greek, never a Roman; and his statements must be estimated accordingly. 
Before criticizing, we must make sure that we understand rightly; and we shall never 
understand rightly, unless we begin by sympathizing with the writer and the tone 
of his work.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p8">Luke then speaks of things Roman as they appeared to a 
Greek. The Greeks never could quite understand Roman matters; even the mysteries 
of the Roman system of personal names were as puzzling to almost all Greeks as they 
are to a modern school boy or college student.<note n="9" id="iii.iii-p8.1">The difficulty of being accurate about 
Roman personal names might be illustrated plentifully even from the books of 
distinguished modern classical scholars, an unpleasant topic from which I refrain.</note> 
Hence, for example, in the remarkable scene at Paphos (<scripRef id="iii.iii-p8.2" passage="Acts 13:9" parsed="|Acts|13|9|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.13.9">Acts 
13:9</scripRef>), it is difficult to feel any confidence whether 
or not Paul disclosed himself to Sergius Paullus in 
his Roman character. If he did so, it is clear that his Roman name ought to be given. 
Strictly taken, Luke’s language at this point implies that Paul showed himself only 
as a Greek traveler and philosopher to the Roman proconsul; and, on the whole, this 
seems perhaps most probable. But that must be gathered from the career of Paul as 
a whole; and it would not be safe to infer it from the fact that Luke gives the 
alternative name in its Greeks not in its Roman form. Paul did not, perhaps, develop 
his idea of Christianity for the Roman empire quite so early.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p9">Luke, indeed, does not distinctly mark any further stage 
of development; but to Luke the great antithesis — Gentile and Jew — quite obliterated 
the lesser distinction between Roman citizen and Roman provincial, when the provincial 
was a Greek. What power lay in the Roman name, the thorough Greek never comprehended; 
and hence Luke has never disclosed to us the fact — which is beyond all doubt — 
that Paul had a Roman name. Had it been clearly present in the consciousness of 
all modern scholars that Paul must have been either Gaius Julius Paullus or something 
of that style, many things that have been said would have been better said, or left 
unsaid. Yet it is as certain as anything can be, that a Roman citizen necessarily 
had a Roman name, that Paul could not have revealed himself to the magistrates at 
Philippi or to Claudius Lysias, and that he could not have appealed to the emperor, 
except by virtue of his Roman name, which he must have stated openly.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p10">Owing to the failure of a Greek to comprehend Roman names 
and their importance, we have no clear record about this important side of Paul’s 
career. Luke sees him only in two aspects, as “Hebrew or Graeco Roman”: he never 
sees him as “Greek or Roman”.<note n="10" id="iii.iii-p10.1">I should now be inclined to modify 
lines 6, 12, 16 of <i>St. Paul the Traveller</i>, p. 83, so as to eliminate 
the word “Roman”. Except in those 143 lines, the scene is there described on 
Paul’s Greek side, as I think is right.</note></p>

<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p11">As a preparation for the study of Luke’s History, one ought 
to become familiar with the remains of the Greek used in the cities of the wider 
Greece,<note n="11" id="iii.iii-p11.1">Canon Hicks in <i>Classical Review</i>, 
1887, pp. 4, 42; Deissmann, <i>Bibelstudien</i>, 1895, and <i>Neue Bibelstudien</i>, 
1897. See also <i>Expository Times</i>, Oct., 1898, p. 9.</note> 
to understand as far as possible the ideas of the people among whom Luke grew up, 
and to appreciate the way in which they rendered or misrendered Roman things. We 
shall then begin to appreciate better Luke’s meaning and his standard as a historian. 
It is true that he regularly uses the popular phraseology, and not the strictly 
and technically accurate terms for Roman things;<note n="12" id="iii.iii-p11.2"><i>St. Paul the Traveller</i>, pp. 
30 f., 111, 135, 255, etc.</note> but he is decidedly more accurate in essentials than
the ordinary Greek, even the official Greek, of the Eastern 
cities. He never is guilty of the blunders that puzzle the epigraphist in Asian 
or Galatian inscriptions.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p12">It has often been remarked that Luke wrote for a public 
ignorant of Palestine, its customs and its language, and familiar with the surroundings 
of Graeco-Roman life in the great cities of the empire. He explains to his readers 
Semitic names and terms; he describes the situation of Nazareth and Capernaum as 
cities of Galilee, of Arimathea as a city of the Jews, of the country of the Gadarenes 
as over against Galilee, and he even tells the distance of the Mount of Olives and 
of Emmaus from Jerusalem.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p13">Now contrast with these explanations the allusions to the 
cities of the Greek and Italian lands. The fact that Syracuse and Puteoli and Rhegium 
are named without any geographical explanation might perhaps be explained from their 
fame and importance. Syracuse was one of the greatest Greek cities; Puteoli was 
the great harbor for passengers by the sea voyage to Rome from the East; and Rhegium 
was situated at a very striking point on the voyage. Similarly, while he explains 
the position of Philippi and Perga, Myra and Lystra, he assumes that the situation 
of Athens, of Corinth, and of Ephesus is familiar to his readers. He thinks that 
the coasts of the Aegean Sea need no explanation, or that the general character 
of the voyage sufficiently explains the position of Troas, Cos, Miletus, Caesarea 
and Ptolemais. The relation of Cenchreae to Corinth (<scripRef id="iii.iii-p13.1" passage="Acts 18:18" parsed="|Acts|18|18|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.18.18">Acts 
18:18</scripRef>) is also taken as familiar. But the most striking 
case occurs as the travelers approach Rome. The author assumes that the Market of 
Appius and the Three Taverns are familiar points on the road, which Paul must traverse 
between Puteoli and Rome. Instead of telling their distance from Rome, he uses them 
as actual measures of distance to show how far the brethren came forth from Rome 
to welcome Paul.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p14">Too much stress should not be laid on reasoning so slight 
as this. There is not enough of evidence to justify full confidence. But, so far 
as it goes, it suggests that Luke wrote for an audience which knew the environs 
of Rome and Corinth far more intimately than the country round Jerusalem and the 
Sea of Galilee. And, on the whole, it is on the great lines of communication leading 
from Syria and Asia to Rome that most knowledge is assumed.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p15">Further, Luke sometimes adapts incidents to the comprehension 
of his readers by expressing them in terms which, though not a literal description 
of the original facts, approximate to the general sense and are more readily intelligible 
to the Western reader. An excellent example of this is found in 
<scripRef id="iii.iii-p15.1" passage="Luke 5:17-20" parsed="|Luke|5|17|5|20" osisRef="Bible:Luke.5.17-Luke.5.20">Luke 5:17-20</scripRef>, as compared with <scripRef id="iii.iii-p15.2" passage="Mark 2:1-4" parsed="|Mark|2|1|2|4" osisRef="Bible:Mark.2.1-Mark.2.4">Mark 2:1-4</scripRef>.</p>
<p class="center" id="iii.iii-p16"><b><scripRef id="iii.iii-p16.1" passage="MARK 2:1-4" parsed="|Mark|2|1|2|4" osisRef="Bible:Mark.2.1-Mark.2.4">MARK 2:1-4</scripRef></b></p>

<div style="margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align:justify; margin-top:9pt" id="iii.iii-p16.2">
<p class="continue" id="iii.iii-p17">And when he entered again into 
Capernaum after some days, it was noised that he was in the house. And 
many were gathered together, so that there was no longer room for them, 
no, not even about the door · and he spake the word unto them. And they 
come, bringing unto him a man sick of the palsy, borne of four. And 
when they could not come nigh unto him for the crowd, they uncovered 
the roof where he was<note n="13" id="iii.iii-p17.1">Literally, “they unroofed the roof”.</note> and when they had broken it up, they let down the bed whereon 
the sick of the palsy lay.</p>
</div>
<p class="center" id="iii.iii-p18"><b><scripRef id="iii.iii-p18.1" passage="LUKE 5:17-20" parsed="|Luke|5|17|5|20" osisRef="Bible:Luke.5.17-Luke.5.20">LUKE 5:17-20</scripRef></b></p>
<div style="margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align:justify; margin-top:9pt" id="iii.iii-p18.2">
<p class="continue" id="iii.iii-p19">And it came to pass on one of 
those days, that he was teaching; and there were Pharisees and doctors 
of the law sitting by, which were come out of every village of Galilee 
and Judea and Jerusalem: and the power of the Lord was with him to 
heal. And behold, men bring on a bed a man that was palsied’ and they 
sought to bring him in, and to lay him before him. And not finding by 
what way they might bring him in because of the multitude, they went 
up to the house-top, and let him down through the tiles with his couch 
into the midst before Jesus.</p>
</div>

<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p20">Here it is obvious that Mark gives the incident in the 
more exact way. The house was a humble erection, with a flat roof of earth or other 
material, which was easily destroyed and as easily replaced. The bearers took advantage 
of this; mounting on the roof, they broke it up, and let down the couch through 
the hole which they thus made.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p21">A modern writer might have explained all this to his readers. 
But Luke, although he interprets a single Semitic word occasionally, would not spare 
time and space enough for a more elaborate description of details, which were, in 
his estimation, unimportant. His readers were familiar with a different kind of house, covered with tiles, and having a 
hole (<span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p21.1">impluvium</span>) in the roof of the principal chamber (<span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p21.2">atrium</span>), where 
the company would be assembled. To turn aside from his proper subject and describe 
differences of architecture would have distracted attention from the really important 
facts. As has been often pointed out,<note n="14" id="iii.iii-p21.3">e.g., <i>St. Paul the Traveller</i>, p. 17.</note> 
Luke never describes such features, but leaves his readers to imagine for themselves 
from their own knowledge the surroundings amid which his story was enacted.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p22">Accordingly, he preserves all the essential features — 
the dense crowd preventing access to the Master by the proper approach the taking 
of the bed with the sick man in it up on the roof the letting down of the bed through 
the roof before the Savior’s eyes. But he does not tell that the bearers broke a 
hole through the roof. A tiled roof, such as his readers were accustomed to, is 
strong; a hole cannot easily be made through it; and when it is broken, it is a 
long and expensive operation to repair it. It would seem unnatural that a hole should 
be violently made in such a roof; and Luke leaves his readers to apply their own 
knowledge, and to understand that the bearers let the man on his couch down through 
(the opening in) the tiles.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p23">Matthew, again, regards all these details about the manner 
of bringing the man as unimportant, and omits them. Corresponding to 
<scripRef id="iii.iii-p23.1" passage="Mark 2:2-4" parsed="|Mark|2|2|2|4" osisRef="Bible:Mark.2.2-Mark.2.4">Mark 2:2-4</scripRef> and <scripRef id="iii.iii-p23.2" passage="Luke 5:18, 19" parsed="|Luke|5|18|5|19" osisRef="Bible:Luke.5.18-Luke.5.19">Luke 5:18, 19</scripRef>, he has only these 
words, <scripRef passage="Luke 9:2" id="iii.iii-p23.3" parsed="|Luke|9|2|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.9.2">9:2</scripRef>:” And behold 
they brought him a man sick of the palsy, lying on 
a bed”. It was only the words and acts of the Master that he considered worthy of 
space. Luke and Mark and Matthew all say that Jesus, “seeing their faith,” told 
the man that his sins were forgiven. He saw that the man had the same “faith able 
to receive cure and salvation” as the lame man at Lystra, 
<scripRef id="iii.iii-p23.4" passage="Acts 14" parsed="|Acts|14|0|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.14">Acts 14</scripRef>. But Luke and Mark explain 
how the special circumstances made evident the faith of the bearers and the man, 
while Matthew leaves the reader to gather from Jesus’ words, that he saw some special 
evidence of faith in the case before him, Matthew relates the story as one long 
familiar; and it would not be thoroughly intelligible to us without the proof of 
eager faith which Luke and Mark relate. The latter stand on an earlier stage than 
Matthew.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p24">We notice that Luke’s account here is not suited to a Greek 
house, but only to a Roman house. The Greek house was of totally different construction from the Roman; and, if Luke had been writing 
primarily for a public resident in the great Greek cities of the Aegean lands, he 
would probably have either related the incident in its original Palestinian form, 
or imparted to it a turn that would suit the style of house usual in those cities. 
It happens, fortunately, that we can illustrate and prove this point by a series 
of analogous cases.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p25">The Roman comic dramatists, Plautus and Terence, adapted 
Greek plays to the Roman stage, modifying the plot and incidents in some respects 
to suit the tastes and the knowledge of a Roman audience. When some incident in 
the Greek play turned on a peculiarity in the structure of a Greek house, the Roman 
playwright often modified the facts, so as to suit the style of house that was familiar 
to his audience. Thus, a Greek dramatist wrote a play called “The Braggart,” in 
which the relation between two lovers is discovered by a slave resident in the neighboring 
house. In adapting this play, Plautus describes this discovery in the form that 
the slave, pursuing an ape which had escaped from his master’s house, clambered 
over the roof of the <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p25.1">atrium</span> of his neighbor’s house, and in this way was 
able to look through the hole in the roof or <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p25.2">impluvium</span> into the <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p25.3">atrium</span>, 
and saw the lovers sitting side by side.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p26">As Lorenz has observed,<note n="15" id="iii.iii-p26.1">See the introduction to his edition 
of Plautus, <i>Miles Gloriosus</i>, p. 11.</note> this could not have been the form which the incident had in the original Greek play. 
The Greek house had no <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p26.2">atrium</span> with its <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p26.3">impluvium</span>, 
nor anything corresponding to it. The ordinary house in the Greek cities contained 
an open court or <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p26.4">aula</span>, to which access was gained by a passage leading from 
the front door. This court was surrounded, sometimes simply by the house walls, 
sometimes by a narrow stoa or portico,<note n="16" id="iii.iii-p26.5">In that case the court was called
<span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p26.6">peristylium</span>.</note> resting on the house walls and supported inside by columns. The covered chambers 
of the house opened off the back of this court, and the part of the mansion which 
contained these chambers was usually of one or, at most, two stories and covered 
by a flat roof. As the houses in these Greek cities were usually built close together, 
divided from one another by the house wall (which was common to both), it was easy 
to look from the flat roof (or from the windows of the upper story) of one house 
into the court of the next; and thus the slave in the Greek play saw the lovers 
in the <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p26.7">aula</span> of the neighboring house. In this same way Thekla at Iconium 
sat at a window in the house of her mother Theokleia, and heard Paul preaching in the court of the house of Onesiphorus, her 
neighbor. See
note 2 at the end of this chapter.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p27">Luke uses even the Roman form of expression. The regular 
term for “the roof” (regarded from the outside) was in Latin “the tiles”;<note n="17" id="iii.iii-p27.1"><i>Tegulae</i>: see Brix’s note on 
Plautus, <i>Miles Gloriosus</i>, 156.</note> but in Greek the collective singular form “the tiling” was 
used.<note n="18" id="iii.iii-p27.2"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iii-p27.3">κέραμος</span>: 
see Pollux, 7., 162; Aristophanes, <i>Clouds</i>, 1127; Thucydides, 2., 4, etc.</note> 
Luke speaks after the Roman fashion, and says that they let the sick man down “through 
the tiles” (<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iii-p27.4">διὰ τῶν κεράμων</span>). by which he implies the roof of Roman style. 
In a similar way, Terence in the Phormio, 707, speaks of a snake as having “fallen 
from the tiles (i.e., the roof) through the <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p27.5">impluvium</span>,” expressing the same 
meaning in a fuller way.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p28">In a review in the <i>Theologische Litteraturzeitung</i>, 
1897, p. 534, Dr. Johannes Weiss says: “When Mark writes ‘they uncovered the roof, 
and when they had broken it up, they let down the bed, ’ but Luke on the other hand 
says ‘they let him down through the tiles, ’ the former thinks of the Palestinian 
style of building, while the latter thinks of the roof of the Graeco-Roman house”. 
This expresses practically the same view which has been advocated in the preceding 
pages, but the word Graeco-Roman seems to require modification. Luke writes with 
a view to the Roman house alone; and his language would not suit the Greek style 
of house.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p29">Luke must have adapted his expression to suit either a 
circle of readers, or more probably the single reader, Theophilus, for whose instruction 
he composed his History; and, in giving to his narrative the form seen in 
<scripRef passage="Luke 5:20" id="iii.iii-p29.1" parsed="|Luke|5|20|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.5.20">5:20</scripRef>, he evidently felt that 
Theophilus was used to the Roman and not the Greek 
house architecture. Taking this in conjunction with the use made of the Market of 
Appius and the Three Taverns, we find a distinct probability that Theophilus was 
a citizen of Rome.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p30">Moreover, Theophilus is addressed by an epithet,<note n="19" id="iii.iii-p30.1"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iii-p30.2">κράτιστος</span> 
See Note 1 at the end of chapter 3.</note> which, under the empire, was peculiarly appropriated to Romans of high rank, and 
which became during the second century a technical title indicating equestrian (as 
distinguished from senatorial) rank. Examples are numerous in the Imperial Greek 
inscriptions; and those who have made themselves familiar with the usages of Roman 
and provincial life under the empire, will recognize the high probability that Luke 
uses this adjective in <scripRef passage="Luke 1:4" id="iii.iii-p30.3" parsed="|Luke|1|4|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.4">1:4</scripRef>,  
as in every other place (<scripRef id="iii.iii-p30.4" passage="Acts 23:26" parsed="|Acts|23|26|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.23.26">Acts 23:26</scripRef>, <scripRef passage="Acts 24:3" id="iii.iii-p30.5" parsed="|Acts|24|3|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.24.3">24:3</scripRef> 
and <scripRef passage="Acts 26:25" id="iii.iii-p30.6" parsed="|Acts|26|25|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.26.25">26:25</scripRef>)<note n="20" id="iii.iii-p30.7">See Note l at end of chapter 3.</note> to indicate the official (probably equestrian) rank of the person to whom he applies it.</p>

<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p31">Luke, then, was adapting the form of his narrative either 
to a single Roman or to a Roman circle of readers. The frequency and emphasis with 
which he mentions matters that are specifically Roman must impress every reader.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p32">In regard to Roman officials of high rank, the favorable 
judgment which they always pass on Christ and on his followers is so marked a feature 
of Luke’s work, that it must have been prominent before his mind.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p33">Luke mentions formally the charge which the Jews vainly 
made, that Jesus had been guilty of disloyalty and treason against the Roman emperor,
<scripRef passage="Luke 23:2" id="iii.iii-p33.1" parsed="|Luke|23|2|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.23.2">23:2</scripRef>. John mentions it 
very informally (<scripRef id="iii.iii-p33.2" passage="John 18:30" parsed="|John|18|30|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.18.30">John 18:30</scripRef>).<note n="21" id="iii.iii-p33.3">“If this man were not an evildoer, 
we should not have delivered him up unto thee”.</note> Matthew and Mark are silent about the nature of the 
charge. Luke records the thrice repeated judgment of Pilate acquitting Jesus of 
all fault before the Roman law; John mentions the acquittal once in similar terms; 
Matthew represents Pilate as disclaiming all responsibility for his death, but not 
as formally pronouncing him innocent of all fault.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p34">In Luke’s Second Book this feature is still more marked. 
The Imperial officers stand between Paul and the Jews to save him from them. The 
Proconsul of Cyprus was almost converted to Christianity. The Proconsul of Achaia 
dismissed the Jews’ case against him as groundless before the law. Festus, the Procurator 
of Palestine, found in Paul nothing worthy of death — he had difficulty in discovering 
any definite charge against him, which he could report in sending him up to the 
supreme court of the empire. Even Felix, another Procurator, one of the worst of 
Roman officials, was affected by Paul’s teaching, and to some extent protected him, 
and did not condemn him, though to please the Jews he left him in prison.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p35">Among inferior Roman officials, Claudius Lysias, Julius, 
Cornelius, even the jailer in the colony of Philippi, were friendly to the Christians, 
or actually joined them. In the few cases in which the magistrates of a Roman colony 
took action against Paul, their action is shown to have been in error (as at Philippi), 
or is passed over in silence and the blame is laid on the jealousy and hatred of 
the Jews (as at Pisidian Antioch and Lystra). The praetors of Philippi scourged 
Paul, but they apologized, and confessed they had been in the wrong. The magistrates 
of the Greek cities, like Iconium, Thessalonica and 
Athens, were far more severe against Paul than those of Roman colonies.<note n="22" id="iii.iii-p35.1">The subject of this paragraph is 
more fully treated in <i>St. Paul the Traveller</i>, p. 304 ff.</note></p>

<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p36">Even the publicans, those hated instruments of a taxation 
after the Jewish and Romanising style, are far more kindly treated by Luke than 
by Matthew or Mark. Compare, for example, the “publicans and sinners” in the house 
of Levi or Matthew. Both Mark and Matthew designate the company by this name; but 
Luke calls them “publicans and others,” and confines the more opprobrious phrase 
to the mouth of the scribes (<scripRef id="iii.iii-p36.1" passage="Matthew 9:10" parsed="|Matt|9|10|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Matt.9.10">Matthew 9:10</scripRef>; <scripRef id="iii.iii-p36.2" passage="Mark 2:15" parsed="|Mark|2|15|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Mark.2.15">Mark 2:15</scripRef>; <scripRef id="iii.iii-p36.3" passage="Luke 5:29" parsed="|Luke|5|29|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.5.29">Luke 5:29</scripRef>, 
cp. <scripRef passage="Luke 7:34" id="iii.iii-p36.4" parsed="|Luke|7|34|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.7.34">7:34</scripRef>). Luke alone sets the publican and the Pharisee 
over against one another as good and bad types, <scripRef passage="Luke 18:10" id="iii.iii-p36.5" parsed="|Luke|18|10|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.18.10">18:10</scripRef>. It is true that several sayings of Christ in favor 
of publicans are given also by Matthew and Mark; they were too characteristic to 
be omitted; but Luke has more of them.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p37">It is not unconnected with this character in his work that 
Luke records with special interest the acts and words of Christ implying that the 
Gospel was as open to the Gentiles as to the Jews. Similar examples are found in 
all the Gospels, because no one who gave a fair account of the teaching of Christ 
could omit them; but in Luke they are more numerous and more emphatic.<note n="23" id="iii.iii-p37.1">Alford quotes <scripRef passage="Luke 4:25-27" id="iii.iii-p37.2" parsed="|Luke|4|25|4|27" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.25-Luke.4.27">4:25-27</scripRef>, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 9:52-56" id="iii.iii-p37.3" parsed="|Luke|9|52|9|56" osisRef="Bible:Luke.9.52-Luke.9.56">9:52-56</scripRef>, <scripRef passage="Luke 10:33" id="iii.iii-p37.4" parsed="|Luke|10|33|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.10.33">10:33</scripRef>, <scripRef passage="Luke 15:11-12" id="iii.iii-p37.5" parsed="|Luke|15|11|15|12" osisRef="Bible:Luke.15.11-Luke.15.12">15:11 ff.</scripRef>, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 17:16-18" id="iii.iii-p37.6" parsed="|Luke|17|16|17|18" osisRef="Bible:Luke.17.16-Luke.17.18">17:16-18</scripRef>, <scripRef passage="Luke 18:10-12" id="iii.iii-p37.7" parsed="|Luke|18|10|18|12" osisRef="Bible:Luke.18.10-Luke.18.12">18:10 ff.</scripRef>, <scripRef passage="Luke 19:5,9" id="iii.iii-p37.8" parsed="|Luke|19|5|0|0;|Luke|19|9|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.19.5 Bible:Luke.19.9">19:5,9</scripRef>.</note></p>

<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p38">It has been, however, pointed out, as a proof that such 
examples cannot be relied on, that Luke omits entirely the story of the Savior’s 
visit to Phoenicia, including the case of the Syrophoenician woman whose great faith 
was commended. But in that story occurs the saying, “I was not sent but unto the 
lost sheep of the house of Israel,” <scripRef id="iii.iii-p38.1" passage="Matthew 15:24" parsed="|Matt|15|24|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Matt.15.24">Matthew 15:24</scripRef>; 
and in view of such sayings as Luke — and Luke alone — records in 
<scripRef passage="Luke 4:25-27" id="iii.iii-p38.2" parsed="|Luke|4|25|4|27" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.25-Luke.4.27">4:25-27</scripRef> (see <scripRef id="iii.iii-p38.3" passage="Luke 24:47" parsed="|Luke|24|47|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.24.47">Luke 24:47</scripRef> paralleled by 
<scripRef id="iii.iii-p38.4" passage="Matthew 28:19" parsed="|Matt|28|19|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Matt.28.19">Matthew 28:19</scripRef>, and <scripRef id="iii.iii-p38.5" passage="Mark 16:15" parsed="|Mark|16|15|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Mark.16.15">Mark 16:15</scripRef>), the historian 
might doubt whether the incident was not likely to give a mistaken impression of 
the Savior’s mission. As to the passing in silence over a visit to Phoenicia, it 
is pointed out below,<note n="24" id="iii.iii-p38.6">See Chapter 10 ff.</note> that Luke deliberately refrains from describing the journeys and movements of Christ.</p>

<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p39">It is, therefore, plain on the face of Luke’s History, 
that he has taken pains to connect his narrative with the general history of the 
empire, and that he has noted with special care the relations between the new religion 
and the Roman state or its officials. Elsewhere I have tried to show that Luke thought 
of his work, from one point of view, as “an appeal to the truth of history against the immoral and ruinous policy of the 
reigning emperor; a temperate and solemn record by one who had played a great part 
in them of the real facts regarding the formation of the Church, its steady and 
unswerving loyalty in the past, its firm resolve to accept the existing Imperial 
government, its friendly reception by many Romans, and its triumphant vindication 
in the first great trial at Rome. The book was the work of one who had been trained 
by Paul to look forward to Christianity becoming the religion of the empire and 
of the world, who regarded Christianity as destined not to destroy but to recreate 
the empire.<note n="25" id="iii.iii-p39.1"><i>St. Paul the Traveller</i>, p. 309 f.</note></p>

<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p40">In such circumstances it is obvious that the historian 
was bound to be specially careful that his references to matters of Roman history, 
and especially his first reference — the subject of this study — were accurate. 
But the accusation which we have to meet is that it grossly misrepresented the character 
of Roman procedure, and was inaccurate in fact. If the accusation is right, any 
Roman citizen who possessed even a small knowledge of the facts of administration 
must have seen the gross inaccuracy at a glance. How, then, does it happen that, 
while the circumstances of the birth of Christ were closely scrutinized by the opponents 
of Christianity and subjected to much misrepresentation and many charges of falsification, 
no one in Roman times seems ever to have discovered the inaccuracies which many 
modern inquirers imagine to themselves?</p>

<hr />
<p class="center" id="iii.iii-p41"><b>NOTE 1</b></p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p42">Professor Blass in his welcome book, <i>Philology</i> of 
the Gospels, 1898, p. 19, declares that the epithet <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iii-p42.1">κράτιστος</span> 
in Luke’s language, had no such force as we find in it, but was merely “the ordinary 
one in epistolary and oratorical style, when the person addressed was in a somewhat 
exalted position”. As examples, he quotes Paul’s address to Felix and Festus, who 
were both Roman officials of equestrian rank! These are two of the many instances 
on which the proof rests that the title was peculiarly appropriated at that period 
to Romans of rank. The same scholar refers, further, to the examples quoted by Otto 
in his edition of the <i>Epistle to Diognetus</i>, p. 79 ff. (53 ff.). I cannot 
consult this book, but Otto considers that Diognetus was the philosopher, the friend 
and teacher of Marcus Aurelius, and the emperor might well raise his teacher to 
equestrian rank, as Septimius Severus raised Antipater, 
the teacher of his sons, to the much higher dignity of the consulship; and, if Otto’s 
identification be accepted, we may regard the epithet as a proof that Diognetus 
was honored by his imperial pupil Galen<note n="26" id="iii.iii-p42.2"><i>De libr. suis</i> (Kuhn, vol. 19.).</note> 
addresses <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iii-p42.3">κράτιστε Βάσσε</span>, 
also a Roman of rank. Longinus addresses Postumius Terentianus, Plutarch speaks 
of Fundanus, and Artemidorus of Cassius Maximus by the same epithet, in all cases 
undoubtedly employing it in the technical imperial sense. Epaphroditus, to whom 
Josephus dedicated his <i>Jewish Antiquities</i> and <i>Life</i>, is a more doubtful 
case; but the dedication implies that he was a man of influence in Rome, and though 
obviously a freedman (on account of his name), he probably had been honored with 
equestrian rank by his imperial patron. The Aphrodisius whom Galen addresses as <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iii-p42.4">κράτιστε</span> and
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iii-p42.5">φίλτατε</span> 
in his Prognost. (Kuhn, vol. 19), is also uncertain; Galen, however, lived amid 
high society in Rome.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p43">I have always conceded that Greeks were not invariably 
accurate in using Latin titles and technical terms, such as <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p43.1">optimus</span> (translated
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iii-p43.2">κράτιστος</span>); but the above examples show how often the technical and accurate 
sense is found in Greek. But Professor Blass has his mind so fixed on Greek literature, 
of which he is one of the first exponents in Europe, that he sometimes omits to 
notice Roman facts.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p44">The usage in Theophrastus, of course, lies apart from our 
subject and belongs to an earlier period of society. Even Horace’s <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iii.iii-p44.1">optimus</span>, 
used of Octavius and Quinctius, is pre-imperial, though both men were persons of 
rank in Rome, and therefore conform to our rule.</p>
<p class="center" id="iii.iii-p45"><b>NOTE 2</b></p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iii-p46">In the Acts of Paul and Thekla Paul was preaching in the 
house of Onesiphorus <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iii-p46.1">ἐν μέσῳ τῆς ἐκκλησίας</span> (or without the last two words): 
is the last word a later alteration of the original<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iii-p46.2">αὐλῆς</span>? In the Armenian version Paul preached in the 
house of Onesiphorus in a great assembly, and Thekla sat at a window which was close 
to their roof.</p>



</div2>

      <div2 title="Chapter 4. Importance in Luke’s History of the Story of the Birth of Christ" progress="27.41%" id="iii.iv" prev="iii.iii" next="iv">


<h3 id="iii.iv-p0.1">CHAPTER 4 <br />
IMPORTANCE IN LUKE’S HISTORY OF THE STORY OF THE BIRTH OF CHRIST</h3>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p1">IT needs no proof that Luke attached the highest importance 
to this part of his narrative. That Jesus was indicated from the beginning as the 
Messiah — though not a necessary part of his life and work, and wholly omitted by 
Mark and only briefly indicated in mystical language by John — was a highly interesting 
and important fact in itself, and could not fail to impress the historian. The elaboration 
and detail of the first two chapters of the Gospel form a sufficient proof that 
Luke recognized the importance of the central incident in them.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p2">Further, the author must have regarded this part of his 
work with special interest, and been impelled to work it up with peculiar care, 
on account of the authority on which it rested; and he takes some pains to show 
his reader what was the authority.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p3">The beautifully told story of 
<scripRef passage="Luke 1:-1-2:52" id="iii.iv-p3.1">Luke 1, 2</scripRef>, is an episode of family 
history of the most private character. The facts could be known only to a very small 
number of persons. If Luke had the slightest trace of historical instinct, he must 
have satisfied himself that the narrative which he gives rested on the evidence 
of one of the few persons to whom the facts could be known. It is not in keeping 
with the ancient style that he should formally name his authority; but he does not 
leave it doubtful whose authority he believed himself to have. “His mother kept 
all these sayings hid in her heart;” “Mary kept all these sayings, pondering them 
in her heart;” (<scripRef id="iii.iv-p3.2" passage="Luke 2:19" parsed="|Luke|2|19|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.19">Luke 2:19</scripRef> 
and <scripRef passage="Luke 2:51" id="iii.iv-p3.3" parsed="|Luke|2|51|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.51">51</scripRef>) those two sentences 
would be sufficient. The historian who wrote like that believed that he had the 
authority of the Mother herself.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p4">But those two sentences are not the only indications of 
the source whence Luke believed his information to come. Some facts intimately concerning 
Elizabeth are mentioned in <scripRef passage="Luke 1:24" id="iii.iv-p4.1" parsed="|Luke|1|24|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.24">1:24</scripRef> 
and <scripRef passage="Luke 1:41" id="iii.iv-p4.2" parsed="|Luke|1|41|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.41">41</scripRef>; and the narrative 
carefully explains how these facts became known to Mary, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 1:36" id="iii.iv-p4.3" parsed="|Luke|1|36|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.36">1:36</scripRef> and <scripRef passage="Luke 1:41" id="iii.iv-p4.4" parsed="|Luke|1|41|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.41">41</scripRef> she had been told. But it 
is never stated that facts intimately concerning Mary were mentioned by her to Elizabeth. 
The narrative has the form which is natural only if 
Mary is understood to be the authority throughout: she simply states what concerned 
herself, while, in what concerned Elizabeth, she not merely states the facts, but 
also explains that she has first-hand authority.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p5">Moreover, what concerned Mary is expressly said to have 
remained secret, known to herself alone and pondered over in her own heart. It would 
be a contradiction that this secret of her heart should be the property of others 
to tell about her. The historian, by emphasizing the silence and secrecy in which 
she treasured up the facts, gives the reader to understand that she is the authority.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p6">It is a different thing when we read, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 1:65-66" id="iii.iv-p6.1" parsed="|Luke|1|65|1|66" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.65-Luke.1.66">1:65 f.</scripRef>, “these sayings were 
noised abroad throughout all the hill country of Judea. And all that heard them 
laid them up in their hearts, saying, <i>What then shall this child be?</i>” There 
a subject of notoriety, which deeply impressed the whole district, is referred to. 
What is known to many is no secret, and in fact is expressly said to have been a 
topic of conversation through the country.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p7">The people in the hill country of Judea knew about the 
marvelous circumstances of John’s birth, and talked about it, and wondered. But 
at Nazareth nothing was generally known. Jesus had been born far away. His parents 
brought him to Nazareth after some time had elapsed. Even after Herod’s death his 
shadow lay heavy on the land; and the parents, being subjects of his son Antipas, 
were not likely to talk to their neighbors about the old king’s relations to the 
child and about the prophecies of Simeon and Anna apart from the consideration that 
the whole subject must have seemed too sacred for gossip. Mary did not herself comprehend 
the things that had occurred. She kept them hid in her heart, and apparently did 
not even tell her husband what was in her mind. This child was not to be an unalloyed 
delight either to her country or herself; he was “set for the falling and rising 
up of many in Israel, and for a sign which is spoken against”; and for herself, 
“a sword should pierce through her own soul”. It was a dread and vague future about 
which she pondered in the depths of her own mind, as “the child grew and waxed strong, 
filled with wisdom”. In that marvelous picture, sketched in such simple and brief 
terms, only he that deliberately shuts his mind against all literary feeling can 
fail to catch the tone of a mother’s heart.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p8">In the description of the early days of John and of Jesus 
the reader notices the woman’s and the mother’s feeling, watching the growth of 
the two children, to whom and through whom so much had been promised. As to John, 
“the child grew and waxed strong and was in the wilderness (of Judah, the remote 
country of his birth) till the day of his showing unto Israel”. But about her own 
son there is an added touch of warmth,</p>
<div style="margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align:justify; margin-top:9pt" id="iii.iv-p8.1">

<p class="continue" id="iii.iv-p9">“the child grew and waxed strong, 
filled with wisdom; and the grace of God was upon him” (<scripRef id="iii.iv-p9.1" passage="Luke 1:80" parsed="|Luke|1|80|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.80">Luke 
1:80</scripRef>, <scripRef passage="Luke 2:40" id="iii.iv-p9.2" parsed="|Luke|2|40|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.40">2:40</scripRef>).</p>
</div>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p10">No one who judges on the ordinary canons of criticism which 
govern the interpretation of ancient literature, can doubt that it is through design, 
and not by accident, that there occur in the opening chapters of Luke’s History 
all these little touches, indicating so delicately and so skillfully what authority 
he had to depend upon in the beginning of his narrative. This is specially clear 
when we remember the declaration made by the author in his preface, that he had 
investigated from their origin the facts which he is going to narrate. After such 
a preface, and with all the indications in the narrative, it is plain that the historian 
either believed his statements to be based on the authority of the Virgin Mary herself, 
or has deliberately tried to create a false impression that such was the case. Is 
it a rational supposition, is it psychologically possible, that any man who was 
impressed with the sacredness of the subject which he is treating should intentionally 
found his narrative upon such a falsehood as this would be?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p11">Understanding that Mary herself is the authority to whom 
Luke appeals, we find that the passage becomes clearer, both as to what it states 
and what it omits.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p12">The origin of the narrative may possibly explain why Luke 
and Matthew give such different accounts of the circumstances of the birth of Christ. 
Matthew gives the public account, that which was generally known during the Savior’s 
life and after his death; and popular belief has always some tendency to transform 
and adapt to moral purposes facts that are much talked about. Luke gives from knowledge 
gained within the family an account of facts known only to the family, and in part 
to the Mother alone.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p13">It is most probable that Luke had heard the story which 
Matthew gives, and it would have been easy to fit this into his own narrative without 
disturbing either account. But they did not rest on equal authority; and Luke would 
not mix the two. What he had got was an account of the miraculous birth and of the 
circumstances which had most deeply impressed the Mother’s mind with regard to the 
origin and mission of her Child, while it was rather the relations of the Child 
to the old king that had impressed themselves on the imagination of his followers. 
In them Matthew read a fulfillment of prophecies about the Messiah. But they had 
not similarly affected Mary’s mind, and they were not among the facts which she 
pondered over in her heart as pledges of the great future that lay before this little 
Child.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p14">Luke therefore confined himself to what he had on the highest 
authority. So much he states in full detail; and the rest of the first twelve years 
of Jesus’ life he sums up in the brief expression, <scripRef id="iii.iv-p14.1" passage="2:40" parsed="|Luke|2|40|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.40">2:40</scripRef>: “He was filled with wisdom and the grace of 
God was upon him”. Then came a remarkable instance of the young Boy’s awakening 
consciousness of his own mission. He had been brought up by his Mother to think 
of Joseph as his father; but suddenly he declared to her that his Father’s business 
lay in a different direction. Here, again, there was something for the Mother’s 
heart to ponder over, while her Son went on once more in the natural development 
of a boy, “increasing in wisdom and stature and in favor with God and man”.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p15">We can argue, then, with perfect confidence that Luke did 
not take the narrative of the birth and childhood of Christ from mere current talk 
and general belief: he had it in a form for which Mary herself was in his opinion 
the responsible authority. What, then, was this form? It must have been either written 
narrative or oral communication.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p16">If it were written, the writer must have been either Mary 
herself or some one who recorded her story so carefully and faithfully as to leave 
full expression to Mary’s own feelings.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p17">That Mary herself wrote it seems highly improbable. We 
should not expect that she had the literary interest or skill which might lead her 
to wish to perpetuate the facts in her own formal narrative: it is more probable, 
considering the circumstances of her position in youth, that she would lack the power of setting down a story in written expression 
with such rare art as to have the appearance of being perfectly natural, even though 
she would be able to tell it well orally in simple, natural, unstudied words. Moreover, 
it seems improbable that she should desire of her own self to make public the facts 
which she had kept so long hid in her heart. It is more natural to think that she 
hardly ever spoke of them, except to the rare individuals whose sympathy drew her 
on. The language, too, has a tone and character that do not suggest a formal autobiographical 
narrative. It seems, if I may venture to express my individual opinion, to be one 
of those which lose from being recited in public; it is one to be read alone or 
in the company of some perfectly sympathetic person, but which suffers from the 
presence of any one who is not in perfect sympathy. It expresses the heart of Mary; 
but in the form in which it was expressed to a sympathetic heart, and not as prepared 
for publication.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p18">It is more easily conceivable that some third person, intimate 
with Mary and recognizing the importance of having an authoritative narrative of 
these events, should have given literary form to an account coming direct from her 
own lips. But this account must have been either a part of a complete life of Christ 
one of those which Luke refers to in his preface, <scripRef passage="Luke 1:1" id="iii.iv-p18.1" parsed="|Luke|1|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.1">1:1</scripRef>, “repeated<note n="27" id="iii.iv-p18.2">On the sense of <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iv-p18.3">ἀνατάξασθαι</span> 
see Blass, <i>Philology of the Gospels</i>, 1898, p. 14 f.</note> according as they who were from the 
beginning eyewitnesses or the word delivered the tradition” — or an independent narrative, 
ranking with the authority of origin from Mary, and describing just so much as she 
was best able to tell.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p19">The existence of such an independent narrative, and the 
utter oblivion into which it fell, if it ever existed, seem alike most improbable. 
Moreover, suppose, for example, the author who gave it literary form to have been 
John, in whose house she lived from the crucifixion till her death, we must suppose 
that her words have passed through the modifying influence of John’s mind; thereafter 
John’s words have passed through the modifying influence of Luke’s mind; and yet, 
after all this, they continue to show clear and fresh the marks of their origin. 
The narrative seems not to have passed through so many stages.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p20">Further, the earliest followers of Christ seem to have 
been so entirely occupied with his engrossing personality that they thought little 
or not at all about his Mother. She hardly appears in three of the four Gospels.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p21">Matthew tells the story of the birth of her son in such 
a way that Joseph is the prominent person, and Mary a mere adjunct. On the few occasions 
on which she appears directly or indirectly, in Matthew and in Mark “there is a 
sound of reproof in the words” which Christ uses to her or of her: 
<scripRef id="iii.iv-p21.1" passage="Matthew 12:46" parsed="|Matt|12|46|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Matt.12.46">Matthew 12:46</scripRef>, <scripRef passage="Matthew 13:56-57" id="iii.iv-p21.2" parsed="|Matt|13|56|13|57" osisRef="Bible:Matt.13.56-Matt.13.57">13:56 f.</scripRef>,
<scripRef passage="Mark 3:33-3" id="iii.iv-p21.3" parsed="|Mark|3|33|3|3" osisRef="Bible:Mark.3.33-Mark.3.3">Mark 3:31 ff.</scripRef>, <scripRef passage="Matthew 6:3-4" id="iii.iv-p21.4" parsed="|Matt|6|3|6|4" osisRef="Bible:Matt.6.3-Matt.6.4">Matthew 6:3 f.</scripRef> They do 
not mention her among the women who watched in sorrow at the crucifixion. It has 
been suggested that they omitted her name in this scene, because it was obvious 
that she would be there; but no ordinary reader of these two Gospels would gather 
from them that this was obvious.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p22">The tone which John’s references to her convey depends 
mainly on the interpretation of <scripRef id="iii.iv-p22.1" passage="John 2:4" parsed="|John|2|4|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.2.4">John 2:4</scripRef>. 
There the Savior says to her, according to the almost universal interpretation, 
“Woman, what have I to do with thee?” (<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iv-p22.2">τί ἐμοὶ καὶ σοί, γύναι</span>) in a tone of reproof and almost 
(it might appear) of dislike, as is seen in the illustrative cases which are usually 
quoted <scripRef passage="Matthew 17:19" id="iii.iv-p22.3" parsed="|Matt|17|19|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Matt.17.19">Matthew 17:19</scripRef>, <scripRef passage="2Samuel 16:10" id="iii.iv-p22.4" parsed="|2Sam|16|10|0|0" osisRef="Bible:2Sam.16.10">2 Samuel 16:10</scripRef>, 
<scripRef passage="1Kings 17:18" id="iii.iv-p22.5" parsed="|1Kgs|17|18|0|0" osisRef="Bible:1Kgs.17.18">1 Kings 17:18</scripRef>, <scripRef passage="2Chronicles 35:21" id="iii.iv-p22.6" parsed="|2Chr|35|21|0|0" osisRef="Bible:2Chr.35.21">2 Chronicles 35:21</scripRef> and 
<scripRef id="iii.iv-p22.7" passage="Judges 11:12" parsed="|Judg|11|12|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Judg.11.12">Judges 11:12</scripRef>. 
Is this the tone of the only information that John gives about the woman who lived 
in his house from the day of the crucifixion till her death? The more one thinks 
of it, the more one hopes that Luther was right when he desired to take the meaning, 
“what is that to me and to thee?”<note n="28" id="iii.iv-p22.8">Dr. E. Nestle in the <i>Expository 
Times</i>, 1898, p. 332.</note> The old Egyptian poet of the fourth or fifth century, Nonnus, understood the words 
in that way, for he slightly varies them in his metrical paraphrase, reading 
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iv-p22.9">τί ἐμοί</span>, <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iv-p22.10">
γύναι</span>, <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iv-p22.11">ἠὲ σοὶ αὐτῇ</span>; 
Professor Blass considers that Nonnus had before him a MS. of the fourth Gospel 
in which <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iv-p22.12">ἣ</span> 
was read where all now existing MSS. have <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iv-p22.13">καὶ</span>, 
and argues that we should replace <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iii.iv-p22.14">ἣ</span> 
in the text. We should rather suppose that Nonnus (and probably the whole Asian 
circle for whom the fourth Gospel was primarily intended) understood the accepted 
text in the same sense as Luther advocated.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p23">In all that part of Luke’s History which is parallel with 
the common tradition in Matthew and Mark, he mentions Mary only in the same way 
as they do, and gives no more information about her than they have; and like them, 
he does not mention her presence at the crucifixion. The only additional allusion 
to her that he gives in the main body of his narrative, is contained in the words 
of an unnamed woman, blessing her who had given birth to such a son as Jesus (<scripRef id="iii.iv-p23.1" passage="Luke 11:27" parsed="|Luke|11|27|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.11.27">Luke 
11:27</scripRef>) Accordingly, considering the interest which 
Luke shows in Mary in the beginning of the Gospel, and in
<scripRef id="iii.iv-p23.2" passage="Acts 1:14" parsed="|Acts|1|14|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.1.14">Acts 1:14</scripRef>, where she is mentioned 
as being in steadfast companionship with the Apostles, 
it seems probable that the written authorities which he had before him told the 
story of the Savior without referring except in the most casual way to his Mother.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p24">It, therefore, seems unlikely that the first two chapters 
of Luke depend on an older written narrative. The quality in them is too simple 
and natural, they give too much of the nature of Mary expressed with the art of 
Luke, to have passed through the mind of an intermediate writer. And it is difficult 
to think that any such composition either could have existed in Luke’s time, or 
would have disappeared without leaving a trace behind, if it had existed.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p25">This result is diametrically opposite to the prevailing 
opinion. It is generally assumed as specially clear, that we have in the narrative 
of the birth and childhood of Jesus a translation from an Aramaic narrative or from 
a series of Aramaic narratives. Instead of seeing evidence of Luke’s literary power 
in the variations of style in different parts of his history, many scholars see 
only evidence of difference in documentary authority. As if the person who wrote 
the preface <scripRef passage="Luke 1:1-4" id="iii.iv-p25.1" parsed="|Luke|1|1|1|4" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.1-Luke.1.4">1:1-4</scripRef> could 
be blind to the complete change in style between <scripRef passage="Luke 1:4" id="iii.iv-p25.2" parsed="|Luke|1|4|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.4">1:4</scripRef> and 
<scripRef passage="Luke 1:5" id="iii.iv-p25.3" parsed="|Luke|1|5|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.5">1:5</scripRef>! Or as if he were unable to put the story into his own Greek, if he desired. It is 
clear as noon-day that the author deliberately aims at the contrast in style between
<scripRef passage="Luke 1:1-4" id="iii.iv-p25.4" parsed="|Luke|1|1|1|4" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.1-Luke.1.4">1:1-4</scripRef> and the following verses.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p26">But that there must be a number of separate documents underlying 
the narrative of 1 and 2, which Luke translated, seems an even more objectionable 
idea. Because there are three distinct statements about the growth of John, of the 
infant Jesus, and of the boy Jesus, it is assumed by some writers that these form 
the conclusions of separate documents. The slight but significant differences between 
them, in which I see evidence at once of literary art and of the natural motherly 
feeling of Mary, are treated as being mere tag-ends of separate narratives, which 
the author of this History had not art enough to hide. He was so incapable of working 
separate authorities into a unity, that he comes to three separate ends, because 
he had three separate authorities before him.</p>

<div style="margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align:justify; margin-top:9pt" id="iii.iv-p26.1">
<p class="continue" id="iii.iv-p27">“And the child grew and waxed 
strong in spirit, and was in the deserts till the day of his showing 
unto Israel,” <scripRef passage="Luke 1:80" id="iii.iv-p27.1" parsed="|Luke|1|80|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.80">1:80</scripRef>.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p28">“And the child grew and waxed strong in spirit, 
filled with wisdom; and the grace of God was upon him,” 
<scripRef passage="Luke 2:40" id="iii.iv-p28.1" parsed="|Luke|2|40|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.40">2:40</scripRef>.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p29">“And Jesus increased in wisdom and stature 
and in favor with God and man,” <scripRef passage="Luke 2:52" id="iii.iv-p29.1" parsed="|Luke|2|52|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.52">2:52</scripRef>.</p>
</div>

<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p30">But, in truth, these three sentences mark three stages 
in a continuous, unified narrative, written with the finest feeling and art by a 
single author of the loftiest literary power. They are a quite sufficient proof 
to one who judges on literary grounds that this is not a composite narrative, but 
the work of the same writer throughout.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p31">If we are right in this view as to Luke’s authority and 
as to the way in which that authority reached him, <i>viz.</i>, by oral communication, 
it appears that either the Virgin was still living when Luke was in Palestine during 
the years 57 and 58 — which is quite a possible supposition on the almost universally 
accepted assumption that she was quite young when Jesus was born — or Luke had conversed 
with some one very intimate with her, who knew her heart and could give him what 
was almost as good as firsthand information. Beyond that we cannot safely go; but 
yet one may venture to state the impression — though it may be generally considered 
merely fanciful — that the in, termediary, if one existed, is more likely to have 
been a woman than a man. There is a womanly spirit in the whole narrative, which 
seems inconsistent with the transmission from man to man,<note n="29" id="iii.iv-p31.1">For Eastern feeling read Lady Duff Gordon’s <i>Letters from Egypt.</i></note> 
and which, moreover, is an indication of Luke’s character: he had a, marked sympathy with women.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p32">Many other facts in his History show that character. Luke 
alone mentions the “women which had been healed of evil spirits and infirmities,” 
who “ministered to him of their substance”; and he names them: he was interested 
in themselves, in their gratitude to Jesus, and in their reason for it (<scripRef id="iii.iv-p32.1" passage="Luke 8:2" parsed="|Luke|8|2|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.8.2">Luke 8:2</scripRef>).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p33">He alone tells of the woman who wet Jesus’ feet with her 
tears, and wiped them with her hair, and kissed them, and anointed them — her to 
whom her many sins were forgiven, because she loved much. He does not tell her name 
— was it because she had been a sinner, and he would not chronicle that fact about 
a definite person? or was his information defective (<scripRef id="iii.iv-p33.1" passage="Luke 7:36" parsed="|Luke|7|36|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.7.36">Luke 
7:36</scripRef>)<note n="30" id="iii.iv-p33.2"><scripRef passage="Luke 7:36-38" id="iii.iv-p33.3" parsed="|Luke|7|36|7|38" osisRef="Bible:Luke.7.36-Luke.7.38">7:36 ff.</scripRef>: See
Note at end of chapter.</note>?</p>

<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p34">He alone tells about the different characters of Martha 
and Mary of Bethany, though he left much for John to add (<scripRef id="iii.iv-p34.1" passage="Luke 10:38" parsed="|Luke|10|38|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.10.38">Luke 10:38</scripRef>). Matthew and Mark do not mention their names, 
but allude to Mary in an obscure and almost inaccurate way.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p35">He alone tells of the women of Jerusalem who followed him 
to his death, bewailing and lamenting. All three synoptics mention the women who 
had followed Jesus from Galilee, and stood watching the crucifixion afar off, and 
how some of them watched where he was laid; but Luke alone tells how they went away 
and prepared spices and ointments (<scripRef id="iii.iv-p35.1" passage="Luke 23:27, 56" parsed="|Luke|23|27|0|0;|Luke|23|56|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.23.27 Bible:Luke.23.56">Luke 23:27, 56</scripRef>).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p36">He alone tells of the nameless woman in the crowd who blessed 
the mother of such a Son as Jesus; possibly one of those to whom Jesus afterwards 
said: “Blessed are the childless women, in those days that are coming” (<scripRef id="iii.iv-p36.1" passage="Luke 23:29" parsed="|Luke|23|29|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.23.29">Luke 
23:29</scripRef> compare <scripRef id="iii.iv-p36.2" passage="Luke 11:27" parsed="|Luke|11|27|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.11.27">Luke 11:27</scripRef>).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p37">Thus time after time, Luke is our only authority for the 
service and ministration of women. He had the tender and sympathetic feeling for 
women which seems to be quite in keeping with his surroundings in Macedonia (where 
women occupied a place of so much more honor than in Greece proper), and which makes 
him record so often in his second book the part played by women in the diffusion 
of the new religion.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p38">In the texture of the two opening chapters we find full 
justification for the prominence that the preface lays upon this episode; and we 
conclude that both the personal character of the author and the high authority on 
which he claims to rest, would prompt him to lavish special loving care on this 
part of his narrative and to avoid defacing it by a serious blunder. If he made 
a blunder, as seems generally admitted, that would be a sufficient refutation of 
the view which I have maintained, that he was a great historian.</p>

<p class="center" id="iii.iv-p39"><b>NOTE</b></p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p40">Probably the most reasonable explanation of the remarkable 
discrepancies between the four passages — <scripRef id="iii.iv-p40.1" passage="Matthew 26:6-13" parsed="|Matt|26|6|26|13" osisRef="Bible:Matt.26.6-Matt.26.13">Matthew 26:6-13</scripRef>, <scripRef id="iii.iv-p40.2" passage="Mark 14:3-9" parsed="|Mark|14|3|14|9" osisRef="Bible:Mark.14.3-Mark.14.9">Mark 14:3-9</scripRef>, 
<scripRef id="iii.iv-p40.3" passage="Luke 7:36-50" parsed="|Luke|7|36|7|50" osisRef="Bible:Luke.7.36-Luke.7.50">Luke 7:36-50</scripRef> and <scripRef id="iii.iv-p40.4" passage="John 12:1-9" parsed="|John|12|1|12|9" osisRef="Bible:John.12.1-John.12.9">John 12:1-9</scripRef> (cp. 
<scripRef passage="John 11:2" id="iii.iv-p40.5" parsed="|John|11|2|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.11.2">11:2</scripRef>) — is that there were two distinct incidents: one occurred in the house of Simon the 
Pharisee, and is described by Luke; the other occurred 
in the house of Martha and Mary at Bethany, and is correctly described by John. 
Mark, and following him Matthew, mix up the two and describe the incident as occurring 
at Bethany in the house of Simon the Leper. They, do not name the woman, and they 
merely say that she poured a box of ointment over the head of Jesus. The attempts 
to harmonize John with Mark and Matthew fail completely. John, who says that “they 
made him a supper there and Martha served,” obviously places the meal in Martha’s 
house: it seems quite absurd to suppose that she would be serving in the house of 
Simon. There is an obvious intention on John’s part to correct the current account, 
as seen in Matthew and Mark, and at the same time to illustrate the character of 
Martha as described by <scripRef id="iii.iv-p40.6" passage="Luke 10:38" parsed="|Luke|10|38|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.10.38">Luke 10:38</scripRef>. 
Similarly, inasmuch as the current account placed the incident two days before the 
last supper, John pointedly says it occurred “six days before the Passover”.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p41">Probably, Mark originally fell into error from treating 
two separate incidents, each perhaps only reported in part to him, or in part forgotten 
by him, as being one and the same incident. From one incident he caught that it 
had occurred in Bethany, and from another that it occurred in the house of Simon: 
accordingly he begins “while he was in Bethany in the house of Simon the Leper, 
as he sat at meat”. It must remain uncertain whether Luke’s Simon the Pharisee is 
the same person as Mark’s Simon the Leper, or (as seems on the whole more probable) 
the incident narrated by Luke occurred in the north, near the Sea of Galilee, in 
the house of Simon the Pharisee, and Mark, connecting the incident at once with 
Bethany and with Simon, put it in the house of a Simon who lived in Bethany and 
was or had been a leper. It would be obviously impossible that the feast should 
be held in the house of one who was a leper; and it seems not very probable that 
it would be held in his house, if he had ever been a leper.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p42">It must be confessed that there is some temptation to follow 
the Roman tradition, and treat the Lukan incident as the same with the Johannine. 
Luke is vague as to the locality, though it is most natural to understand that it 
occurred in the north. But the decisive argument lies in the moral of the tale. 
The reason why any incident was remembered by the disciples lay in the lesson which 
the Master had deduced from it. The features which drew forth the lesson in Luke 
are precisely those which are most difficult to reconcile 
with John. To identify the two incidents, it becomes almost necessary to suppose 
that the features on which the moral hinges are errors on Luke’s part. Now I should 
be quite ready to admit that Luke had made mistakes about various points, provided 
they were not essential to the moral; but those are precisely the points that are 
vital, and give vitality to the whole incident. Matthew and Mark are reconciled 
with John by assuming that they have erred in the accompaniments; but in the vital 
details they agree with him. To identify Luke and John requires that the vital details 
are false in one or the other.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iii.iv-p43">The considerations advanced (see chapter 11) ff., if correct, 
would entirely disprove the identity of the Lukan and the Johannine incident.</p>

</div2>
</div1>

    <div1 title="Part 2. Solution of the Problem" progress="34.97%" id="iv" prev="iii.iv" next="iv.i">

<h1 id="iv-p0.1">PART 2<br />
SOLUTION OF THE PROBLEM</h1>

      <div2 title="Chapter 5. The Question at Issue" progress="34.98%" id="iv.i" prev="iv" next="iv.ii">
<h3 id="iv.i-p0.1">CHAPTER 5<br />
THE QUESTION AT ISSUE</h3>

<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p1">NEITHER Mark nor John mentions where Jesus was born. 
<scripRef id="iv.i-p1.1" passage="Mark 1:9" parsed="|Mark|1|9|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Mark.1.9">Mark 1:9</scripRef> says: “Jesus 
came from Nazareth of Galilee and was baptized of John in the Jordan”. In 
<scripRef id="iv.i-p1.2" passage="John 1:45" parsed="|John|1|45|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.1.45">John 1:45</scripRef> Philip speaks 
of him as “Jesus of Nazareth, the son of Joseph”; and in 
<scripRef id="iv.i-p1.3" passage="Acts 10:38" parsed="|Acts|10|38|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.10.38">Acts 10:38</scripRef> Peter mentions “Jesus 
of Nazareth”.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p2">These expressions obviously do not imply that Mark, or 
John, or the author of Acts considered Nazareth to be the place of Jesus’ birth. 
They merely show that Nazareth was universally considered to be the abode of his 
parents, the place which had been his home, coming from which he had appeared before 
the world. Similarly the expression, “son of Joseph,” used by Philip in 
<scripRef id="iv.i-p2.1" passage="John 1:45" parsed="|John|1|45|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.1.45">John 1:45</scripRef>, cannot be taken as 
indicating John’s own opinion, but merely as showing the current belief.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p3">Again, <scripRef id="iv.i-p3.1" passage="John 7:40, 41" parsed="|John|7|40|7|41" osisRef="Bible:John.7.40-John.7.41">John 7:40, 41</scripRef>, 
quotes the opinions expressed in Jerusalem about Jesus: some of the multitude said: 
“This is of a truth the prophet”: others said: “This is the Christ”: but some said: 
“What, does the Christ come out of Galilee? Hath not the scripture said that the 
Christ cometh of the seed of David and from Bethlehem?”</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p4">These are the popular sayings, and it is obvious that they 
are arranged to form a climax; but the last, which is really the strongest recognition 
of Jesus as the Messiah, gains all the more emphasis because it has the form of 
an objection to him. He was the Prophet: He was the Christ: He fulfilled all the 
prophecies about the coming of the Christ. The irony, which makes the objectors 
unconsciously bear such emphatic witness in his favor, might have been expected 
to be clear and impressive to every rational mind. But there is no blindness so 
complete as that of the historical critic with a bad 
theory to maintain; and the critics of this class actually quote this passage as 
a proof that John did not believe that Jesus was born in Bethlehem. Would they be 
consistent, and maintain also that John did not believe him to be of the seed of 
David, though that was indubitably the accepted doctrine of the early Church, as 
is attested by Paul, <scripRef id="iv.i-p4.1" passage="Romans 1:3" parsed="|Rom|1|3|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Rom.1.3">Romans 1:3</scripRef> 
and <scripRef passage="2Timothy 2:8" id="iv.i-p4.2" parsed="|2Tim|2|8|0|0" osisRef="Bible:2Tim.2.8">2 Timothy 2:8</scripRef>, as 
well as by the Synoptics?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p5">But the two points mentioned by the objectors must go together. 
They who quote <scripRef passage="John 7:41" id="iv.i-p5.1" parsed="|John|7|41|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.7.41">7:41</scripRef> 
as a proof that John did not know the second point must infer also that John did 
not know the first. Every Christian reader of John’s Gospel would recognize the 
irony involved in the first point, for he knew the doctrine set forth by Paul and 
the Synoptics. He would therefore necessarily recognize that the second point was 
also ironical.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p6">Accordingly, every scholar who judges literature on literary 
grounds will recognize that the writer of the fourth Gospel assumes such perfect 
familiarity in his readers with the story of the birth in Bethlehem, that not merely 
must he be ranked among the witnesses to it, but he must have written at a time 
when this belief was a part of recognized Christian teaching; and it is probable 
that this will be urged by some scholars as a proof that the fourth Gospel springs 
from a much later period, after the story as given by Matthew and Luke had had time 
to become a fundamental part of Church doctrine.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p7">But a remarkable feature in the Gospels, at least of Matthew, 
Luke and John, is that they assume in their readers such a background of knowledge 
about the life of the Savior. They are written for the use of persons who were already 
Christians, and who already had the life of Jesus in their minds as the foundation 
of their faith. None of the Gospels is intended to be a formal biography: their 
completeness is moral and spiritual and not historical:”<note n="31" id="iv.i-p7.1">Westcott, <i>Gospel of St. John</i>, p. 78.</note> 
they are, in reality, Gospels. But the facts of the life of Jesus were fundamental 
in the Gospel, and from that point of view each Gospel had to present a record of 
facts, actions and words sufficient to bear the structure of faith which had to 
rest upon it. But John, in particular, assumes that his readers know the facts recorded 
in the Synoptic Gospels, and his work is an unintelligible phenomenon in literature 
unless this is recognized.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p8">Now Matthew and Luke agree that Jesus was born in Bethlehem.
<scripRef id="iv.i-p8.1" passage="Matthew 2:6" parsed="|Matt|2|6|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Matt.2.6">Matthew 2:6</scripRef> points out 
that this place of birth was the fulfillment of the 
prophecy that the Ruler of Israel was to be born there. Yet they are also fully 
aware that Jesus was considered by the world to be a native of Nazareth, and that 
he had been brought up from infancy in that city. <scripRef id="iv.i-p8.2" passage="Matthew 2:23" parsed="|Matt|2|23|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Matt.2.23">Matthew 
2:23</scripRef> again sees in the up-bringing at Nazareth the 
fulfillment of another prophecy. How, then, do they 
account for the general oblivion of the real place of birth?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p9">Matthew begins with the birth of Jesus. He tells nothing 
about any previous connection of his parents with Nazareth; but says that they retired 
to Nazareth while the Child was still an infant, being in fear of the reigning King 
of Judea. If Luke’s History had not been preserved, it would have been unhesitatingly 
concluded on the authority of Matthew that the parents of Jesus had never lived 
at Nazareth until after the birth of the Child. And though Matthew does not explicitly 
assert that, yet it is hard to think that he could have expressed himself as he 
has done, if he had known that the parents had their original home in Nazareth.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p10">Luke goes farther back, in accordance with his profession 
to have studied all things from their origin. He mentions that both Joseph and Mary 
resided at Nazareth. He tells that they made frequent visits to Jerusalem, and that 
the mother had relatives there or in the neighborhood; and he explains what was 
the cause that led them to make a brief visit to Bethlehem at such a moment that 
Jesus was born there.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p11">Luke does not indeed say explicitly in so many words that 
the visit was intended to be a mere temporary one; and this has led some commentators 
to suggest that there may have been an intent on the part of the parents to change 
their residence to Bethlehem. But the cause stated in 
<scripRef id="iv.i-p11.1" passage="John 2:4, 5" parsed="|John|2|4|2|5" osisRef="Bible:John.2.4-John.2.5">John 2:4, 5</scripRef>, implies a mere temporary 
visit; and the language of <scripRef id="iv.i-p11.2" passage="Luke 2:39" parsed="|Luke|2|39|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.39">Luke 2:39</scripRef> shows that after 
the brief visit they returned to their own city, Nazareth, and implies that this 
had always been their intention.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p12">The occasion of this short visit to Bethlehem is thus described 
by Luke. In accordance with the orders of the Roman Emperor, Augustus, there was 
made an enrollment, or numbering, of the population of Herod’s kingdom; and this was made according to households and tribal descent 
and local tribal connection, so that those Hebrews who were not residing in the 
proper city of their tribe and family were obliged to go to their city in order 
to be enrolled there.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p13">Further, it seems to be implied that the wife, as well 
as the head of the house, had to go to the proper city (or for some reason felt 
it a duty to go), so that the household as a whole might be numbered in the tribal 
and family center.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p14">Joseph, then, with Mary, his wife, went to his proper city, 
Bethlehem, to be numbered there among his own people, “because he was of the house 
and family of David”.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p15">It has been maintained by many scholars in modern times 
that the census is either a fiction or a blunder; that the circumstances connected 
with it, which Luke relates, are contrary to history; and, in short, that the story 
is unhistorical and impossible, not in one way merely, but in several. It is asserted 
as unquestionable that the sole germ out of which the story has developed is the 
fact, recorded by Josephus, that about AD. 6-7 there was made a census and valuation 
of Palestine, the first and the only one which the Romans held in that country; 
and that Luke has transferred this census, with the officer, Quirinius, who made 
it, to a different period about nine or twelve years earlier, when it was for various 
reasons impossible that any census could have occurred.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p16">It has been urged with triumphant certainty as established 
on incontrovertible evidence that the whole story of
chapter 
2, with all its pathetic and romantic incidents, is a mere fiction, destitute 
of even as much historical foundation as most historical novels possess. It is asserted 
as a demonstrated truth that the story contradicts the established facts of contemporary 
history; and that any one who accepts the ordinary canons of historical reasoning 
must relegate the whole talc of the birth of Christ to the realm of imaginative 
fiction. Nor is it only the extreme school of critics that reject the talc as an 
invention. Many of those scholars who thoroughly accept the trust-worthiness of 
the Gospel narrative as a whole abandon the attempt to defend this incident, and 
either pass by on the other side, or frankly admit that it is at least in part erroneous, 
a mixture of <span lang="DE" id="iv.i-p16.1">Dichtung und Wahrheit</span>.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p17">Against the trustworthiness of this narrative the following 
are the main lines of argument: —</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p18"><b>1.</b> It is declared to 
be a demonstrated fact that Augustus never ordered any general “Enrollment,” or 
census, to be made of the whole Roman world. Gardthausen, the latest historian of 
Augustus, speaks most emphatically on this point. He goes even so far as to declare 
that it is inconsistent with Augustus’s aims to attribute to him any such intention: 
he quotes the words of Luke, and then adds that, for the emperor’s plans, a general 
census of the empire was neither necessary nor suitable.<note n="32" id="iv.i-p18.1"><i><span lang="DE" id="iv.i-p18.2">Ein allgemeiner Reichscensus war 
dazu weder nothig noch zweckmassig</span></i> are his exact words (Augustus und seine Zeit, Part 1., vol. 2., p. 923).</note></p>

<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p19">The eminent German scholar here displays a familiarity 
with Augustus’s intentions and the limits of his aims, which is quite unjustified 
by the scanty evidence accessible to us. Such assumption of the right to pronounce 
negative judgments is not the spirit in which the history of Augustus ought to be 
written, and such a wild statement as this shows a momentary loss of the historic 
instinct, which enables a writer to distinguish between legitimate inference and 
loose imagination. It is one of the places in Gardthausen’s work where a regret 
rises strong in every reader’s mind that Mommsen<note n="33" id="iv.i-p19.1">I do not mean to imply that Mommsen 
has shown any disposition to accept Luke’s evidence on this point. On the contrary, 
he dismisses it as a mere mistaken inference from Josephus.</note> has never found opportunity to write the history of that period.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p20">In truth, the distinguished historian of Augustus was not 
justified in asserting more than that no evidence was known to him corroborating 
Luke’s statement as to Augustus’s intentions. It will be my aim to show that evidence 
was in existence, apparently unknown to Gardthausen, which affords some confirmation 
of Luke’s assertion; and establishes it, when Luke’s words are properly translated, 
on a basis of high historical probability.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p21"><b>2.</b> Even if Augustus 
had ordered a census to be made of the whole empire, it is maintained that such 
a census would not have extended to Palestine, which was an independent kingdom 
and not subject to the orders of Augustus.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p22">There is a mixture of truth and error in this line of argument. 
It will be our aim to demonstrate that, while the application of the Roman census 
by Roman officials to Herod’s kingdom could not be accepted as credible, yet Luke 
does not speak of any such application. The argument is founded on a false interpretation. Luke nowhere asserts or implies that 
the census was made by a Roman official. He states that the birth of Jesus occurred 
in the days of Herod the King of Judea, and in the country over which that king 
ruled: compare <scripRef passage="Luke 1:5" id="iv.i-p22.1" parsed="|Luke|1|5|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.5">1:5</scripRef> and
<scripRef passage="Luke 2:4" id="iv.i-p22.2" parsed="|Luke|2|4|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.4">2:4</scripRef>. He merely mentions 
the Roman officer, Quirinius, for purposes of dating according to the ancient style, 
employed generally before eras and numbering of years had come into literary use, 
just as he mentions various kings and priests in <scripRef passage="Luke 3:1,2" id="iv.i-p22.3" parsed="|Luke|3|1|3|2" osisRef="Bible:Luke.3.1-Luke.3.2">3:1, 2</scripRef> for the same purpose. He assumes that his readers 
would appreciate the fact that the census in the territory of King Herod was conducted 
under the immediate orders of the king himself.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p23">Further, Luke certainly understands that Herod’s kingdom 
was a part of the Roman world, and that Herod was bound to obey orders issued by 
Augustus in respect of numbering the population of the Roman world.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p24">We shall have to show — what no one except a theological 
critic with a theory to maintain would dream of denying — that Herod’s kingdom was 
a part of the Roman world; that it was not independent, but ought rather to be styled 
a “dependent state”; and that any tendency on the part of such dependent kings to 
disregard their duty of submission to the general principles of Roman policy was 
sharply repressed by the emperors.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p25"><b>3.</b> Even if a census 
had been held in Palestine, it is asserted that there would have been no necessity 
for Joseph and Mary to go up from Nazareth to the city of Bethlehem, inasmuch as 
a Roman census would be made according to the existing political and social facts, 
and would not require that persons should be enrolled according to their place of 
birth or origin. The Roman method necessarily was to count the population according 
to their actual residence. It is, however, an essential point in Luke’s story, that 
it should explain how the son of a resident in Nazareth came to be born in Bethlehem, 
and thus fulfilled the prophecy that the Messiah was to be born in that city. Hence 
it is contended that Luke’s fiction is doubly erroneous, for even if it were true 
it would not lead to that journey, which is the critical point in the history.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p26">There can be no doubt that in the Roman census the existing 
facts were recorded, and that any disturbance of the existing distribution of population 
would defeat the purpose and impair the value of the census. Therefore, if the census 
which Luke had in mind were one carried out purely 
after the Roman method, it would not furnish the explanation which is the prime 
reason for mentioning the census. That must be freely conceded.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p27">But, far from asserting that this census was carried out 
strictly after the Roman method, Luke explains at the outset that it was made on 
a different principle, not merely by households (as the Roman method<note n="34" id="iv.i-p27.1">On this see chapter 7.</note>  
required), but also at the same time according to descent and stock, that is by 
tribes. It will be our aim to show why this modification of the Roman method was 
necessary for Herod in his peculiar position: he disguised the Roman and foreign 
character by the additional requirement that the census should be tribal and thus 
less alien to the national feeling.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p28"><b>4.</b> It is maintained 
that no census was ever held in Judea until AD. 6-7, on the ground that that “great 
census” (<scripRef id="iv.i-p28.1" passage="Acts 5:37" parsed="|Acts|5|37|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.5.37">Acts 5:37</scripRef>) is 
described by Josephus as something novel and unheard of, rousing popular indignation 
and rebellion on that account.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p29">We freely concede that the attempts which have been made 
to find in Josephus any allusion to an earlier census held under Herod have failed. 
They have been directed on the wrong lines they have been made with a view to discover 
signs of such a knowledge of the finances of Palestine as would imply a formal Roman 
census and valuation made under Herod.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p30">We also fully acknowledge that the earliest census and 
valuation of property made after the Roman fashion in Palestine took place, as Josephus 
says, in AD. 7. It is a necessary part of our case that a totally new departure 
was made in that year; and that the novel, unheard-of, and anti-national proceeding 
roused indignation and rebellion. In all that Josephus is thoroughly right. But 
the census of Herod was tribal and Hebraic, not anti-national. It was wholly and 
utterly unconnected with any scheme of Roman taxation; and it was conducted by Herod 
on strictly tribal methods. It roused little indignation and no rebellion; and therefore 
gave no reason for Josephus to notice it.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p31">It is plain too how great an extent these four arguments 
against the “Enrollment” hang together, and depend on a false character ascribed 
to the operation. When Luke’s narrative is looked at from the proper point of view 
by the true historical and sympathetic judgment, with the intention, not of picking all possible faults, but of understanding in 
the best light the testimony which he gives, we shall see that his evidence explains 
satisfactorily a peculiarly obscure episode in Roman provincial history. And we 
shall find that in one more case the progress of discovery in Egypt has set in a 
new light the problems that seemed insoluble to our predecessors, and made perfectly 
clear what was obscure to them.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p32">In addition to these four closely connected arguments, 
another of a different character is advanced.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p33"><b>5.</b> It is affirmed that 
Quirinius never governed Syria during the life of Herod, for Herod died in 4 BC. 
and Quirinius was governor of Syria later than 3 BC. and probably in 2 or 1 BC. 
Therefore a census taken in the time of Quirinius could not be associated with the 
birth of a child “in the days of Herod, King of Judea”.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p34">The conclusion of Mommsen, of Borghesi, and of de Rossi, 
that Quirinius governed Syria twice, has been generally accepted by modern scholars. 
Quirinius went to govern Syria for the second time in AD. 6. The proof that his 
first governorship of Syria fell as late as the year 2 or 1 BC. is incomplete, depending 
on an estimate of probabilities; and it is founded on the assumption that a statement 
made by Suetonius is inaccurate. We shall try to show that the decided balance of 
probabilities is in favor of his having held command in Syria before Herod died. 
In the present defective state of the evidence, one cannot go further than a probable 
statement.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p35">The propositions which we seek to defend are only probable. 
The evidence is too scanty to demonstrate any of them in such a perfectly conclusive 
fashion that the most prejudiced minds must be convinced. But how many of the “facts” 
of ancient history are demonstrated beyond all reach of cavil and dissension? Every 
one who has studied the foundations of ancient history knows that most of our knowledge 
is founded on a balance of evidence, often a very delicate balance; and, if there 
were any strong motive to make it worth while fighting the case, almost any detail 
in ancient history can be called in question. What I am concerned to maintain is 
that all our positions are the most probable issue of the scanty evidence, and that 
some of them rest on testimony, outside of Luke’s writings, which in ordinary historical 
criticism is reckoned sufficient justification, while the others are in themselves 
quite natural, and there is practically no evidence 
against them, so that Luke’s authority should be reckoned as sufficient to establish 
them.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p36">The possible views with regard to the present question 
seem to reduce themselves to three: —</p>
<div style="margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align:justify; margin-top:9pt" id="iv.i-p36.1">

<p class="continue" id="iv.i-p37"><b>1.</b> The 
story of the birth of Christ, as given by Luke, is so suspicious and 
encumbered with so many difficulties that it is as a whole incredible.</p>
<p class="continue" id="iv.i-p38"><b>2. </b>The story is true.</p>
<p class="continue" id="iv.i-p39"><b>3.</b> The main part of the story is true, but the reference to Quirinius is wrong, 
and the incident occurred ten to fourteen years before his census. It 
is possible to cut out the verse about Quirinius, which is a mere date 
added by Luke, and leave the story otherwise complete; but all the rest 
hangs together, and if one detail be false, everything is affected.</p>
</div>

<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p40">As to the third alternative, besides the general considerations 
already urged, see to what a dilemma it reduces its supporters! They acknowledge 
that the date is added in error by Luke. The rest they hold to be true, because 
Luke learned it from some other authority not so inaccurate as himself. After discrediting 
Luke, they proceed to accept everything that is most difficult to believe in his 
History. But, when the channel through which the story reaches us is unworthy of 
belief, everything that comes through the channel is discredited; the story has 
in truth not a leg to stand upon except Luke’s personal authority as a safe and 
trustworthy judge of truth and weigher of evidence. Those who first discredit Luke’s 
personal authority, and then attach credibility to his story, are far less reasonable 
and critical than they who accept the whole.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p41">Obviously, the truth of the story in
<scripRef passage="1:1-80" id="iv.i-p41.1" parsed="|Acts|1|1|1|80" osisRef="Bible:Acts.1.1-Acts.1.80">Luke 1</scripRef>, 
<scripRef passage="2:1-52" id="iv.i-p41.2" parsed="|Acts|2|1|2|52" osisRef="Bible:Acts.2.1-Acts.2.52">2</scripRef>, can never be demonstrated. 
There will always remain a large step to be taken on faith. A marvelous event is 
described in it. They only will accept it who, for other reasons, have come to the 
conclusion that there is no adequate and rational explanation of the coming of Christianity 
into the world, except through the direct and “miraculous” intervention of Divine 
power.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p42">But it is highly important to show that the circumstances 
with which Luke connects this marvelous event are true, and that, in things which 
can be tested, he does not fall below the standard of accuracy demanded from the 
ordinary historians.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p43">Again, those who hold Luke’s statement about the enrollment 
to be a mere blunder ought to give some explanation of the way in which the blunder 
originated. It is generally stated as an explanation that Luke was dependent on 
Josephus for the facts of general history which he mentions; and that, as he found 
in Josephus an account of “the Great Enrollment” made by Quirinius in AD. 6-8, he 
erroneously connected this enrollment with the birth of Christ.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p44">In discussing this suggested explanation, I shall lay no 
stress on the steadily growing consensus of opinion that all attempts to prove the 
dependence of Luke on Josephus have failed, and that Luke’s work was composed before 
Josephus’s work on Jewish Antiquities was published; for it is possible to maintain 
that the error was made through confusion and misunderstanding of some other historian’s 
statement. Luke, who was not born when the events in question occurred, was dependent 
on some earlier authority or other for his knowledge of the Roman circumstances 
which he mentions; and the possibility of error arising must be admitted.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p45">But it is necessary to realize clearly how much is involved 
in the assumption that such an error was made. It is implied not merely that Luke 
misplaced that important event — fundamental in the Roman organization of Palestine 
— “the great census”; but also that he distorted the character of that census, which 
was, beyond all doubt, conducted on the Roman system without the slightest regard 
to tribal connection, and that he used this distortion of the census to explain 
why a family belonging to Nazareth came to be present in Bethlehem. Such a series 
of blunders of a very gross type cannot have been mere slips or mistakes due to 
ignorance. They bear on their face the character of deliberate invention. They have 
been concocted for a purpose, viz., to lend verisimilitude to the tale that Jesus 
was born in Bethlehem. But a tale which is buttressed by such shameful falsifications 
loses all claim on our belief. And what can we say about a historian who concocts 
such a series of inventions? What condemnation could 
be too strong for his shameful conduct? What words too sharp to characterize his 
imposture?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p46">I put the question to any reasonable person: Is it consistent 
with human nature that a writer who claims to be earnestly setting forth the simple 
facts should begin with so impudent a series of fabrications? Can any reasonable 
judge believe that the author who wrote the rest of the two books could be guilty 
of such deliberate deception?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p47">Another explanation may perhaps be offered, <i>viz</i>., 
that Luke did not himself invent the connection between the birth of Jesus and this 
fraudulent census, but that he incautiously adopted a series of errors which had 
either grown in popular tradition or been invented by some older writer.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p48">In the first place, we reply, oriental tradition does not 
take this character: it does not invent such a circumstantial historical setting, 
whose aim is to work an incident into a place in Roman Imperial history. The census 
would obviously have been introduced here, not by popular fancy, but by the calculated 
invention of a person trying to give plausibility to a fiction.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p49">Secondly, Luke’s work has all the appearance of being the 
first attempt to show the place which early Christian history occupied in the general 
history of the empire: the author is evidently taking the Gospel from his earlier 
authorities, and on the ground of his own historical inquiries stating its place 
in Roman history, a subject in which his Jewish authorities took no interest: probably, 
therefore, he is not dependent on older Christian writers for his statements about 
the census This is, I think, generally admitted.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.i-p50">Thirdly, Luke devotes much care to the relations of early 
Christianity to the Roman state; it was easy for him to acquire correct knowledge 
as to the Roman census; and, if he allowed a statement on that subject to find a 
place in his book, he makes himself responsible for it in the fullest sense.</p>


</div2>

      <div2 title="Chapter 6. Luke’s Account of the Enrollment" progress="42.72%" id="iv.ii" prev="iv.i" next="iv.iii">


<h3 id="iv.ii-p0.1">CHAPTER 6 <br />
LUKE’S ACCOUNT OF THE ENROLLMENT</h3>

<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p1">LUKE wrote for readers belonging to the civilized Graeco-Roman world; and he conceived the History which he presented to his readers as occupying 
a place in the general history of the Roman world. He often speaks of “the world”; 
but to him “the world” was strictly the Roman world, and any order issued by Augustus 
affected the whole world, as he says in <scripRef passage="Luke 2:1" id="iv.ii-p1.1" parsed="|Luke|2|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.1">2:1</scripRef>. 
Accordingly, at important stages in the action, he inserts a few brief notes, just 
sufficient to show the position of his subject in the general history of the empire.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p2">The most important of these notes is contained in the following 
words, <scripRef id="iv.ii-p2.1" passage="2:1-4" parsed="|Luke|2|1|2|4" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.1-Luke.2.4">2:1-4</scripRef>, which 
we give according to the Revised Version:</p>
<div style="margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align:justify; margin-top:9pt" id="iv.ii-p2.2">
<p class="continue" id="iv.ii-p3">Now it came to pass in those 
days, there went out a decree from Caesar Augustus that all the world 
should be enrolled. This was the first enrollment, made when Quirinius 
was governing Syria. And all went to enroll themselves, every one to 
his own city. And Joseph also went up from Galilee, out of the city 
of Nazareth, into Judea, to the city of David, which is called Bethlehem, 
because he was of the house and family of David — to enroll himself 
with Mary his wife.</p>
</div>

<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p4">It might seem hardly necessary to state that in this passage 
of Luke the term “world,” <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.ii-p4.1">οἰκουμένη</span>, 
must be understood as the “Roman world, and not the entire earth with all its inhabited 
lands. But some modern scholars actually charge it as an error that this passage 
makes an order of Augustus effective throughout the whole earth, whereas the order 
would have no force except in the Roman empire. Accordingly we must point out that 
in several places Luke uses the same term “world” when he obviously is speaking 
only of the Roman empire. To the citizens of the empire all the rest of the earth 
often passed out of mind; and when they spoke of the world their view was restricted 
to the Roman world. So, for example, Demetrius, the silversmith of Ephesus, spoke 
about the State-Goddess Diana, “whom all Asia and the world worshippeth,” <i>i.e</i>., 
to worship whom the whole province Asia and the Roman 
empire send their representatives and their crowds of visitors. Again, Paul and 
Silas were accused before the magistrates of Thessalonica because they had “turned 
the world upside down”; the accusers were not thinking of the disturbance of order 
among the outer barbarians, but only in many parts of the Roman empire. Similarly, 
any ordinary rational interpretation will recognize that 
<scripRef id="iv.ii-p4.2" passage="Luke 2:1" parsed="|Luke|2|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.1">Luke 2:1</scripRef> speaks of the order 
of Augustus as issued for the whole Roman empire.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p5">What was the extent of “the world” or “the Roman world,” 
of which Luke speaks?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p6">It included, of course, Italy and the organized Roman provinces. 
But, further, Luke evidently considered that it included the dependent kingdoms, 
such as Judea, for he describes this order as being carried out in the kingdom of 
Herod. That such was his point of view seems not to be appreciated by the scholars 
who ridicule the whole episode; and hence they think that he contradicts himself, 
when he speaks as if this order extended to the kingdom of Herod.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p7">The question then arises whether it is justifiable to regard 
these dependent kingdoms, Judea and others, as forming part of the Roman world.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p8">This question Strabo, writing about AD. 19, answers emphatically 
in the affirmative. In the last chapter of his Geography he gives a description 
of the Roman empire as it was when he was writing about AD. 19. He describes it 
as extending over the entire coasts of the Mediterranean Sea, and he expressly includes 
in it the western part of the African coast (Mauretania) which was ruled by King 
Ptolemy, who had just recently succeeded his father Juba II. Some parts of this 
empire are, he says, governed by kings, while part is in the form of provinces. 
There are also subject to the Romans certain dynasts,<note n="35" id="iv.ii-p8.1">This title was given to certain princes, 
e. g., those who ruled Ketis in Cilicia Tracheia.</note>  
and chiefs, and priests: and these live according to certain national laws. He distinguishes 
this whole empire, containing these various territories and governments and provinces, 
from the non-Roman and barbarian world. He declares that in the part of the empire 
which is directly under the authority and power of the emperor there are not merely 
Roman governors of three grades sent from Rome by himself, but also kings, and dynasts, 
and native officials of lower degree.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p9">Strabo uses several expressions which show how completely 
he considered these kingdoms to be part of the Roman world. He defines the entire 
complex of territories as “the possessions of the Romans,” <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.ii-p9.1">τὰ τούτων</span>; 
he speaks of <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.ii-p9.2">συμπάσης χώρας τῆς ὑπὸ Ῥωμαίοις</span>; and he describes 
how the Romans. obtained them, <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.ii-p9.3">προσεκτήσαντο</span>.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p10">Moreover, it is impossible to suppose that Augustus, when 
he defeated Mark Antony, abandoned the suzerainty which the latter had certainly 
exercised over many lands, and gave away to independent kings what had once belonged 
to Rome. The eastern parts of Asia Minor had been treated by Antony as subject to 
his own absolute authority. When he pleased, he set up a king over part of them; 
when he chose, he degraded the king. But whoever was the king, Antony claimed from 
him contributions and military service; and they all sent or led their troops to 
swell the army of their supreme lord at Actium. It would be irrational to suppose 
that Augustus, who claimed to be the champion of Rome against Antony, abandoned 
great territories which Antony had held to be under Rome.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p11">We cannot, therefore, doubt that Strabo expresses the view 
held by Augustus and by all Rome, that the territory ruled by these dependent kings 
was part of the Roman empire. They were subject kings, and not free from the suzerainty 
of Rome.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p12">Appian<note n="36" id="iv.ii-p12.1"><i>Bell. Civil.</i>, 5., 75.</note>  
describes the subject kings whom Antony appointed, including Herod, as paying tribute. 
We cannot doubt that the same was the case under Augustus. The empire did not abandon 
its claim to gain something from these kings; and Augustus would not gain less than 
Antony had gained. On the other hand, it seems to have been left to the discretion 
of the native rulers to govern and to collect revenue according to native customs 
and laws. Strabo, in his final chapter; distinguishes between the provinces, to 
which governors and collectors of taxes were sent from Rome, and the countries subject 
to Rome, but governed by native princes according to native laws.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p13">Further, Strabo on p. 671 describes the intention of the 
Romans in setting up these subject kings. He is speaking of Cilicia Tracheia, but 
he expresses the Roman theory as it was applied generally. Some of the subject countries 
were specially difficult to govern, either on account of the unruly character of 
the inhabitants, or because the natural features of the land lent themselves readily to brigandage and piracy. As these countries 
must be either administered by Roman governors or ruled by kings, it was considered 
that kings would more efficiently control their restless subjects, being permanently 
on the spot and having soldiers always at command. But the history of the following 
century shows how, step by step and district by district, these countries were incorporated 
in the adjacent Roman provinces, as a certain degree of discipline and civilization 
was imparted to the population by the kings, who built cities and introduced the 
Graeco-Roman customs and education.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p14">It appears, therefore, that when Luke counts the kingdom 
of Herod part of “the Roman World,” his point of view agrees with the ideas expressed 
by Strabo and held generally in the empire.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p15">The decree of Augustus which Luke mentions is commonly 
interpreted as ordering that a single census should be held of the whole Roman world. 
This is not a correct interpretation of Luke’s words. He uses the present tense 
(<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.ii-p15.1">ἀπογράφεσθαι πᾶσαν τὴν οἰκουμένην</span>), and he means that Augustus ordered 
enrollments to be regularly taken, according to the strict and proper usage of the 
present tense. What Augustus did was to lay down the principle of systematic “enrollment” 
in the Roman world, not to arrange for the taking of one single census.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p16">It deserves notice that Malalas, who took the false sense 
from Luke and describes Augustus as ordering that a single enrollment should be 
made, unconsciously changes the expression and uses the aorist<note n="37" id="iv.ii-p16.1"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.ii-p16.2">ὥστε ἀπογραφῆναι πᾶσαν τὴν ὑπ᾽ αὐτὸν γενομένην 
γῆν καὶ ἣν πρώην εἶχον 
Ῥωμαῖοι</span>, Malalas, p. 226.</note>  
where Luke uses the present tense. Similarly, when Luke tells that Joseph went up 
for enrollment on one definite occasion, he uses the aorist (<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.ii-p16.3">ἀνέβη</span> 
and <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.ii-p16.4">ἀπογράψασθαι</span>).
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p17">Thereafter the text of Luke proceeds naturally: “This was 
the first enrollment, while Quirinius was administering Syria; and all persons proceeded 
to go for enrollment each to his own city”. Here the presential tenses (<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.ii-p17.1">ἀπογράφεσθαι</span> 
and <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.ii-p17.2">ἐπορεύοντο</span>) 
are necessitated by the sense: all persons, individually and severally, repaired 
to their proper cities for their respective enrollment. In the series of enrollments, 
which were inaugurated by the orders of Augustus, the first was the one with which 
the story is concerned; and Joseph, like the rest, went up from Galilee out
of the city of Nazareth into Judea, to the city of David, 
which is called Bethlehem, because he was of the house and family of David.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p18">From this passage, then, it appears that Luke’s conception 
of the procedure in the Roman empire was as follows: Augustus ordered a systematic 
numbering to be made in the empire. This system of numbering went on for a time, 
or more probably permanently, and hence the “first” of the series is here defined 
as the occasion on which the story turns. We may assume unhesitatingly that, if 
any such system was inaugurated, it would be periodic, recurring regularly either 
once a year or after a definite term of years.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p19">It is not stated or implied by Luke that the system was 
actually put into force universally. The principle of universal enrollments for 
the empire was laid down by Augustus; but universal application of the principle 
is not mentioned That point was a matter of indifference to Luke. What he implies, 
indubitably, is that the system was put into force in Syria, for it would be quite 
irrational that he should speak as he does, unless declare that Luke refers to a 
hitherto unsuspected fact in the methods of Imperial administration.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p20">But, if our interpretation of Luke’s words is correct, 
we must frankly admit that his credit as a historian is staked on this issue: there 
was a periodical numbering or enrollment in the Syrian province, and Christ was 
born actually during the time when the first enrollment of the series was being 
made in Palestine.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p21">We observe that Luke knew about more than one “enrollment” 
or census (to use the strict Roman term). In 
<scripRef passage="Luke 2:2" id="iv.ii-p21.1" parsed="|Luke|2|2|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.2">2:2</scripRef> he speaks of a certain census 
as “the first”; in <scripRef id="iv.ii-p21.2" passage="Acts 5:37" parsed="|Acts|5|37|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.5.37">Acts 5:37</scripRef> 
he mentions the census,” i.e., the great census, meaning the epoch-making census 
taken about AD. 7, when Judea had just been incorporated in the Roman empire as 
part of the province of Syria. According to the proper and accepted canons of interpretation 
in ancient literature, he must be understood in these expressions to distinguish 
between the first census and the great census. In an ordinary Greek writer the distinction 
would be unhesitatingly drawn. Why should some scholars assume that Luke thought 
there had been one single census, as to the date of which he was in a the system 
had been in force for a time, at least, throughout the Syrian lands. Further, it 
is not easy to admit that Luke could have used these 
words, unless the system had come into permanent use.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p22">We conclude, then, that if Luke’s authority is trustworthy, 
there must have prevailed during the first century a system of numbering the population 
at periodic intervals in the Syrian province, and probably elsewhere in the Eastern 
lands, or even in the whole empire.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p23">If one had ventured ten years ago to draw this conclusion 
from the words of Luke, it would have been regarded as a <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.ii-p23.1">reductio ad absurdum</span> 
of his statement. The idea that such a system could have existed in the East, without 
leaving any perceptible signs of its existence in recorded history, would have been 
treated with ridicule as the dream of a fanatical devotee, who could believe anything 
and invent anything in support of the testimony of Luke. But now such revelations 
of order and method in the Roman Imperial Government, unmentioned and unheeded by 
historians, have resulted from epigraphic and archaeological investigation, that 
it is no longer so hazardous to state of utter confusion, when he uses language 
which in the simple and natural interpretation indicates two different census? A 
scholar should never start by assuming that the author whom he is interpreting is 
wrong; but to say that Luke in these two passages refers to one and the same census, 
is to fasten an error upon him at the outset, by disregarding the distinction indicated 
in his words.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p24">Clement of Alexandria evidently understood the words of 
Luke in the same way as we have interpreted them. He speaks of the occasion when 
first they ordered Enrollments to be made.<note n="38" id="iv.ii-p24.1"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.ii-p24.2">ὅτε πρῶτον ἐκέλευσαν 
ἀπογραφὰς γενέσθαι</span>, <i>Strom</i>., 1., 21, 147.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p25">It is hardly possible to avoid inferring from these words 
of Clement that he knew of some system of enrollments, either in the empire as a 
whole, or at least in the province of Syria. His use of the plural and of the word 
“first” force this inference upon us.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p26">Further, we shall find in 
chapter 7 that Clement, as residing in Egypt, was 
familiar with the Egyptian system of periodic enrollments. He could hardly avoid 
writing with this system in his mind, and his words imply beyond a doubt that he 
thought of some system of enrollments in Palestine. I do not see how any fair and 
unprejudiced critic can fail to conclude that Clement, 
rightly or wrongly, believed that the same system of periodic enrollments was maintained 
in Egypt and in Syria.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p27">Again, Clement expressly says that the system of enrollments 
in Syria began with the one at which the birth of Christ occurred. Luke in all probability 
was his sole ultimate authority for connecting the birth of Christ with the first 
enrollment, he, no doubt, saw the statement also in other authorities, but they 
in their turn probably got it, whether immediately or ultimately, from Luke. But 
it is not so certain that Clement had no other authority than Luke for his belief 
that the system began in the reign of Augustus. He knew the system from his own 
experience in Egypt. It had recurred there regularly throughout his own life, and 
long before his time. It must have been a matter of common knowledge in his time 
what was the origin of the system. We are, I think, fully justified in quoting Clement 
as believing that the system of enrollments which he saw round him in Egypt, and 
which he thought or knew to be also practiced in Syria, began from Augustus and 
was made according to the, orders of Augustus.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p28">A suggestion has been made that the Indictional Periods 
of fifteen years, which formed so important a feature in the administration of the 
later Roman empire, began to run from the census of Quirinius. On this theory the 
first census was taken in the year 3 BC. as the beginning of the first Indictional 
Period. But it can be shown positively that the Indictional System did not prevail 
under the early empire. The Indictions are an invention of the fourth century; and 
not merely are those periods unknown in earlier time, but a contradictory system 
existed.<note n="39" id="iv.ii-p28.1">Mr. Grenfell notes, “it is absolutely certain that the indictions began in A. D. 312, and not before,” as is shown 
by one of the Rainer papyri.</note> Moreover, it is not easy to bring the evidence as to the duration of Herod’s reign 
into consistence with the theory that he lived till 3 BC.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.ii-p29">Our whole theory is based on the determination of the periodical 
enrollment system in the early empire; and for this fortunate discovery we are indebted 
to the wonderful progress of research in Egypt during the last few years.</p>

</div2>

      <div2 title="Chapter 7. Enrollment by Households in Egypt" progress="47.73%" id="iv.iii" prev="iv.ii" next="iv.iv">

<h3 id="iv.iii-p0.1">CHAPTER 7 <br />
ENROLLMENT BY HOUSEHOLDS IN EGYPT</h3>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p1">RECENTLY, three different scholars announced about the 
same time, and independently of one another, the discovery that periodical enrollments 
were made in Egypt under the Roman empire, and that the period was not of fifteen 
years, as in the later system of indictions, but of fourteen years. The same Greek 
term is used in the Egyptian documents and in Luke to indicate the census: they 
were called “Enrollments,” <i>Apographai</i>.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p2">Mr. Kenyon of the British Museum had slightly the priority 
in briefly declaring that these “Enrollments” obeyed a cycle of fourteen years; 
but Dr. Wilcken followed him within a month or two with an elaborate paper, and 
shortly afterwards Dr. Viereck with another, discussing their period, nature and 
purpose.<note n="40" id="iv.iii-p2.1">Kenyon in <i>Classical Review</i>, 
March 1893, p. 110; Wilcken in <i>Hermes</i>, 1893, p. 203 ff.; Viereck in Philologus, 
1893, p. 219 ff. There is a short supplementary paper by Wilcken in <i>Philologus</i>, 
1893, p. 563.</note>  
The three papers are the authority for what is here stated on the subject.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p3">The facts relating to the “Enrollments” in Egypt are deduced 
from the actual census papers, many of which have been found (usually in a more 
or less fragmentary condition). The census was always taken after the end of the 
year to which it belongs; thus, for example, a census paper dated in the end of 
the year AD. 90-91 contains a statement of the facts required for the enrollment 
of 89-90, and so on. The purpose evidently was to include in each enrollment all 
children born before the end of the first year of the census period, which we shall 
henceforth call the periodic year. All dates in these documents are given according 
to the Egyptian way of reckoning; and the Egyptian year, which began on the twenty-ninth day of August, was at the basis of the whole census system in Egypt. It is 
proved that enrollments were made for the years ending in the summer of AD. 90, 
104, 118, 132 and so on till 230. An enrollment also took place under Vespasian, 
but its date is not fixed by the evidence. There can, however, be no doubt that 
Dr. Viereck is right in placing it for the year 75-76.<note n="41" id="iv.iii-p3.1">Confirmed by Mr. Kenyon’s new discovery.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p4">Though the Egyptian year was employed, the census was carried 
out by Roman officials, and formed part of the Imperial system of administration.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p5">It was the habit of the Romans in the East to adapt their 
arrangements to the custom of the country. They did not force the natives to adopt 
the Roman system of arranging the year and the months, but rather modified their 
practice to suit the native year, using an Asian year in the Province Asia, an Egyptian 
year in the Province Egypt, and so on. As the beginning and end of the years varied 
greatly in different Eastern provinces — all, however, being now solar years, like 
the Roman — we shall throughout these pages speak of the Roman year; and the reader 
will understand that in each province it has to be translated into the native year 
there employed. Censorinus mentions, as was to be expected, that the years of the 
Imperial system — <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iii-p5.1">anni Augustorum</span> — were counted from the first of January: 
they differed in this from the years of any individual emperor’s reign, which during 
the first century were usually reckoned from the day on which the reign began, though 
during the second century the habit of reckoning them from the first of January 
became general.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p6">Accordingly, instead of mentioning the enrollment for the 
Egyptian year falling in AD. 89-90, we shall call it the enrollment for the Roman 
year AD. 90. The periodic years, then, are as follows: BC. 23, BC. 9, AD. 6, 20, 
34, 48, 62, 76, 90, 104, 118, 132, 146, 160, 174, 188, 202, 216, 230, 244, 258, 
272, 286, 300, 314, 328.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p7">In every case, of course, the actual enumeration began 
after the periodic year was ended, though the enumeration is called in the documents 
the enrollment of the past (periodic) year. Usually the enrollment paper is dated 
late in the following year; people were allowed to make their declaration at any 
time during the following year, and as human nature will have it, most people delayed 
until the year was approaching its end.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p8">It appears, therefore, that already under Vespasian a system 
of periodical enrollments was the rule of Roman administration in Egypt. The existing 
documents establish its existence from AD. 76 to 230; but the failure of documents 
attesting its previous or subsequent existence affords no evidence that it began 
under Vespasian or ended under Alexander Severus. The preservation of papyri is 
so accidental and precarious, that imperfection and <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iii-p8.1">lacunae</span> are the rule 
in every department which they touch upon. We must be grateful for the light they 
throw on any subject, but it would be absurd to reason, because no fragment of papyrus 
has been found to attest a fact, that therefore the fact did not occur. The argument
<span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iii-p8.2">a silentio</span>, always a dangerous one, is especially dangerous where papyrusfragments 
are concerned.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p9">On this point Mr. Grenfell writes: “I should admit that 
the argument <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iii-p9.1">a silentio</span> cannot yet be used as regards the first century after 
Christ. About the second and third centuries it is, however, worth something, and 
also, I think, about the Ptolemaic period.” The silence of the papyri about the 
period before AD. 76 therefore constitutes no argument that the periodic enrollments 
began in that year.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p10">At the last moment Mr. Grenfell, in a letter dated 12th 
Sept., 1898, brings to my knowledge, and the courtesy of the discoverer permits 
me to mention, that Mr. Kenyon has found, and is on the point of publishing in the 
forthcoming volume of the <i>Catalogue of British Museum Papyri</i>, a document<note n="42" id="iv.iii-p10.1">CCLX. 78, 79, and CCLXI. 31, 32.</note> which mentions the enrollment for the eighth year of Nero, AD. 61-62. 
Mr. Kenyon thinks that it implies also still earlier enrollments. This important 
discovery will be regarded as a strong confirmation of the theory set forth in the 
following pages, and printed before I heard of the new evidence. The only argument 
that could be brought forward against the theory lay in the silence of the papyri; 
and already that silence is broken for part of the period. [Enrollment of AD. 20, 
see
Preface]</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p11">The question, then, must be put — at what time and through 
whose organizing initiative is the Roman series of enrollments likely to have been 
begun? The answer to that question is not doubtful. We may appeal with confidence 
to the students of Roman history, and put the question in this way. We find that 
under Vespasian a system of periodical enrollments formed a fundamental part of 
the government of Egypt: these enrollments gave a basis on which a statistical account 
of the population according to households and place of residence at the beginning 
of each period could be drawn up. Whom should we expect to have introduced the system?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p12">In the first place every one who has studied the history 
of Roman provincial administration would reply that Augustus was, in all probability, 
the originator of this Roman system in Egypt. Any important part of Egyptian administration 
which was in existence under Vespasian is probably as old as the organization of 
the country by Augustus. It is well known with what peculiar and jealous and minute 
care: he regarded that country. No Roman of senatorial or equestrian rank was permitten, even to visit it without special leave from the Emperor. It was considered 
as the granary of Rome; and it was regulated in the most careful way so that its 
harvests should be reserved for Roman needs, and its resources should be always 
calculable and certain, as far as care and forethought could make them so.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p13">It is unnecessary to do more than briefly refer to those 
facts touching the policy and intentions of Augustus which have been skillfully 
collected and marshaled by a long succession of writers on this subject — his general 
survey of the whole empire: the <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iii-p13.1">rationes imperii</span>, “a sort of balance sheet 
published periodically”: the <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iii-p13.2">libellus</span> or <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iii-p13.3">breviarium totius imperii</span>, 
a compendium of useful statistics about the kingdoms, the provinces, the allies,
<i>etc</i>.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p14">These show how carefully and methodically Augustus organized 
his splendid machinery of government on the basis of accurate, minute and complete 
knowledge of everything that concerned the subject peoples, and make it probable 
that the system of periodic enrollments, which alone rendered a complete statistical 
account of those peoples possible, originated from him, and formed part of his plan 
of Imperial administration.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p15">In the second place, the system of periodic enrollments 
is likely to be as old as Augustus, because it probably rested on a pre-Roman foundation. 
Every year’s discoveries strengthen the proof that the organization of Egypt was 
brought to a very high degree of perfection long before the Romans entered the country, 
and increase the probability that the germ or even the complete form of almost every 
detail of administration was found by Augustus already in existence in Egypt, and 
was merely adapted by him to Roman needs.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p16">Mr. Grenfell notes that the silence of the Ptolemaic papyri 
about Household-Enrollment — constitutes an argument against its being an institution 
of the Ptolemaic period; whereas valuation papers of the class (described later 
in this chapter) are found not infrequently under the Ptolemies. There must, however, 
have been in that period some kind of numbering (as Wilcken thinks). Papyri are 
found <i>c.</i> BC. 3000, “a kind of census list of a household,” naming the head 
of the house, resident female relatives, slaves, and 
young male children.<note n="43" id="iv.iii-p16.1">F. Ll. Griffith, <i>Law Quart. Rev.</i>, 1898, p. 44 f.</note> 
Two Apographai of unusual character. occur,<note n="44" id="iv.iii-p16.2">Grenfell, <i>An Alex. Erotic Papyrus, etc.</i>, Nos. 45 and 46.</note>  
resembling the Household-Enrollment papers more than the Valuation papers, and 
dated BC. 19 and 18, before the Periodic Household-Enrollment system was organized.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p17">The probability remains that Augustus originated a new 
system in Egypt of Periodic Enrollment-by-Households, developing some previously 
existing system of numbering the population.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p18">In the third place, as we saw in 
the preceding chapter, Clement of Alexandria believed that the system of enrollments 
originated from Augustus; and he expresses the general opinion held in Egypt at 
the end of the second century.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p19">In the fourth place, chronological reasons suggest that 
the enrollments come down from the organization of Augustus, because the cycle leads 
us back to the year BC. 23, from which dates the Imperial rule of Augustus in the 
most formal and complete sense. The Roman emperors, beginning from Augustus, reckoned 
the years of their reign according to their tenure of the <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iii-p19.1">tribunicia potestas</span>, which constituted them “Champions 
of the Commons”; Augustus received the tribunician power on 27th June, BC. 23; and 
the number of years in his Imperial title is reckoned invariably in all later inscriptions 
from that date. The Coincidence that the EnrollmentCycle was arranged according 
to the official years of Augustus’s reign, is conclusive in favor of the view that 
Augustus inaugurated the system of periodical enrollments.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p20">This coincidence, also, shows with almost complete certainty 
that the Fourteen-Years’-Cycle was not devised in Egypt, or for Egypt alone. Mr. 
Grenfell points out to me that in Egypt the reign of Augustus was invariably reckoned 
from the taking of Alexandria, the first year being considered to begin on 29th 
August, BC. 30; and there is not a trace of any other reckoning of his reign in 
the country. Had the Enrollment-Cycle been an Egyptian matter simply, it is in 
the last degree improbable that it would have been arranged according to the years 
of the tribunician power.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p21">On the other hand, that was the natural system in general 
Imperial matters. It was the only method of reckoning which was known universally 
throughout the empire: it was employed in every official statement of the Emperor’s title: it was sometimes used even in dating private 
inscriptions.<note n="45" id="iv.iii-p21.1">See <i>e.g. Varia</i> 2. in <i>Classical Review</i>, Oct., 1898.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p22">The use of this epoch, further, proves in all probability 
that the Enrollment was, as Luke says, actually held first for the year BC. 9. It 
could not be devised until after the reign began, for the epoch was unknown until 
the epoch-making event had occurred; and, after it had occurred, no time remained 
to arrange all the details for an Imperial enrollment for the current year. Hence 
we find a different style of enrollment paper used in Egypt in the years BC. 19 
and 18.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p23">We see also why the Egyptian year 24-23, and not 23-22, 
was taken as that correspondent to the Roman year 23. Augustus’s reign began during 
the Egyptian year 24-23, two months before the end of that year on 29th August. 
Thus the reign of Augustus began officially in the Egyptian year BC. 24-23. On 
the other hand, in any country where the year began in the spring, the official 
year 1 of Augustus would be the year BC. 23-22; and the year 15, which was the 
first periodic year, would be BC. 9-8.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p24">These reasons justify the reasonable confidence that Augustus 
arranged a system of periodical “enrollments” in Egypt. As the system is fixed according 
to the year BC. 23, in which the fully formed constitutional Principate was organized 
and the reign of Augustus in the official reckoning began, the arrangement of this 
system must have taken place later than that year. The system of enrollments must 
therefore be distinguished from the operation called by Marquardt<note n="46" id="iv.iii-p24.1"><i><a id="iv.iii-p24.2" />Rom. Staatsrecht</i>, 2., p. 212 f.</note> 
the provincial census, which began to be taken in Gaul in BC. 27.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p25">The latter operation was intended to form the basis on 
which the taxation of the provinces of the empire should be regulated. It was repeated 
from time to time throughout the period of the empire, and was an essential part 
of the orderly working of the Imperial administration. That taxation should be proportionate 
to wealth was a Roman principle, and without frequent revaluation of property it 
was impossible to secure a fair apportionment of taxation. Augustus fully recognized 
the vast importance of making correct valuation of property in the provinces, as 
securing both fair taxation and a more lucrative revenue for the State.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p26">Such enumeration and valuation of property was confined, 
as a rule, to Roman provinces, and was often made as soon as any new province was 
incorporated in the empire. Such, for example, was the case in Palestine when Quirinius, 
in his second Syrian governorship, made that country part of the empire. The novel 
proceedings on that occasion, and the strict inquisition into value of property, 
brought vividly home to the Jews that they were now wholly reduced to servitude 
under a foreign power, and led to much disorder and rebellion. The name census was 
used by the Romans to denote this characteristic institution. In modern usage the 
term census denotes the periodic numbering of the people, without valuation of property. 
In this study we use the terms “valuation” or “rating” and “enrollment”.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p27">But the system of periodic enrollments in Egypt is quite 
different from the system of rating and valuation. The latter system also existed 
in Egypt; many census papers are preserved among the papyri, and Wilcken gives several 
examples of them on pp. 231-240 of the article which we have quoted above. These 
valuations seem to have been made annually;<note n="47" id="iv.iii-p27.1">Mr. Grenfell notes, “for ‘seem to 
have been’ you might say ‘were’: there are hundreds of instances to show it”.</note>  
and it is often stated in the papers that the census is taken according to the orders 
of the governor of the province. They contain an enumeration and precise definition 
of all property in land, houses, and live stock<note n="48" id="iv.iii-p27.2">Mr. Kenyon notes, “returns of live stock are separate”.</note>  
belonging to the enumerator, often also a statement whether the property is free 
from debt or mortgage, and often an estimate of the money value, of the whole. Where 
there is no estimate of value, it is understood that the value is unchanged from 
previous valuations and can be found in the older official registers.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p28">The same verb <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.iii-p28.1">ἀπογράφομαι</span> 
is used in both kinds of papyri, and both operations seem to have been termed <i>
Apographai</i>. But the periodic enrollment papers are distinguished by other criteria 
besides the want of statistics about property and money value; they are dated according 
to the year of the reigning emperor, and contain no reference to the orders of the 
governor; they state accurately and exactly which periodic enrollment they are intended 
for; and they always use the phrase “Enrollment-by-Household”,
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.iii-p28.2">ἀπογραφὴ κατ᾽ οἰκίαν</span>. 
These periodic enrollments according to the Four-teen-Years’-Cycle<note n="49" id="iv.iii-p28.3">The Romans, who counted both initial 
and final years in each period, would have called it a Fifteen-Years’-Cycle; 
it was held in years 1, 15, 29, <i>etc</i>. We call that a Cycle of fourteen years.</note>  
were therefore closely connected with the existing households, and served as basis 
for an enumeration of the total population. This operation obviously corresponds much more closely than the other kind of Egyptian 
census to the “enrollment” alluded to by Luke; and we shall therefore always allude 
to it as the enrollment system, or, more accurately, enrollment-by-household.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p29">The enrollment papers were filled up and sent in to the 
proper official by the heads of households. In the enrollment paper, the householder 
specified the house, or part of a house, which belonged to him; he declared that 
he was formally enrolling himself and his family for the house-to-house enrollment 
of the past year, twenty-eight of the Emperor Commodus, or whatever else the case 
was. But, if the owner did not live in the house himself, he enrolled only the tenants; 
if he kept lodgers, he enrolled himself, his family and the lodgers. He gave a complete 
enumeration of all the individuals who lived in the house, children, relatives, 
etc. In one case, twenty-seven persons are enumerated in one paper by a householder. 
No statement of income or of the money value of the house is given in the enrollment 
papers.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p30">Thus, according to our theory, the nature of the case led 
the Romans to adopt a double system, which presents a remarkable analogy to our 
modern methods. We have an enumeration of the people every ten years, the census: 
the Romans numbered the people every fourteen years. We have an annual making up 
of the valuation roll, and an annual system of income tax returns. The Romans, likewise, 
found it expedient to require annual valuation of property; but they did not require 
any estimate of annual income, for they, like the United States, arranged their 
taxes, not according to income, but according to property.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p31">The intention of this system of enrollment by households 
has been investigated by Wilcken. It furnished a complete enumeration of the population 
of Egypt; both provincials and resident Romans had to fill up their enrollment papers 
and send them in to the proper official. The papers not merely furnished the total 
numbers of the population; they were also useful in allotting the various burdens 
of public service, and especially they facilitated the conscription; and finally 
they gave information which aided in levying the poll-tax, determining the classes 
of persons who were free from the tax, and the date at which each male became of age to pay it (fourteen), or reached the age of 
exemption (sixty).<note n="50" id="iv.iii-p31.1">So Kenyon writes correcting Wilcken’s 
published statement. In Syria women, as well as men, paid; and the age was fourteen 
for men, twelve for women, until sixty-five, Ulpian, <i>Dig</i>., L. 15, 3.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p32">According to Marquardt, 2., p. 199, a poll-tax was levied 
by the Romans only in countries where it had been customary from ancient times, 
or where there was for the time no survey of property available to furnish a standard 
for a more rational kind of tax. He is disposed to consider the <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iii-p32.1">tributum capitis</span> in the province of Syria as not a 
poll-tax, but a tax on those engaged in an industrial occupation; but Wilcken seems 
clearly right in regarding the Syrian tax as a poll-tax, exactly similar to the 
Egyptian poll-tax.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p33">Thus the Egyptian documents, and the inferences founded 
on them by comparison with other evidence, have revealed two most important and 
hitherto unsuspected facts.</p>
<div style="margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align:justify; margin-top:9pt" id="iv.iii-p33.1">
<p class="continue" id="iv.iii-p34"><b>(1) </b>In some parts at least of the empire the enrollment and numbering of 
the population according to their households was a distinct and separate 
process from the census and valuation, which previously was considered 
to be the only properly Roman kind of census.</p>
<p class="continue" id="iv.iii-p35"><b>(2) </b>The enrollment by households took place periodically, 
according to a cycle arranged according to the years of the reign of 
Augustus in Imperial, but not in Egyptian, reckoning. Probably this 
system was introduced later than 18 BC.</p>
</div>
<hr />
<p class="center" id="iv.iii-p36"><b>NOTE</b></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iii-p37">Papyrus Br. Mus. CCLX. is a poll-tax register of AD. 72-3, based on the Household-Enrollment of 61-2; and references to older poll-tax 
registers are made, which imply previous Enrollments. In fact the register is part 
of an existing system of some standing. [The Household-Enrollment of AD. 20 has 
just been discovered: see Preface].</p>


</div2>

      <div2 title="Chapter 8. The Syrian Enrollment in 8 BC" progress="54.33%" id="iv.iv" prev="iv.iii" next="iv.v">

<h3 id="iv.iv-p0.1">CHAPTER 8 <br />
THE SYRIAN ENROLLMENT IN 8 BC</h3>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p1">IN the preceding chapter we have seen that, in all probability, 
Augustus inaugurated a series of enrollments in Egypt. Now, according to Luke, Augustus 
laid down the principle that “enrollments” should be made over the whole Roman world; 
and this assertion stands on a very different level of probability from that which 
it occupied before the Egyptian discovery. If Luke be wrong, his error has been 
to extend over the whole Roman world a practice which Augustus established in Egypt. 
Every one must see that such an extension is not likely to have been made without 
some justification by the author of Acts, whoever he was. If there is anything certain 
about him it is that he had neither connection with Egypt nor interest in it, and 
that he was entirely uninfluenced by Alexandrian thought or Egyptian ideas; he even 
omits from his Gospel the incident of the flight into Egypt, which a writer connected 
with Egypt would be most unlikely to do. Such an author is not likely to have known 
about institutions peculiar to Egypt; and, if he thinks that the system of periodical 
enrollments, which existed in Egypt, was also found in other parts of the Roman 
world, there is a strong presumption that such was the case at least in those parts 
of the world which were best known to him. The reasons stated above, chapters
6 and
7, 
confirm this presumption.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p2">Other considerations, also, prove that some attempt was 
made in Syria, whether systematically or sporadically, to number the population 
Such enumerations can be traced back to the reign of Augustus and to the government 
of Syria by Quirinius.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p3">An inscription, which was long the subject of keen controversy 
and was condemned by Mommsen and many others as a forgery,<note n="51" id="iv.iv-p3.1">Absolutely the only reason for thinking 
it to be a forgery was that it mentioned the census of Quirinius, and therefore 
seemed to give some support to Luke. But as this might be the historical census 
of Quirinius in AD. 7, the support was very slight and indirect; and, if a forger 
were inventing a support for Luke, he would hardly be content with such a small 
result for his work. See Mommsen in <i>Ephemeris Epigraphica</i>, 4., p. 588, 
on the rediscovery of the stone.</note> was recently found to be genuine, when half of the long-lost stone on which it 
was engraved was rediscovered in Venice. In that inscription, which records the 
career of Q Aemilius Secundus, a Roman officer, who served under Quirinius when 
governor of Syria, it is mentioned that by the orders of Quirinius he made the “census” 
of the population of Apameia, enumerating 117,000 citizens. The emphasis laid on 
the number suggests (though it does not demonstrate) 
that the numbering of the total population was the chief object of the Apamean “census”; 
in that case it would correspond to the periodic enrollment by households in Egypt 
rather than to the annual valuation.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p4">The inscription leaves it uncertain whether the Apamean 
numbering occurred in the first or second administration of Syria by Quirinius. 
He is called <i>legatus Caesaris Syriae</i>, without<i> iterum</i>, but there was 
no need for expressing in the inscription that he had held the government of Syria 
on two separate occasions. Our opponents, who hold that there was only one census 
under Quirinius, are justified in maintaining that this inscription refers to a 
numbering of the population of Syria, made by Quirinius in AD. 7 concurrently with 
his census and valuation in Palestine. We, on our side, are, for a different reason, 
bound to maintain that Quirinius ordered this enrollment of Apameia (and of all 
the other states of Syria) to be made in AD. 7, as will appear in chapters
9 and
11.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p5">Again, Suidas mentions that Augustus numbered the population 
of the territory that belonged to the Romans, and it was found to be 4,101,017 men 
(<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.iv-p5.1">ἄνδρες</span>). 
It is obvious that Suidas did not simply invent this number, but had access to some 
other authority besides Luke (whom he quotes in one of the two places<note n="52" id="iv.iv-p5.2">Suidas,<i> s. vv</i>.<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.iv-p5.3">Ἀπογραφὴ</span> and
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.iv-p5.4">Αὐγοῦστος</span>.</note>  
where he refers to this enumeration of the Roman world). The question is how far 
any confidence can be placed in that other authority. Had he real knowledge at his 
command?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p6">The number seems so small as to be absurd. Josephus<note n="53" id="iv.iv-p6.1"><i>Bell. Jud</i>., 2., 16, 4.</note> gives the population of Egypt, Alexandria excepted, as 7,500,000. Adding 
500,00 as the population of Alexandria, we have the total Egyptian population, 8,000,000. 
But, according to Suidas, the population of the entire Roman world would not be 
much more than 21,000,000. Probably the populous countries of Syria and Asia Minor 
alone contained more than 21,000,000 inhabitants, though we must remember that no 
slaves were counted in the enrollments.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p7">The most probable supposition is that Suidas is giving 
an inaccurate account of the total of Roman citizens. A numbering of Roman citizens 
was three times made by Augustus — 28 BC., 8 BC. and 14 AD. — and the total was 
in each case between 4,000,000 and 5,000,000. The liability of numbers to corruption 
is exemplified in the result of Augustus’s first 80 
census. The Latin text of the <i>Monumentum Ancyranum</i>, expressed in Augustus’s 
own words, gives the total as 4,063,000, but the Greek translation gives 4,603,000, 
while Eusebius has it as 4,164,000. In the third census, Eusebius probably gave 
the correct total; but Jerome in his Latin version and the Armenian translator have 
both gone wrong in rendering Eusebius’s words. Suidas, finding this total in Eusebius, 
took it as representing the total population of the empire, instead of the sum of <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iv-p7.1">cives Romant</span>, an error which was easily made after 
the time of Caracalla, when all free citizens of the empire were <i>cives Romani</i>. 
Further, like Jerome, he misunderstood the numbers in Eusebius. Syncellus gives 
the total in still another form.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p8">Thus Suidas, when we trace him back, is found to have been 
using a distinct and good authority, but to be misunderstanding and misrepresenting 
it. He throws no light on Luke’s statement.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p9">Further, there is a certain amount of positive evidence 
that “Enrollments” according to the Fourteen-Years’-Cycle were made in Syria and 
elsewhere. According to Luke, the first enrollment was made a few years BC. in the 
unknown year of Christ’s birth, which is variously fixed, and must have been somewhere 
between 8 and 3 BC.. On the system that obtained in Egypt, the year 9 BC. would 
be the beginning of the second period; and the scanty evidence that exists about 
the general survey of the empire, shows that any enrollment according to the Cycle 
is not likely to have been made until the beginning of the second period. We find, 
then, that the year 8 BC. was the one in which the first “enrollment” would naturally 
begin to be made, if a Cycle was observed; for this enrollment was intended, as 
has been stated already, to include all children born in 9 BC. Now Tertullian declares 
that an “enrollment” was made by Sentius Saturninus, who was governor of Syria from 
about 9 to 7 BC. It is obvious that Tertullian did not make this assertion on Luke’s 
authority, nor with the intention of bolstering up Luke. On the contrary, it has 
always been a serious problem how his statement can be reconciled with Luke’s words. 
It can hardly be doubted that Tertullian was aware of the discrepancy between his 
own words and those of Luke; but he remains true to his own principle that “this 
world’s things must be tested by its own documents”.<note n="54" id="iv.iv-p9.1"><span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iv-p9.2">De uis enim instrumentis saecularia 
probari necesse est</span> (<i>de Cor.</i> 7).</note> He had the authority of Roman documents that Sentius Saturninus was the governor 
in question; and he prefers to follow “this world’s 
documents”. The discrepancy with Luke would not trouble him; his belief was too 
robust-to be affected by trifles of that kind; but whether or not he understood 
how the apparent discrepancy arose, he at any rate followed his Roman authority 
in this detail.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p10">Tertullian’s procedure was probably this: he knew that 
an enrollment period fell in 9 BC. which was the first enrollment; and Roman authorities, 
either official documents or historians, showed him that Sentius Saturninus was 
governor of Syria at that time. The only other alternative seems to be that he investigated 
Roman documents, and found evidence that a census of Syria had been held by Saturninus. 
In the former case he was aware of the Fourteen-Years’-Cycle; in the latter case 
he knew of a census of Syria about 9-7 BC. and in either case he is an important 
yet independent witness in favor of Luke, so far as concerns the reality of a Syrian 
enrollment about 9-7 BC.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p11">We must observe that it was possible for any one living 
in the first or second or third century to discover for himself the facts about 
any of these early enrollments, if he were willing to take a little trouble and 
show a little care. Accurate observation, registration and preservation of all facts 
formed the basis of Roman Imperial administration. We know from Pliny<note n="55" id="iv.iv-p11.1"><i>Nat. Hist.,</i> 7., 48 (159).</note> 
that the facts obtained at every census were so carefully preserved that in 48 AD. 
Claudius could verify from the records of earlier numberings the statement, which 
a citizen of a small Italian town made about his age; and there can be no doubt 
that similar careful preservation was the rule everywhere, as is proved in Egypt. 
Abundant material existed on which, the historian who was willing to take trouble 
could base an accurate narrative of facts. With an author of ordinary ability and 
care, serious error could hardly arise except from intention to mislead; though, 
of course, a slip in some unimportant detail may be made by any man, however careful, 
and probably none are free from them, not even Mommsen himself, whose grasp of detail 
is so marvelous.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p12">The discrepancy between Tertullian, who seems to connect 
the birth of Christ with the enrollment of Saturninus, and Luke, who connects that 
event with the enrollment of Quirinius, will engage our attention in chapter 
11. For the moment our purpose is to show that the Egyptian enrollment periods 
were observed in Syria and elsewhere. But the existence of such a discrepancy is the conclusive proof that Tertullian had good 
evidence to trust to. He would never have contradicted Luke as regards the name, 
unless he had obtained the fact on undeniable authority.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p13">In the same year 8 BC.., in which “enrollments” seem to 
have been made in Syria and in Egypt, Augustus, as he mentions in his official review 
of his own life, made a census and found that the total number of Roman citizens 
in the whole empire was 4,233,000. A similar numbering of Roman citizens had been 
made by him in 28 BC.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p14">The fact that Augustus’s first two enumerations show an 
interval of twenty years forms no argument against our theory of a Fourteen-Years’Cycle. 
The first enumeration was made before the plan was initiated, and the second, the 
initiation of the plan, was fixed according to the epoch of 23 BC.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p15">At any rate, 8 BC. was a marked year in the administration 
of the city of Rome. In that year, Augustus gave Rome a new municipal organization, 
dividing it into regions and quarters; and in a certain class of Roman city inscriptions, 
it is reckoned as the year 1 of an epoch which remained in use for a time. It was 
not an Imperial epoch; it was merely used in dating some documents connected with 
the new Roman municipal system, and the year I did not agree with the first of the 
Fourteen-Years’-Cycle, but was taken at, the: first year in which the new municipal 
system was actually in existence.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p16">The next periodic year was 6 AD. and the enrollment would, 
therefore, naturally be taken in the following year, 7 AD. Quirinius was governor 
of Syria for the second time in 6 and the following years; and he held “the great 
census” and valuation of Palestine, as Josephus records. Judea was now incorporated 
in the empire, administered by a <i>Procurator</i>, and connected with the Province 
Syria; and a complete set of statistics of the new territory was required as the 
basis of the Roman organization. “The great enrollment” might, it is true, be plausibly 
explained as due merely to the necessities of administration in a newly incorporated 
part of the empire. But it is, at least, an interesting coincidence that it should 
tally with the beginning of a new Cycle. Moreover, it is practically almost certain 
that Quirinius made a numbering of the population of Syria in 7 AD. as we have gathered 
from the inscription of Aemilius Secundus, <i>previously 
qouted</i>. The natural inference from the known facts is that two operations, one 
corresponding to the Egyptian periodic enrollment and one corresponding to the Egyptian 
annual census and valuation, occurred in Palestine in 7 AD.; and that the periodic 
enrollment at least, if not the other also, was made throughout the province of 
Syria.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p17">The Cycle beginning 6 AD. seems not to have been observed 
by Augustus himself in Rome. It is well known that, as he grew old and feeble, his 
administration became more lax. Possibly, as Luke declares, he intended in 9 BC. 
to begin a series of “enrollments” for the empire; but, if he had that intention, 
the idea was too great for the time and was not fully carried into effect. The administrative 
machinery of the empire was not as yet sufficiently perfect and smooth-working 
to be able to carry into regular execution such a great idea; and Augustus postponed 
the next numbering of Roman citizens, until Tiberius was associated with him in 
the government, when 4,937,000 Roman citizens were numbered, 14 AD. Dion Cassius 
indeed mentions that in 4 AD. Augustus made a partial census; but that would be 
two years too early; and, as Mommsen and others have shown, Dion Cassius’s account 
of the various numberings made by Augustus is wrong in almost every case, and his 
assertion about a census in 4 AD. cannot be credited on his sole authority. Mommsen, 
therefore, rejects it as an error of Dion’s.<note n="56" id="iv.iv-p17.1">Mommsen, <i>Monum. Ancyran</i>., ed. 2., p. 37.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p18">The next periodic year fell in 20 AD.; but no evidence 
survives to show that it was observed in any part of the Roman empire. Perhaps after 
the numbering of Roman citizens in 14, it was considered unnecessary by Tiberius 
to hold another in 20; and our authorities hardly ever mention any numberings except 
of <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.iv-p18.1">cives Romani</span>.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p19">The following census period began with 34 AD.; and it would 
appear that the numbering was held in the Province Syria in 35, as was usual. This 
we gather indirectly from the fact that an attempt was made by King Archelaos to 
enforce a census after the Roman style in his kingdom of Cilicia Tracheia. Now this 
kingdom was always considered as a dependency of the Province Syria;<note n="57" id="iv.iv-p19.1">Strictly the province was termed <i>Syria et Cilicia et Phoenice</i>.</note> 
and, when any Roman interference in its affairs was needed, the Syrian governor 
marched an army into the Tracheiotis. Archelaos’s attempt, therefore, implies that 
the census of Syria was taken in 35, and was observed also in the dependent kingdom 
of Tracheiotis. It may be regarded as obviously true 
that Archelaos acted under Roman orders, for the imposition of a Roman custom on 
the free Cilicians, as if they had been inhabitants of a Roman province, was a curtailment 
of his rights, which he was not likely to initiate of his own accord, and which 
a monarch would not allow except under compulsion. But nations which were not thoroughly 
Romanised strongly objected to the census as a mark of subjection to the foreigner 
and as a serious step forward in the process of Romanising their country. King Archelaos 
was considered by his subjects to be weakly helping to impose on them the Roman 
yoke with his own hand. Disturbances broke out among the Kietai,<note n="58" id="iv.iv-p19.2">Tacitus, <i>Annals</i>, 6., 41, and Wilhelm, <i>Arch. Epigr. Mittheilungen</i>, 1894, p. 1 ff.</note> 
the leading people of Cilicia Tracheia; and, after the power of King Archelaos had 
proved insufficient to quell their, rebellion, the presence of Roman troops was 
required; and finally, in 36 AD. Vitellius, the governor of Syria, sent an army 
to his aid.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p20">As in “the great enrollment” of Palestine in 7 AD., there 
was made in Cilicia in 35 AD. both a numbering of the population and a valuation 
of their property. A simple numbering of the people might not be felt so grievous, 
but a valuation of property seemed to be the beginning of incorporation in a province.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p21">Some scholars understand that the census among the Kietai 
was held because they had been subjected to the Roman authority and incorporated 
in the province. But Tacitus distinctly states that they were subject to Archelaos, 
and continued to hold out against his troops. His language is quite explicit, and 
could be misinterpreted only through prejudice. Moreover, if the Kietai had been 
incorporated in the province, that would show even more conclusively that an enrollment 
of the province was made in 34-5 AD.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p22">The next periodic year fell in 48; and Tacitus mentions 
that the Emperor Claudius held a census of the Roman citizens in that year, and 
numbered 6,944,000. He was personally engaged as censor in the operations at Ostia 
in the middle of October, 48 AD. The individual householders recorded their age 
in these numberings, just as they did in the Egyptian enrollments, for Pliny mentions 
that a citizen of Bononia stated his age as 150; Claudius thereupon ordered that 
his record in previous census should be examined, and his statements were found 
to be consistent.<note n="59" id="iv.iv-p22.1">Tacitus, <i>Annals</i>, 9., 25, 31; 
Suetonius, <i>Claud</i>., 16; Pliny, <i>Nat. Hist</i>., 7., 48 (159).</note> 
This fact, mentioned incidentally by Pliny, proves 
that several census had previously been taken, and suggests that there was a system 
and a definite plan in the enumerations. No one who considers the method of the 
Romans and the orderly character of all their work, will regard it as probable that 
the taking of these general numberings was left purely to the caprice of the emperor. 
Some plan and order must have been aimed at, though the weakness or caprice of the 
emperors might occasionally disturb the order. The existence of some underlying 
plan is inexorably demanded; and if the plan which existed in Egypt was not common 
to the whole empire, one asks what was the plan elsewhere, and why the empire followed 
separate plans in different regions.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p23">Claudius evidently made his numbering a few months too 
early, before the periodic year was ended.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p24">The succeeding census period, beginning in 62 AD. is not 
known to have been observed in any part of the Roman world except Egypt (where Mr. 
Kenyon’s new discovery has revealed it); and the Subsequent one, 76 AD. was anticipated 
in Italy by two years, for Vespasian and Titus held the censorship in 73 and 74,<note n="60" id="iv.iv-p24.1">Beginning April 73 (according to Chambalu, <i>de magistrat. Flaviorum</i>, quoted by Goyau, <i>Chronologie de 
l’Emp. Rom., s. a</i>.) their office lasted eighteen months. See Pliny, <i>Nat. Hist.,</i> 7., 49 (162).</note> 
and made all enumeration of Roman citizens.</p>

<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p25">These facts, most of them only slight in themselves, establish 
in conjunction a strong case that the periods of the Egyptian enrollments were frequently 
coincident with the holding of census in some other parts of the empire; and thus 
the presumption is strengthened that the Egyptian Fourteen-Years’-Cycle has its 
root in a principle of wider application. This brings us very near to Luke’s statement 
that Augustus laid down a general principle of taking census of the whole Roman 
world. The supposition that his statement is true has now ceased to be out of keeping 
with extra-scriptural evidence. On the contrary, Luke’s statement supplies the 
missing principle which holds together and explains and makes consistent all the 
rest of the evidence. When Luke’s evidence is held correct, the other recorded facts 
fall into line with it, and are seen to be the working of one general principle. 
Though weakness sometimes failed to carry out the principle, and though in other 
cases the time was anticipated a little, yet the recorded facts show a clear tendency 
to conform to the Cycle.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p26">In a number of cases nothing except the census of Roman 
citizens is recorded. Almost all Romans, with characteristic Roman pride, regarded 
a census of the subject population as beneath the dignity of historical record. 
Augustus himself, in that famous record of his achievements, which is commonly known 
as the <i>Monumentum Ancyranum</i>, mentions only his census of Roman citizens. 
Distinct evidence exists that the first and second periodic enrollments were carried 
out in Syria; but the Emperor thought them unworthy of notice in his review of his 
services to the State. Similarly it is only by indirect inference, through the accident 
that a rebellion was provoked, that we learn of the fourth enrollment in Syria. 
The Romans of that period did not agree with our estimate of what was most important 
in their history; and we must be very chary of drawing negative inferences merely 
from their silence. Evidence about the details of the Augustan system of provincial 
administration had almost completely perished, until inscriptions began to reveal 
a few isolated facts.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p27">Hence the silence of Augustus about the scheme of an Imperial 
census affords no argument against his having projected such a scheme. In his review 
of his career, Augustus says nothing about the reorganization of the. provincial 
administration (which, to our judgment, is almost the most important fact in his 
career); he mentions nothing about the provinces except the colonies which he founded 
in Pisidia, Gallia, <i>etc</i>., and the colonies are mentioned simply because they 
were settlements of Roman citizens. He therefore could not, ill accordance with 
his own plan, mention the scheme of numbering the subject population; he only speaks 
of the numbering of the Romans. Moreover, the principle of periodic enrollments 
appears not to have been, perhaps, carried out completely, and could not claim a 
place in the list of the emperor’s achievements.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p28">The most important fact is that we have clear evidence, 
quite independent of Luke, that the first, second and fourth periodic enrollments 
were observed ill the Province Syria. The evidence for the first is Christian, and 
is therefore commonly set aside, except when the “critical” — or rather uncritical 
— theologian desires to bring out that these Christians don’t even agree with one 
another: then he quotes Tertullian.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p29">The evidence for the second. periodic enrollment in Syria 
lies in the chance preservation of an inscription, ill which a Roman officer recorded 
his service at Apameia; but this evidence was long 
discredited as a forgery, made in modern times by some person who wanted’ to illustrate 
Luke, and pretended to have copied the inscription from a stone. The demolition 
of a house in Venice revealed the stone, and justified the inscription.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p30">The evidence for the fourth periodic inscription is, found 
in Tacitus. Had the authority been a mere Christian, his words would have been ridiculed 
and disregarded.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p31">But three occurrences are sufficient to show what was the 
law of recurrence. If the other evidence is enough to suggest that some system was 
recognized in Syria, then the three dates show that the Fourteen-Years’-Cycle was 
the system which was followed there.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p32">Further, we observe that in all three cases it is only 
by a mere accident that we learn about the occurrence of a census — a casual reference 
in Terullian’s disputation against a heretic: the chance preservation of an inscription 
in Venice: the fact that a disturbance in a dependent kingdom was too serious for 
the king’s strength, and required the intervention of the Roman arms, and thus rose 
to the level of dignity required for mention in Tacitus’s <i>Annals</i>. The ordinary 
class of inscriptions on stone does not mention events of this kind, except through 
an occasional chance, as,<i> e.g</i>., that some private: 
individual was specially concerned with the taking of a census (like Aeimilius Secundus). 
But we cannot expect many such chances, as have preserved the memory of the three 
enrollments in Syria.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p33">In Syria there existed the same reasons which are considered 
by Wilcken to have required the periodic enrollment by households in Egypt. In both 
countries there existed a poll-tax (which was not a general Roman institution): 
conscription and imposition of various burdens in the State service were common 
to all parts of the empire: hence the periodic enrollments would enable the machinery 
of government to work with much greater ease and certainty in Syria.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p34">Any rational and scholarly criticism must accept the conclusion: 
There was a system of periodic enrollment in the Province Syria, according to a 
Fourteen-Years’-Cycle (in the modern expression — Fifteen-Years’-Cycle in the 
Roman form), and the first enrollment was made in the year 8 BC. (strictly the Syrian 
year beginning in the spring of 8 BC.).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p35">The fact that there exists no evidence of such frequent 
taking of census in Syria, as we suppose, constitutes no disproof of our theory. 
The evidence has perished. Twenty years ago no one dreamed to what a degree of minuteness 
and perfection the registration of inhabitants, property and values in Egypt was 
carried by the Romans. The evidence seemed to have perished. Now the graves and 
rubbish-heaps of Egypt have begun to give up their evidence; and our knowledge 
of Roman provincial administration has entered on a new stage. But elsewhere we 
cannot hope for such discoveries as in Egypt, for other climates are too moist to 
allow paper to survive. But the analogy of Egyptian administration is a strong argument 
as regards Syria; and, if Augustus instituted periodic enrollments in Egypt, the 
evidence of Luke, implying that he ordered a similar system in the whole empire, 
and that the system was carried into effect in Syria, has every probability in its 
favor and will be accepted by every candid historian.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p36">We have the evidence of Justin Martyr<note n="61" id="iv.iv-p36.1"><i>Apolog.</i>, 1., 34. Felix, governor 
of Egypt, is mentioned in it, and he governed Egypt about 150.</note> 
a native of Syria, writing about 150 AD., that the tabulated information gathered 
from the periodic enrollments of the province was preserved, and might be consulted 
by any who doubted the evidence of Luke. Writing to the emperor, the Caesars, the 
senate, and the people of Rome, he tells them that they can learn the facts regarding 
the birth of Christ from the registers made under Quirinius. It is obvious that 
Justin had not himself consulted the registers. He merely knew that they existed 
and might be consulted. The facts he takes from Luke, and challenges all to disprove 
them by appeal to the registers.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p37">Similarly Tertullian<note n="62" id="iv.iv-p37.1">Apolog. 5.</note> 
appeals to the letter of Marcus Aurelius, in which he had informed the senate of 
the important service rendered by Christian soldiers in the German war. He had not 
seen the letter himself, but he knew that all such documents addressed to the senate 
were preserved, and challenged his readers to consult the letter for themselves.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p38">It would be quite fair to quote Tertullian as evidence 
(if any evidence were needed) that such Imperial letters were preserved in official 
records; and similarly it is quite fair to quote Justin as evidence that the registers 
of the Syrian enrollments were preserved and might be consulted by those who wished.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p39">Mr. Kenyon writes that natives of Egypt refer to previous 
enrollments as evidence of relationship, <i>etc.</i> Josephus,<i> Vit.,</i> 1., 
apparently is quoting similar enrollment-registers, when he speaks of the evidence 
for his family history.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.iv-p40">Justin himself had no desire or need to consult the registers 
in order to be convinced. It was quite enough for him that Luke recorded the facts; 
and he asked no further evidence. As to questions of date and officials he felt 
no interest. Perhaps he may have interpreted Luke’s words as referring to Quirinius’s 
second government of Syria in 6-7 AD.; but he styles him procurator of Palestine, 
which does not suit that or any office held by him, for the procuratorship was an 
equestrian position, while Quirinius was of senatorial rank. But it tended to convince 
the Romans that the Gospels as a whole were true, if these little details were found 
to be correctly stated; and therefore he challenges his readers to verify them for 
themselves.</p>

</div2>

      <div2 title="Chapter 9. King Herod’s Enrollment" progress="63.16%" id="iv.v" prev="iv.iv" next="iv.vi">
<h3 id="iv.v-p0.1">CHAPTER 9 <br />
KING HEROD’S ENROLLMENT</h3>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p1">THE first enrollment in Syria was made in the year 8-7 
BC., but a consideration of the situation in Syria and Palestine about that time 
will show that the enrollment in Herod’s kingdom was probably delayed for some time 
later.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p2">Herod occupied a delicate and difficult position on the 
throne of Judea. On the one hand he had to comply with what was required of him 
by the Imperial policy; he was governing for the Romans a part of the empire, and 
he was bound to spread western customs and language and civilization among his subjects, 
and fit them for their position in the Roman world. Above all, the prime requirement 
was that he must maintain peace and order; the Romans knew well that no civilizing 
process could go on, so long as disorder and disturbance and insecurity existed 
in the country. Herod’s duty was to keep the peace and naturalize the Graeco-Roman 
civilization in Palestine.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p3">On the other hand, he must soothe the feelings and accommodate 
himself to the prejudices of the jealous and suspicious people whom he governed. 
He could not hope to keep the peace among them, unless he humored their prejudices. 
They hated and despised Roman ideas, and they were intensely attached to their own 
customs. Their customs had all a religious foundation, and they could not comply 
with foreign requirements without doing violence to their deep-rooted pride of 
religion and their lofty contempt for the pagans by whom they were surrounded. Everything 
Roman was to them a heathen abomination; and, if Herod seemed to them to be forcing 
on them anything Roman, insurrection was almost certain to follow. But it was absolutely 
necessary to prevent insurrection, which was likely to make Augustus quite as angry 
with him as with the insurgents.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p4">On the whole, Herod had been successful in his ambiguous 
position. He built many fortresses and many cities of the Graeco-Roman type, with 
temples of the Graeco-Roman gods, beginning with the god incarnate, the emperor himself, whose refusal to accept Divine honors was 
not very much regarded in the eastern lands. That was the approved method of spreading 
the Graeco-Roman civilization. The “city” was originally a Greek creation, and 
every city tended towards the cosmopolitan type of the Roman empire. Education, 
luxury, commerce, imitation of western manners, dislike for the national and “barbarian” 
manners, use of the Greek language, were encouraged in the crowded and feverish 
line of cities; and the national piety and the national exclusiveness found it more 
difficult to maintain themselves in their old strength.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p5">But Jerusalem was left still Hebrew in spite of the theater 
and amphitheater and fortress called Antonia, which Herod built. There was really 
a double life in the ancient city, and Herod put on the appearance of fostering 
both. If he adorned the city with splendid buildings after the Greek fashion, he 
also was careful to rebuild the Jewish Temple with far greater magnificence than 
of old. He would show himself a true king of the Jews. He pretended to conform to 
the Jewish Law, and did so in some matters of form and ceremony. He refused to permit 
his sister Salome’s marriage with the Arabian Syllaeus, unless the latter conformed 
to the Jewish law.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p6">Herod never entered the holy place, as Pompey did. He allowed 
the religious ritual free play. He never attempted to prevent any of the priestly 
ceremonial. He never assumed to himself ally of the priestly functions. When the 
temple was being built, only the priests were used in constructing the sanctuary, 
so that the holy place might never be profaned by any other than a priest’s foot 
or hand. He avoided heathen emblems and devices on his coins and on the buildings 
of Jerusalem. He: permitted the Sanhedrin to continue during his reign, and to exercise 
a shadow of its ancient power doubtless only in religious matters, and subject, 
doubtless, to constraint from the ever-present thought of what would be the result 
to themselves, if they did anything that Herod disliked.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p7">Thus Herod kept up the appearance of maintaining national 
feeling, of defending the Jewish cause against all foreigners, and of respecting 
national ideas and prejudices. He governed his action on the natural and obvious 
principle. He did not attempt to force the Jews to do anything that was distinctly 
<span class="unclear" id="iv.v-p7.1">non</span>-national and <span class="unclear" id="iv.v-p7.2">non</span>-Jewish; he maintained their religious ceremonial, and refrained 
from obtruding on them personally anything that was offensive to them. The theaters 
and other pagan abominations were for the accursed heathen; but the Jews could do 
as they pleased about such unholy things. They tolerated Herod, and he did not outrage 
them.<note n="63" id="iv.v-p7.3">Dr. Schuerer well describes the ambiguous 
policy of Herod, <i>Gesch. d. Jud. Volkes, etc.</i>, 2., p. 327 f.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p8">But, in spite of all his care to comply with the Roman 
requirements, towards the end of his life Herod fell into disgrace with Augustus. 
He had made war on the Arabians; and Syllaeus, the Arabian minister, who was in 
Rome, obtained the ear and the confidence of Augustus, and persuaded him that Herod 
had made war on his own authority without Roman permission. Augustus was very angry, 
and wrote to Herod that, whereas hitherto he had treated the Jewish king as a friend, 
he would henceforth treat him as a subject.<note n="64" id="iv.v-p8.1"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.v-p8.2">πάλαι χρώμενος αὐτῷ φίλῳ, 
νῦν ὑπηκόῳ χρήσεται</span>, 
Josephus, <i>Ant. Jud</i>., 16., 9, 3 (§ 290).</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p9">The time when this letter was written is, uncertain. Schuerer 
is inclined to date it in 8 BC., probably rightly. Lewin, <i>Fasti Sacri</i>, p. 
109, places it in 7 BC.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p10">These emphatic words, coming from an emperor whose words 
were always well weighed and weighty, soon bore fruit in action, as we may be certain. 
Nothing is related by Josephus as to the exact form that the Roman action took; 
but he tells very emphatically how much Herod was embarrassed by the loss of Augustus’s 
favor. In one point, Luke comes to our aid. He shows that Herod was ordered to consider 
that the recent orders for an enrollment in the Province Syria applied also to his 
kingdom and must be obeyed.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p11">A probable conjecture places at this point the oath of 
fidelity to the Emperor, which the whole Jewish people was ordered to take, and 
which 6000 Pharisees refused. It is natural that, when the king was degraded to 
the rank of a subject, his people should be constrained to take the oath of allegiance 
to Caesar, in place of the oath to Herod which they had formerly taken.<note n="65" id="iv.v-p11.1">Schuerer, <i>l. c</i>., 1., p. 329; Josephus, 15., 10, 4.</note> 
It was the practice under the empire that all subjects, both Romans and provincials, 
should swear allegiance and fidelity to the Emperor. In later time, under Trajan, 
the oath was taken every year on the anniversary of the Emperor’s accession, but 
it is uncertain when this custom was introduced. The words which Josephus uses would 
seem to imply that the oath to Caesar was taken and refused only once;<note n="66" id="iv.v-p11.2"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.v-p11.3">παντὸς γοῦν τοῦ Ἰουδᾶικοῦ βεβαιώσαντος 
δι᾽ ὅρκων ἦ μὴν εὐνοησειν Καίσαρι . . . οἵδε οὐκ 
ὤμοσαν</span>. Josephus, <i>Ant. Jud.</i>, 17., 2, 4. The aorists imply a single occasion, not a regularly repeated custom.</note> 
and the occasion is implied to have been towards the end of Herod’s life.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p12">The two acts, the oath and the enrollment, obviously form 
part of the new policy of Augustus towards Herod, though we need not go so far as 
to suppose that the two were one (as some scholars have done), and that the oath 
was taken as part of the ceremony of enrollment.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p13">Incidentally, we may notice as a masterpiece of irrationality 
and uncritical prejudice, the reflection which Strauss makes about the oath of allegiance 
to Augustus imposed on the Jews. “That this oath, far from being a humiliating measure 
for Herod, coincided with his interest, is proved by the zeal with which he punished 
the Pharisees who refused to take it.”<note n="67" id="iv.v-p13.1"><i>Life of Jesus,</i> 1., p. 203.</note> 
Naturally, Herod had to punish the refusal as an act of treason. If he did not do 
so, any one of his enemies could ruin him by reporting the fact to Augustus. Moreover, 
there were so many Roman officials in Syria that the omission to punish the recalcitrants 
could not be kept from their knowledge, and every official was in duty bound to 
report the omission to his superiors or to the Emperor. The punishment, however, 
was very mild: a fine was inflicted on the whole 6000 recalcitrants, and was paid 
by the wife of Herod’s brother Pheroras. Subsequently, the ringleaders were put 
to death; but that was not on account of their refusing the oath, but because they 
were disobedient and disrespectful to Herod himself on a later occasion.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p14">Herod was, naturally, unwilling to accept this mark of 
servitude and degradation in rank without making an effort to avoid it. He would, 
doubtless, request time; and he would have little or no difficulty in obtaining 
leave from the Roman governor, Saturninus, to postpone the numbering, until he had 
sent an embassy to Rome. Herod had formerly had great influence with Augustus; he 
might become powerful again; and the Roman officials had no reason to refuse compliance 
with such a reasonable request for temporary delay. Herod could represent with perfect 
truth that the imposition of a Roman census in Palestine would offend the prejudices 
of the Jews, and endanger the peace of the kingdom. Moreover, the crafty king knew 
well how to make his requests acceptable to Roman officers, who were almost invariably 
accessible to bribery.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p15">Further, according to Josephus, Herod’s case was a good 
and strong one, and Syllaeus was a false accuser. After Saturninus had come to Syria 
as governor, in succession to Titius (probably in the summer of 9 BC.<note n="68" id="iv.v-p15.1">Some date his arrival as late as 8 
BC. This would make the delay in the enrollment of Judea all the more natural. 
He was succeeded by Quinctilius Varus in 7. See Note 1 at end of chapter 11.</note> 
), long negotiations went on in his presence between 
Herod and Syllaeus; an arrangement was made between them; it was afterwards broken 
by Syllaeus; Herod again complained to Saturninus, and was authorized to make war 
on the Arabians.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p16">Incidentally, we notice that both the accusation that Herod 
had made war without Roman sanction, and the defense that he had been authorized 
by the governor of Syria, show how far he was from being an independent king.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p17">It is, therefore, natural and probable that a postponement 
of the enrollment should have been granted to Herod; and, although our authorities 
merely say that an embassy was sent, and give no information as to the exact message, 
yet we may fairly assume that it was intended both to soothe the anger of Augustus 
and to beg for exemption from the enrollment, on the ground that this was likely 
to rouse the religious feeling of the Jews and cause disturbance and insurrection.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p18">The embassy was sent to Rome, but it was not received in 
audience, and it returned without effecting anything. Augustus, of course, knew 
in a general way what instructions had been given to it, and he did not think that 
Herod had been sufficiently humiliated. Perhaps Herod’s case was not quite so good 
as Josephus represents it, and there was something to be said on the Arabian side 
of which we are not informed. Augustus must assuredly have received the reports 
of Saturninus the governor, and of Volumnius his own procurator; but he still continued 
stern and unforgiving to Herod.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p19">In these circumstances the delay granted to Herod in regard 
to the enrollment was not extended, and, as we may suppose, he was called upon to 
obey the emperor’s orders. He sent a second embassy to Augustus, which was, in all 
probability, commissioned not, as before, to request exemption from the enrollment, 
but to announce his submission and to promise unconditional compliance. This embassy 
was much more favorably received, and returned from Rome successful; but Herod was 
evidently by no means completely pardoned or restored fully to favor. When once 
Augustus’s anger had been roused at the Jewish monarch’s assumption of too great 
freedom, it was far from easy to appease it entirely, and impossible to eradicate 
the effect produced on his mind.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p20">The succession to Herod’s kingdom was subject to the sanction 
of Augustus<note n="69" id="iv.v-p20.1"><i>Ant. Jud.,</i> 17., 3, 2 (§ 53); 8, 2 (§ 195).</note> 
He could not punish his own sons without formally accusing them before a council 
of his relatives and the Roman officers of the province.<note n="70" id="iv.v-p20.2"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.v-p20.3">τῶν κατὰ τὴν ἐπαρχίαν 
ἡγεμόνων </span><i>Bell. Jud</i>., 1., 27, 1.</note> 
He had to send embassy after embassy to Rome to obtain the sanction of Augustus 
for his intended acts. He could not punish his guilty son Antipater without getting 
special leave from Augustus. In fact his kingdom was treated ostentatiously as an 
outlying part of the province, in which nothing of any consequence could go on without 
the Roman sanction.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p21">Luke’s statement that the enrollment was applied to Palestine 
is therefore in perfect accord with the situation as revealed by Josephus during 
the last years of the life of Herod. The question that remains is: In what year 
was the enrollment made in Palestine?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p22">The year which was generally observed in the southern part 
of the Province Syria and perhaps followed by Josephus in his history, began in 
the spring.<note n="71" id="iv.v-p22.1">See Niese in <i>Hermes</i>, 28., 1893, p. 212 ff.; also see
Notes at the end of chapter 10.</note> In Syria, therefore, the periodic year was probably 9-8 BC. and the actual numbering 
would take place in the year 8-7 BC.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p23">The recital of events which has just been given will prove 
that the numbering in Palestine could not have occurred so early as the year 8-7, 
ending 17th April, 7 BC. A consideration of the character of the enrollment will 
bring us to a more precise result.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p24">Herod was naturally eager to avoid giving to the enrollment 
an entirely foreign and non-national character Such a character both accentuated 
his own humiliation and was more liable to rouse the ever-wakeful pride and jealousy 
of his Jewish subjects. Obviously, the best way to soothe the Jewish sentiment was 
to give the enrollment a tribal character and to number the tribes of Israel, as 
had been done by purely national Governments.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p25">The Roman officials would not be likely to object to this 
form of enrollment. Provided Herod obeyed the orders of Augustus that an enrollment 
must be made, it would be entirely in accordance with the spirit in which these 
subject kingdoms were treated, that the manner of making the enrollment should be 
left to the discretion of the responsible authority, <i>viz.</i>, the king. Moreover, the marvelous success of 
Roman provincial administration was due to the skill 
and tact with which the officials accommodated themselves to the prejudices of the 
subject population; and this was clearly a case in, which Jewish susceptibilities 
might be taken into account as regards the manner of numbering. The people was well 
known to be stubborn and unyielding in its religious ideas; and, with rare exceptions, 
Rome humored its religious prejudices.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p26">In his work on the relations between the Imperial law and 
the National law, Dr. Mitteis has shown how much the Roman law was affected in the 
Eastern provinces by national law and custom.<note n="72" id="iv.v-p26.1"><i>Reichsrecht und Volksrecht</i>, Leipzig, 1891.</note> 
In those countries Rome was brought in contact with an old civilization and a settled 
system of Greek law; and it did not seek to force on them its own law, as it did 
on the barbarous countries of the West. Similarly, the Roman governor of Syria was 
not likely to dictate the precise fashion in which the numbering of Palestine must 
be carried out.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p27">Moreover, we have already seen that the prime consideration 
in the Imperial system of administering the provinces was to avoid disturbance and 
sedition. Augustus and the later emperors emphatically inculcated this principle 
on their lieutenants in the provinces. Herod could with perfect justice show that 
tribal numbering was the form which would tend most to peace and order in his kingdom.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p28">Herod’s method in governing his kingdom was, as we have 
seen, to humor the Jews, and to accept the distinction which they proudly drew between 
themselves and the heathen. Must we not, then, suppose that he would employ the 
same method in his enrollment? Owing to the care with which the Jews preserved their 
family records and pedigrees, all true Jews would know what was their family and 
their proper city according to the ancient tribal system, even though they might 
have been forced by circumstances to change their abode. This seems to have suggested 
the mode of enrollment which Luke describes a mode which would mark off by a broad 
clear line the true Jews from the mongrel population of Palestine. All who claimed 
to be Jews were to repair to the proper city of their tribe and family. The rest 
of the population, who were probably much more numerous, would be counted according 
to their ordinary place of residence.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p29">My friend, Professor Paterson, to whom I am indebted throughout 
these pages, points out that Augustus would specially desire an enrollment of Palestine 
in order to have some clear idea what was the military strength of the country. 
It was a troublesome district to rule. Disturbances were always apprehended. There 
was obvious advantage in knowing what was the exact strength of the possible rebels.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p30">Moreover, the non-Jewish population was peaceable and 
well-affected to Rome. The enrollment would obviously be much more useful, if in 
distinguished accurately the rebellious from the peaceful element in the population. 
The tribal enrollment furnished the means of gaining this information. It might 
safely be concluded that all those who were content to be counted as non-tribal 
would be loyal subjects of Rome. The imposition of the oath of allegiance to Augustus 
would also furnish a test, and the number of those who refused the oath was kept. 
Josephus says there were more than 6000. He implies, not that this was an estimate 
of the strength of the Pharisaic faction, but that those who actually refused to 
take the oath were counted; and he says that they were regarded as dangerous and 
likely to rouse war and disturbance.<note n="73" id="iv.v-p30.1"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.v-p30.2">ἐκ τοῦ προύπτου εἰς τὸ 
πολεμεῖν τε 
καὶ βλάπτειν ἐπηρμένοι</span>,
<i>Ant. Jud.</i>, 17., 2, 4 (41).</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p31">According to Luke the tribal enrollment was made by ordering 
every head of a household to repair for the numbering to the proper city from which 
his family had sprung. Such a method would have been entirely inapplicable in a 
large country. But, as the traveler rides across the length of Palestine, it is 
vividly brought home to him that this was an easy and short method in that land. 
The Romans, who required that citizens should travel to Rome from the remotest part 
of Italy when they wished to register their vote, would see nothing to object to, 
if Herod consulted them as to his proposed scheme.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p32">In the national character which Herod gave to his enrollment, 
probably, lies the reason why Mary as well as Joseph went up to Bethlehem — a detail 
which would be so inexplicable if the enrollment had been modeled after a Roman 
census. To go personally to the enrollment was regarded as substantiating a claim 
to true Hebrew origin and family. All they that went to their proper city were true 
Hebrews; and, as Luke says, “all (<i>i.e.</i>, all true Hebrews in Palestine) went 
to enroll themselves, every one to his own city”.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p33">It is important to notice the force of the word “all” here. 
This is one of many passages in Luke’s History where the precise sense that should 
be attributed to the word “all” or the word “they” 
may be, or has been, a subject of controversy, and can be determined only from the 
whole train of thought in the historian’s mind. He that misconceives the general 
thought underlying the whole passage inevitably misinterprets “they” or “all”</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p34">For example, who are “they” in 
<scripRef id="iv.v-p34.1" passage="Acts 13:3" parsed="|Acts|13|3|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.13.3">Acts 13:3</scripRef>? On the way in which 
that question is answered hinges a controversy as to Church government. Who are 
“all” in <scripRef id="iv.v-p34.2" passage="Acts 18:17" parsed="|Acts|18|17|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.18.17">Acts 18:17</scripRef>? 
On the answer depends the whole sense of the incident; but an answer is difficult, 
and depends on the general conception in the reader’s mind. Some say “all the Jews 
beat a Christian”: others say “all the Greeks beat a Jew”. Similarly, who are “us” 
in <scripRef id="iv.v-p34.3" passage="Luke 1:1" parsed="|Luke|1|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.1">Luke 1:1</scripRef>? Professor 
Blass has recently answered that in his own way. Many would give a different reply.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p35">Accordingly, to understand “all” in 
<scripRef id="iv.v-p35.1" passage="Luke 2:3" parsed="|Luke|2|3|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.3">Luke 2:3</scripRef>, one must put oneself 
at the narrator’s point of view. As we have seen, he conveys the impression throughout 
the two chapters that he is giving the story of Mary herself. To her “all” are the 
Jews: she thinks only of her own people: the nonJewish population of Palestine is 
not embraced in her view.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p36">But, when such a plan of tribal numbering was adopted, 
the time of year had to be carefully considered. In the first place the winter months 
had to be avoided, during which traveling was often difficult, and in which unfavorable 
weather might cause great hardship and even prevent the plan from being carried 
out. As the day had to be fixed a long time beforehand, it must have been fixed 
in the season when good weather could be calculated on. In winter, weather might 
be good or it might be bad, and at the best it would be cold and trying.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p37">That a day was fixed by the authorities, and that it was 
not left to the discretion of the people to go when they pleased (as in Egypt people 
seem to have been permitted to send in their enrollment papers at any time they 
pleased within the year), seems to follow from the fact that Joseph and Mary traveled 
from Nazareth to Bethlehem at the very time when the birth of the child was approaching. 
Moreover, the advantages of the plan in ease and speed would have been sacrificed, 
unless a day had been fixed for the numbering.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p38">Further, it was urgently necessary that the time which 
was fixed should not interfere with agricultural operations — that it should not 
come between the earliest date for the first harvest and the latest date for finishing 
the threshing, and getting in the grain and the fine cut straw from the threshing 
floors.<note n="74" id="iv.v-p38.1">See Mr. J. W. Paterson’s excellent 
article on “Agriculture” in Hastings’ <i>Dictionary of the Bible</i>. On the 
use of the fine chopped straw in the economy of the farm, see <i>Contemporary 
Review,</i> August, 1897, p. 237.</note> The harvest varied considerably in different parts of the country, and reaping extended 
over about seven weeks, beginning from the middle of April.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p39">Taking these circumstances into consideration, we may say 
with considerable confidence that August to October is the period within which the 
numbering would be fixed. It is no objection to this view that tradition places 
the birth of Jesus at Christmas. It is well known that the tradition is not early, 
that it varies in different periods and in different sections of the Church, and 
that the earliest belief was different.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p40">Lewin, in <i>Fasti Sacri,</i> p. 115, selects 1st August 
as the day and month. Without laying any stress on the reasoning from the priestly 
periods by which he reaches this precise and exact conclusion, we must attach great 
weight to the argument which he founds on the fact that the shepherds were watching 
their flocks in the open country by night. In Asia Minor, at least, the pasturing 
of the flocks by night takes place only during the hot season and not in the winter. 
The sheep will not eat under the hot sun: they stand idly in a dense crowd in any 
place where the semblance of shade can be found during the day, and during the night 
they scatter and feed. In cold weather they seek food during the day.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p41">On this characteristic of the sheep is founded the rule, 
said to be observed in Palestine, that the flocks were sent out after the Passover 
and brought in about October before the “former rain”.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p42">Within that period, April to October, the day fixed for 
the numbering must fall; and during that period April to July was required for the 
reaping and garnering of the year’s crop.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p43">It seems unnecessary to do more than refer to the idle 
objection that has been made: How were the shepherds numbered? There must always 
be some people for whom the numbering is inconvenient, whatever be the time at which 
it is fixed; and we need not trouble to inquire what was the method adopted to meet 
the special case of the shepherds. That inquiry belongs 
to the sphere of the archaeological student, who studies the <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.v-p43.1">minutiae</span> of the census system; but the historian, in 
his more general view, must omit such details. No critic, who retains his sober 
reason and does not yield to mere prejudice, would find any difficulty in it.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p44">After all, not a great deal of journeying to and fro would 
be required for the enrollment. The remnant that could trace their origin to the 
Ten Tribes must have been very small. The majority of the strictly Jewish population 
was probably resident at that time in the southern part of Palestine, though there 
was also a large minority scattered over all the cities of the central and northern 
districts. A considerable number of people would have to make journeys of one to 
four days to their own city, and the same back again; but nothing approaching to 
a general transference of population would be necessitated.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p45">For Herod’s enrollment, then, there is open only the late 
summer of 7 or 6 BC. Unless we have omitted some important factor (which is, of 
course, far from improbable, considering how scanty the evidence is), the enrollment 
can hardly be brought down so late as 5 BC. and we have seen that 8 BC. is excluded 
by other considerations.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p46">Between the years 7 and 6 it is difficult to choose, so 
long as we confine ourselves to the evidence outside of Luke, for that evidence 
is insufficient to found a judgment upon, owing to the uncertainty of all the dates 
connected with the question. It may be that the embassy which was dismissed unheard 
by Augustus, returned so late that the necessary preparations and notice could not 
be made in time for the autumn of 7 BC. and it is certain that Herod was by no means 
eager to hurry the numbering. But these are mere vague presumptions.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p47">Luke, however, gives additional information about the Savior’s 
life, which affords reasonable confidence that 6 BC. was the year of Christ’s birth.</p>
<p class="center" id="iv.v-p48"><b>NOTE</b></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.v-p49">That a difference should be made in the treatment of Jews 
and non-Jews in Palestine, is quite in accordance with Roman usage. For example, 
after the rebellion under Hadrian, the Jews were forbidden to enter Jerusalem.</p>


</div2>

      <div2 title="Chapter 10. Chronology of the Life of Christ" progress="71.37%" id="iv.vi" prev="iv.v" next="iv.vii">

<h3 id="iv.vi-p0.1">CHAPTER 10 <br />
CHRONOLOGY OF THE LIFE OF CHRIST</h3>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p1"><scripRef passage="Luke 3:23" id="iv.vi-p1.1" parsed="|Luke|3|23|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.3.23">LUKE 3:23</scripRef> tells that Jesus 
appeared before the world as the teacher, when he was about thirty years of age. 
Now it is a characteristic usage in Greek to employ this vague expression, when 
there is no intention to imply doubt as to the age: it lies in the genius of the 
language to avoid positiveness in assertion, and to prefer less definite and pronounced 
and harsh forms of statement.<note n="75" id="iv.vi-p1.2">The less definite form is strictly correct: Jesus was thirty years and a few months, more or less.</note> 
It is unnecessary to think that Luke was really doubtful what was the age of Jesus, 
whether twenty-eight or thirty-two. His elaborately careful and precise dating,
<scripRef passage="Luke 3:1,2" id="iv.vi-p1.3" parsed="|Luke|3|1|3|2" osisRef="Bible:Luke.3.1-Luke.3.2">3:1, 2</scripRef>, may be taken 
as an indication that he had good and accurate information on the subject; that 
he “had investigated all the circumstances accurately in their origin”. But, like 
a true Greek, he says “about thirty,” where the less sensitive barbarian of our 
northern island would use a rudely positive and definite number. The only doubt 
that remains is whether Luke means in his thirtieth year, or when he was thirty 
years old; and this doubt is resolved by the other facts recorded by Luke, as we 
shall see. Jesus was thirty years old, when he began his public career.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p2">The precise statement is doubtless derived from the same 
authority as the whole of the first two chapters (and perhaps also 
<scripRef passage="Luke 4:16-30" id="iv.vi-p2.1" parsed="|Luke|4|16|4|30" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.16-Luke.4.30">4:16-30</scripRef>); and the only reason 
for recording it is that it was given exactly by a first-rate authority, and therefore 
helped Luke’s readers “to know the certainty concerning the things wherein they 
had been instructed”. An authority, who was really good on such a point, would know 
the exact age, and Luke expressly declares his intention of setting down only such 
facts as he had accurately and certainly on trustworthy authority. Where his knowledge 
was only vague, he usually refrains from making any statement.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p3">If the birth of Jesus occurred in BC. 6, he became thirty 
years of age in the second half of AD. 25, and his appearance as a teacher took 
place within the year that followed. If his birth occurred in BC. 7, the date of 
his appearance must be placed one year earlier, but we shall find reason to reject 
that supposition.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p4">Some time, but apparently quite a short time, before Jesus 
came forward as a teacher, John the Baptist began to preach that the Messiah was 
at hand; and Jesus was among the crowds who flocked to him to receive baptism. Now, 
as Luke mentions, “the word of God came to John” in the fifteenth year of the authority<note n="76" id="iv.vi-p4.1"><i>Hegemonia</i>, <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vi-p4.2">ἡγεμονία</span>, 
is the word; on its sense see Chapter 11.</note>  
of Tiberius Caesar. The date is given very precisely and definitely; but, unfortunately, 
it is by no means easy to say what year is meant by it.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p5">It is often found that, where an ancient writer aims at 
making his statement most precise and exact, his words lend themselves to several 
interpretations.<note n="77" id="iv.vi-p5.1">Mommsen quotes a remarkable case in 
the <i>Monumentum Ancyranum </i>where Augustus’s desire to be precise and certain 
has exposed his statement of a number to be interpreted in three different ways by different writers.</note> 
What did Luke understand by the authority of Tiberius? In the inscriptions of that 
emperor’s lifetime, the years of his reign are estimated according to the number 
of times that he had received tribunician power. On that system his fifteenth year 
began on 27th June, AD. 13. Obviously Luke cannot intend that year.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p6">Again, according to Velleius, the admirer and friend and 
faithful follower of Tiberius, associated with him in nine years of warfare, authority 
equal to that of Augustus in all the provinces and armies of the empire was granted 
to Tiberius by the senate and people, on the proposal of Augustus himself, before 
he returned to Rome to celebrate his triumph over the peoples of Pannonia and Dalmatia. 
Now this triumph was celebrated on</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p7">16th January, AD. 12,<note n="78" id="iv.vi-p7.1"><i>Prosopographia Imp. Rom.</i>, 2., 
p. 183; Mommsen, <i>Staatsrecht,</i> 2., p 1159.</note> 
therefore the decree of equal power must have been passed before the end of AD. 
11. Further, the language of Velleius suggests that the decree was issued not long 
before Tiberius returned, and it was so closely connected with his return that Suetonius 
seems to place it after he reached Rome. But Velleius’s authority must be ranked 
superior in regard to such a point.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p8">There can be no doubt that this was the event which Tacitus 
had ill mind when he said that Tiberius had been created <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vi-p8.1">Collega Imperii</span> 
during the lifetime of Augustus (<i>Annals</i>, 1., 3).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p9">It follows that the first year during which Tiberius held 
power as colleague of Augustus with equal power in all provinces of the empire coincided 
with the end of AD. 11 and the greater part of AD. 12, and the fifteenth year with 
AD. 25-6.<note n="79" id="iv.vi-p9.1">See Note at end of chapter 10.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p10">If Luke counted the years of Tiberius according to that 
system, all his statements as to time in these early chapters are found to be consistent 
and accurate. The first enrollment must have taken place in autumn BC. 6. Jesus 
was thirty years old in autumn BC. 25. In the later months of that year, when the 
fifteenth year of the <i>Hegemonia</i> of Tiberius in the provinces had just recently 
begun (according to the official usage<note n="80" id="iv.vi-p10.1">See Note at end of chapter 10.</note> 
), John appeared announcing the coming of Christ; and very shortly thereafter Jesus 
came and was baptized by John in the river Jordan. A month or two thereafter occurred 
the Passover on 21st March, AD. 26 (Lewin, <i>Fasti Sacri</i>, p. 173).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p11">The only reason for doubting whether Luke could have counted 
the years of Tiberius on that system, is that it is never employed elsewhere in 
reckoning the reign of that emperor. When his tribunician years are not stated, 
his reign is always elsewhere counted from the death of his predecessor, Augustus; 
and it is beyond dispute that he was not in any proper and strict sense emperor 
until that time. But it seems not impossible that his <i>Hegemonia</i> in the provinces 
might be counted from AD. 11, when his authority began in them. Similarly, we saw 
that in Egypt the reign of Augustus was reckoned, not from any date when he became 
emperor in a strict and proper sense, but from BC. 30, when his authority began 
in that country.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p12">Further, Luke, the whole spirit of whose History stamps 
it as belonging to the Flavian period, knew that the reign of Titus was counted 
from the day when he was made the colleague of his father, Vespasian; and thus he 
may have been led to apply to the time of Tiberius the principle which was in current 
and official use while he was writing.<note n="81" id="iv.vi-p12.1">See Mr. Turner in Dr. Hastings’ <i>
Dict. of Bible,</i> 1., p. 406.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p13">Now the only dates that are permissible for the crucifixion 
are AD. 29, 30 and 33. Different authorities vary between these three years. But, 
as it is not possible to allow that more than four Passovers occurred during the 
public career of Jesus, we are bound to the view that his career extended from the 
time preceding the Passover of 26 till the Passover of 29. The strength of the tradition 
that places the crucifixion in 29 has been admirably stated by Mr. C. H. Turner 
in his article on the “Chronology of the New Testament”.<note n="82" id="iv.vi-p13.1">In Dr. Hastings’ <i>Dict. of Bible</i>.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p14">But is this consistent with Luke’s narrative? Does he permit 
the supposition that four Passovers occurred within the period of Jesus’ teaching?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p15">Luke does not refer to any Passover during that whole period 
except the last. He was not interested in the relation of Jesus to the Jewish feasts, 
and hardly alludes to the subject after the Passover that occurred in the Savior’s 
twelfth year. Hence we cannot expect from him much direct evidence bearing on the 
Passovers during the teaching of Jesus.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p16">Moreover, Luke had little of the sense for chronology, 
the value of which in clearly understanding or describing any series of incidents 
had not been appreciated so early as the first century. Chronology, too, was much 
more difficult when no era had come into general use, when dates were commonly stated 
by the names of annual magistrates, or the years of sovereigns, and when in Asia 
scores of different eras for dating had just begun to come into use side by side 
with one another, so that, even when one does find a date by a numbered year, it 
is often a difficult problem to determine what era is used.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p17">Want of chronological sense or interest may seem a serious 
defect in a historian. But we are too apt to forget that Luke was not writing for 
us, and that he was not even writing for posterity. He wrote for the benefit of 
his own contemporaries. His work stands in the closest relation to the time. That 
which seemed most important for the requirements of the Church at the time was what 
Luke most desired to record with absolute accuracy and trustworthiness. Abstract 
scientific interest in the chronology of the Gospel did not exist among his readers. 
What they were concerned with was its truth; and that was gathered from the Savior’s 
teaching, from his statements about himself, and from the facts of his Birth, Death 
and Resurrection. These were the points on which Luke’s attention was concentrated 
in his first book.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p18">Some authorities are disposed to think that Luke believed 
the whole period of the teaching of Jesus to have been comprised within the period 
of a little more than a year, lasting from shortly before one Passover till the 
Passover of the following year. A widely-spread opinion in the second and third 
centuries assigned that duration to the Savior’s ministry, but I can discover nothing 
to show that Luke shared it. The opinion, probably, was the result of two causes. In the first place, the notes of 
time in the Gospels are very slight and difficult to fit together. In the second 
place, the saying about “the acceptable year of the Lord” was easily misunderstood.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p19">The memory of the earliest authorities, as a rule, was 
entirely filled with the words and teaching of the Savior. Chronological order was 
little thought of; and we should probably find that most of the writings alluded 
to by <scripRef passage="Luke 1:1-80" id="iv.vi-p19.1" parsed="|Luke|1|1|1|80" osisRef="Bible:Luke.1.1-Luke.1.80">Luke 1.</scripRef> I took the 
form of collections of sayings and parables. The only events, probably, that were 
vividly remembered in their historical aspect and apart from the doctrine connected 
with them, were the series of actions comprised within the last few days of the 
Savior’s life. The sequence of these events was indelibly stamped on the memory 
of all.<note n="83" id="iv.vi-p19.2">Yet compare <scripRef id="iv.vi-p19.3" passage="John 12:1" parsed="|John|12|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.12.1">John 12:1</scripRef> and <scripRef id="iv.vi-p19.4" passage="Mark 14:1" parsed="|Mark|14|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Mark.14.1">Mark 14:1</scripRef>. See
Note at the end of Chapter 4.</note> 
But the rest of the tradition was a reproduction of past lessons and impressive 
sayings. These were connected with certain localities; some were associated with 
certain actions of the Savior or of those who were in his company. But his numerous 
journeys great and small were not remembered in their sequence. In this state of 
information, Luke evidently forbore the attempt to describe exactly the movements 
of Jesus during the greater part of the teaching.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p20">In the beginning, indeed, he describes the sequence of 
Jesus’ first journeys. He tells how Jesus was baptized by John in Jordan, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 3:21" id="iv.vi-p20.1" parsed="|Luke|3|21|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.3.21">3:21</scripRef>; and he dates at that point 
the beginning of his teaching, <scripRef passage="Luke 3:23" id="iv.vi-p20.2" parsed="|Luke|3|23|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.3.23">3:23</scripRef>. 
Then he tells of the journey into the wilderness, <i>i.e</i>., the country south 
from Jerusalem, and mentions that Jesus was actually in Jerusalem, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 4:1-13" id="iv.vi-p20.3" parsed="|Luke|4|1|4|13" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.1-Luke.4.13">4:1-13</scripRef>. Thereafter Jesus returned 
to Galilee and taught there for some time, <scripRef passage="Luke 4:14,15" id="iv.vi-p20.4" parsed="|Luke|4|14|4|15" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.14-Luke.4.15">4:14, 15</scripRef>, 
after which he returned to Nazareth for a brief visit, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 4:16-30" id="iv.vi-p20.5" parsed="|Luke|4|16|4|30" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.16-Luke.4.30">4:16-30</scripRef>. Being rejected and 
threatened with death at Nazareth, he came down to Capernaum, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 4:31" id="iv.vi-p20.6" parsed="|Luke|4|31|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.31">4:31</scripRef>.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p21">The narrative during this stage touches that of the other 
Gospels at occasional points; and one paragraph, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 4:1-13" id="iv.vi-p21.1" parsed="|Luke|4|1|4|13" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.1-Luke.4.13">4:1-13</scripRef>, is perhaps founded on 
the same ultimate authority as <scripRef id="iv.vi-p21.2" passage="Matthew 4:1-11" parsed="|Matt|4|1|4|11" osisRef="Bible:Matt.4.1-Matt.4.11">Matthew 4:1-11</scripRef> 
(though with a difference in order). No indication of the lapse of time is given; 
but some considerable period is likely to have elapsed even in the events implied 
in <scripRef id="iv.vi-p21.3" passage="4:15" parsed="|Matt|4|15|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Matt.4.15">4:15</scripRef> alone.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p22">But at this point, <scripRef passage="Luke 4:31" id="iv.vi-p22.1" parsed="|Luke|4|31|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.31">4:31</scripRef>, 
begins a new section of the narrative. The indications of movement for a considerable 
period are of the vaguest kind. <scripRef passage="Luke 4:42" id="iv.vi-p22.2" parsed="|Luke|4|42|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.42">4:42</scripRef>, 
He went into a desert place. <scripRef passage="Luke 5:16" id="iv.vi-p22.3" parsed="|Luke|5|16|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.5.16">5:16</scripRef>, 
He withdrew himself in the deserts.<scripRef passage="Luke 5:27" id="iv.vi-p22.4" parsed="|Luke|5|27|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.5.27">5:27</scripRef>, He went 
forth.<scripRef passage="Luke 6:1" id="iv.vi-p22.5" parsed="|Luke|6|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.6.1">6:1</scripRef>, He was going through the cornfields, probably in May or June when the wheat was ripe 
but not cut. <scripRef passage="Luke 6:12" id="iv.vi-p22.6" parsed="|Luke|6|12|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.6.12">6:12</scripRef>, He 
went out into the mountain to pray. <scripRef passage="Luke 6:17" id="iv.vi-p22.7" parsed="|Luke|6|17|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.6.17">6:17</scripRef>, 
He came down with them. 
<scripRef passage="Luke 7:1" id="iv.vi-p22.8" parsed="|Luke|7|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.7.1">7:1</scripRef>, He entered into Capernaum.<scripRef passage="Luke 7:1" id="iv.vi-p22.9" parsed="|Luke|7|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.7.1">7:1</scripRef>, 
He went soon afterwards to a city called Nain 
(an episode peculiar to Luke). His return from Nain is never mentioned, but 
<scripRef passage="Luke 7:18-20" id="iv.vi-p22.10" parsed="|Luke|7|18|7|20" osisRef="Bible:Luke.7.18-Luke.7.20">7:18 ff.</scripRef> probably belongs 
to the coasts of the Sea of Galilee. <scripRef passage="Luke 8:1" id="iv.vi-p22.11" parsed="|Luke|8|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.8.1">8:1</scripRef>, 
He soon afterwards went about through cities and villages. 
<scripRef passage="Luke 8:22" id="iv.vi-p22.12" parsed="|Luke|8|22|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.8.22">8:22</scripRef>, He entered into a boat 
(on the Sea of Galilee). <scripRef passage="Luke 8:26" id="iv.vi-p22.13" parsed="|Luke|8|26|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.8.26">8:26</scripRef>, 
He arrived at the country of the Gerasenes, which is over against Galilee. <scripRef passage="Luke 8:38" id="iv.vi-p22.14" parsed="|Luke|8|38|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.8.38">8:38</scripRef>, 
He entered into a boat and returned. <scripRef passage="Luke 9:10" id="iv.vi-p22.15" parsed="|Luke|9|10|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.9.10">9:10</scripRef>, 
He withdrew apart to a city called Bethsaida. <scripRef passage="Luke 9:28" id="iv.vi-p22.16" parsed="|Luke|9|28|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.9.28">9:28</scripRef>, 
He went up about eight days after into the mountain to pray. 
<scripRef passage="Luke 9:37" id="iv.vi-p22.17" parsed="|Luke|9|37|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.9.37">9:37</scripRef>, On the next day when they 
were come down from the mountain, a great multitude met him (and here Mark’s reference 
to the green grass, <scripRef passage="Luke 6:39" id="iv.vi-p22.18" parsed="|Luke|6|39|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.6.39">6:39</scripRef>, 
and John’s to the abundant grass, <scripRef passage="Luke 6:10" id="iv.vi-p22.19" parsed="|Luke|6|10|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.6.10">6:10</scripRef>, 
show that the time was spring).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p23">In this part of the narrative, the lapse of time is hardly 
alluded to: only the brief and vague indications just quoted are given. The marks 
of locality, apart from those implied in the indications of movement, are also very 
vague and elusive. <scripRef passage="Luke 4:44" id="iv.vi-p23.1" parsed="|Luke|4|44|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.44">4:44</scripRef>, 
He was preaching in the synagogues of Galilee. <scripRef passage="Luke 5:1" id="iv.vi-p23.2" parsed="|Luke|5|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.5.1">5:1</scripRef>, 
He was standing by the Lake of Gennesaret. <scripRef passage="Luke 5:12" id="iv.vi-p23.3" parsed="|Luke|5|12|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.5.12">5:12</scripRef>, 
He was in one of the cities.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p24">This section of the narrative, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 4:31-9:50" id="iv.vi-p24.1" parsed="|Luke|4|31|9|50" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.31-Luke.9.50">4:31-9:50</scripRef>, is as a whole (though 
with some considerable exceptions) closely parallel to Mark and Matthew. Great part 
of the section is evidently founded on an authority common to them (though we expressly 
avoid stating any opinion as to the nature of the connection between the three).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p25">It is plain that though Luke, with his usual indifference 
to the chronological aspect of history, does not properly mark the lapse of time, 
yet this section must extend over some considerable period. “Preaching in the synagogues 
of Galilee” is the sort of phrase by which Luke sums up a considerable period; and 
the different movements, mentioned or implied, vague as they are, together with 
the intervals between them, demand time.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p26">From <scripRef passage="Luke 9:51" id="iv.vi-p26.1" parsed="|Luke|9|51|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.9.51">9:51</scripRef> 
begins another new section describing the movement to Jerusalem preparatory to the 
culmination of Christ’s teaching there. In <scripRef passage="Luke 10:38" id="iv.vi-p26.2" parsed="|Luke|10|38|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.10.38">10:38</scripRef>, 
as they went on their way, he entered into a certain village (<i>viz.</i>, Bethany); and in <scripRef passage="Luke 11:1" id="iv.vi-p26.3" parsed="|Luke|11|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.11.1">11:1</scripRef>, 
he was praying in a certain place. In this and the following chapters there continues 
the same vagueness. Luke only makes it clear that the most advanced stage in the 
ministry has begun, and that Jesus is moving gradually towards the south and is 
affecting the southern half of Palestine. In <scripRef passage="Luke 13:22" id="iv.vi-p26.4" parsed="|Luke|13|22|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.13.22">13:22</scripRef>, 
he went on his way through towns and villages teaching and journeying on unto Jerusalem. 
In <scripRef passage="Luke 17:11" id="iv.vi-p26.5" parsed="|Luke|17|11|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.17.11">17:11</scripRef>, as they were 
on the way to Jerusalem, he was passing through the midst of Samaria and Galilee.
<scripRef passage="Luke 8:31" id="iv.vi-p26.6" parsed="|Luke|8|31|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.8.31">8:31</scripRef>, We go up to Jerusalem. 
<scripRef passage="Luke 18:35" id="iv.vi-p26.7" parsed="|Luke|18|35|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.18.35">18:35</scripRef>, He drew nigh unto Jericho.<scripRef passage="Luke 19:1" id="iv.vi-p26.8" parsed="|Luke|19|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.19.1">19:1</scripRef>, 
He entered and was passing through Jericho.
<scripRef passage="Luke 19:11" id="iv.vi-p26.9" parsed="|Luke|19|11|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.19.11">19:11</scripRef>, He was nigh to 
Jerusalem. <scripRef passage="Luke 19:28" id="iv.vi-p26.10" parsed="|Luke|19|28|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.19.28">19:28</scripRef> f., 
He went on before, going up to Jerusalem (by the steep 
road from Jericho), and he drew nigh to Bethany.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p27">Then comes the entry into Jerusalem, where the rest of 
the narrative has its scene.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p28">With very slight exceptions, the section 
<scripRef passage="Luke 9:51-19:28" id="iv.vi-p28.1" parsed="|Luke|9|51|19|28" osisRef="Bible:Luke.9.51-Luke.19.28">9:51-19:28</scripRef> is quite peculiar 
to Luke, and has hardly any points of contact with any of the other Gospels. But 
the same vagueness of place and time continues.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p29">It is, however, clearly unnecessary and improbable that 
this section represents, or was considered by Luke to represent, the events of one 
single continuous approximately straight journey. The multitudes, the towns and 
villages, the frequent repetition of the idea of progress towards Jerusalem, imply 
a gradual advance of the circle of the teaching towards the south and towards the 
center of Jewish religion and the completion of his mission.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p30">If, as I believe to be probably the case, Luke knew what 
was the “certain village” of Martha and Mary, <scripRef passage="Luke 10:38" id="iv.vi-p30.1" parsed="|Luke|10|38|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.10.38">10:38</scripRef>, 
but for some reason (about which we need not speculate) avoided naming it, our view 
would be raised to complete certainty, that in this section the historian is describing 
a general movement southwards, accompanied and complicated by many short journeys 
to and fro, up and down, “through towns and villages teaching”. If he is at Bethany 
in 10., and at Jericho in 18, and in Samaria in 17, zigzag wanderings are clearly 
implied. But, as many may prefer to consider that <scripRef passage="Luke 10:38" id="iv.vi-p30.2" parsed="|Luke|10|38|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.10.38">10:38</scripRef> has been put in false local and chronological order 
by Luke through his ignorance that the “certain village” 
was Bethany, we need not press an argument that is not actually required for our 
purpose. Even without it the view which we are stating 
as to Luke’s intention in this section seems certain.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p31">It is obvious, then, that Luke divides the teaching of 
Jesus, previous to the final scenes in Jerusalem, into three stages. The first and 
preliminary stage — in the wilderness of Judah, in Galilee and in Nazareth — is 
very briefly recorded The second — spent in Galilee or the north continuously — 
is described at much greater length: Jesus had now become a famous teacher, and 
attracted many hearers and followers. The third — the extension of the sphere of 
influence over central Palestine as Far as Jerusalem — is described still more fully. 
There is no attempt or intention to describe the movements of Jesus exactly in the 
second and third stages.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p32">Further, the second stage evidently lasted a Full year, 
For after it has begun some time, we find ourselves in the month of May or June, 
and at the end we are again in spring (as we know From Mark but not from Luke).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p33">The probability, then, is that roughly the three stages 
correspond to the three years; and the memory of the witnesses retained very little 
that was accurate and definite (except some important changes of scene and journeys) 
during the preliminary stage, AD. 26, more about the second, AD. 27, and still more 
about the third, AD. 28.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p34">The first Passover, AD. 26 (<scripRef id="iv.vi-p34.1" passage="John 2:13" parsed="|John|2|13|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.2.13">John 2:13</scripRef>), falls about <scripRef id="iv.vi-p34.2" passage="Luke 4:13" parsed="|Luke|4|13|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.13">Luke 
4:13</scripRef>, and the year ends about 
<scripRef passage="Luke 4:31" id="iv.vi-p34.3" parsed="|Luke|4|31|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.4.31">4:31</scripRef>. At the feast of this year, 
the Jews spoke about the 46th year of the building of the Temple (<scripRef id="iv.vi-p34.4" passage="John 2:20" parsed="|John|2|20|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.2.20">John 
2:20</scripRef>); and the 46th year had begun shortly before 
they spoke.<note n="84" id="iv.vi-p34.5">See Note 2 at the end of Chapter 10.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p35">The second Passover, AD. 27 (<scripRef id="iv.vi-p35.1" passage="John 5:1" parsed="|John|5|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.5.1">John 
5:1</scripRef>), falls about <scripRef passage="Luke 5:1-39" id="iv.vi-p35.2" parsed="|Luke|5|1|5|39" osisRef="Bible:Luke.5.1-Luke.5.39">Luke 5</scripRef>. Then follows the month of May, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 6:1" id="iv.vi-p35.3" parsed="|Luke|6|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.6.1">6:1</scripRef>.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p36">The spring of AD. 28 and the third Passover (<scripRef id="iv.vi-p36.1" passage="John 6:4" parsed="|John|6|4|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.6.4">John 6:4</scripRef>) must be placed in 
<scripRef passage="Luke 9:1-62" id="iv.vi-p36.2" parsed="|Luke|9|1|9|62" osisRef="Bible:Luke.9.1-Luke.9.62">Luke 9</scripRef>. The summer of this year, 
however, was still spent in Galilee, according to <scripRef id="iv.vi-p36.3" passage="John 7:1" parsed="|John|7|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.7.1">John 7:1</scripRef>; but it is not inconsistent with this statement 
that the third stage of Luke had already begun. The characteristic of that stage 
was that Jesus had now set his face firmly to go to Jerusalem, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 9:51" id="iv.vi-p36.4" parsed="|Luke|9|51|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.9.51">9:51</scripRef>; but during it, he was 
still passing through the midst of Samaria and Galilee, 
<scripRef passage="Luke 17:11" id="iv.vi-p36.5" parsed="|Luke|17|11|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.17.11">17:11</scripRef>. The period in Luke’s 
estimation is rather one of firm and definite resolution 
than of bodily movement continuously towards Jerusalem. The visit to the country east of Jordan (<scripRef id="iv.vi-p36.6" passage="Mark 10:1" parsed="|Mark|10|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Mark.10.1">Mark 
10:1</scripRef> and <scripRef id="iv.vi-p36.7" passage="Matthew 19:1" parsed="|Matt|19|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Matt.19.1">Matthew 19:1</scripRef>) certainly belongs to this stage.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p37">That there was a strong tradition to the effect that the 
Savior suffered at the age of thirty-three seems to follow from the agreement of 
Hippolytus<note n="85" id="iv.vi-p37.1">On Hippolytus see Mr. Turner’s remarks, <i>l. c.</i> p. 413, col. 2.</note> 
and Eusebius and Phlegon. The latter, as is allowed by Mr. Turner, was indebted 
to very early Christian authorities for his information. It is true that both Eusebius 
and Phlegon place the crucifixion in AD. 33, but this arises from their both depending 
on the original Christian calculation which ultimately gave rise to the modern era 
of the birth of Christ. This was wrongly calculated as early as the second century; 
and, starting from that initial error, the chronologists had to place the beginning 
of the teaching in thirty and the crucifixion in thirty-three.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p38">It is a strong confirmation of our result that it agrees 
with two so ancient traditions, which are quite unconnected with one another and 
evidently seemed to most of the ancients to be inconsistent with each other.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p39">Starting from a very different point of view from that 
of Mr. Turner, and working on utterly diverse lines, we have reached nearly the 
same conclusion that he reached. The only differences of importance are two: —</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p40"><b>1.</b> I find myself obliged, 
on the principles of interpretation which I have followed consistently throughout, 
to attach a distinctly higher value than he does to Luke’s statement as to the age 
of Jesus when he began to teach.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p41"><b>2.</b> Mr. Turner is inclined 
to think that Luke compressed the teaching into one year; and he holds that the 
teaching in reality lasted only for two years, interpreting 
<scripRef id="iv.vi-p41.1" passage="John 5:1" parsed="|John|5|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.5.1">John 5:1</scripRef> as referring to some 
unnamed minor feast.<note n="86" id="iv.vi-p41.2">Reading “a feast” instead of “the 
feast” (<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vi-p41.3">ἑορτὴ</span> for 
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vi-p41.4">ἡ ἑορτή</span>).</note> 
This view cannot be disproved, but it seems to have nothing to recommend it, and 
it introduces quite unnecessary discord between the different Gospels. The chronological 
marks in the Gospels are so slight that almost anything can be made out of them, 
if one is bent on doing so. Hence there was in ancient time an immense variety of 
opinion on this point. But in four independent accounts of one series of events, 
a reasonable criticism will prefer the interpretation in which all the various conditions 
are reconciled.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p42">At the last moment, after this chapter is in type, Professor 
Paterson reminds me that the result which we have attained agrees with the celebrated 
calculation of Kepler, who fixed on the year BC. 6, because in March of that year 
there occurred a conjunction of Jupiter, Saturn and Mars, which would present a 
most brilliant appearance in the sky, and would naturally attract the attention 
of observers interested in the phenomena of the heavens, as were the Wise Men of 
the East.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p43">I have no knowledge what is the value of Kepler’s reckoning. 
Mr. Turner, who knows much more about the matter, speaks only of the conjunction 
of Jupiter and Saturn, which occurred in, May, October and December, BC. 7; and 
I presume that he would have mentioned the triple conjunction (on which Kepler laid 
such stress), if he had accepted the calculation, even though it does not suit the 
date 7-6, to which he inclines. The coincidence, however, seems worthy of mention, 
but it is not presented as an argument.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p44">But, while we lay no stress upon it as an argument, the 
subject is so interesting, and presents so many curious coincidences, that a few 
paragraphs may profitably be devoted to it.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p45">The conjunction of Jupiter and Saturn in the constellation 
Pisces, according to a Jewish belief of some antiquity,<note n="87" id="iv.vi-p45.1">Mr. Turner says: “The statement of 
a medieval Jew, R. Abarbanel, that the conjunction of these two planets in Pisces 
is to be a sign of Messiah’s coming, may perhaps have been derived ultimately 
from ancient traditions known to the Chaldaeans”.</note> 
is the sign of the Messiah’s coming. If there existed some belief that the coming 
of a King of the Jews was to be heralded thus, the occurrence of the phenomenon 
would necessarily arrest the attention of the astrology-loving priests in the East. Kepler’s theory was, that just as the conjunction in 1604 of Jupiter and Saturn, 
culminated in 1605 in the conjunction of Jupiter, Saturn and Mars, and was followed 
by the appearance of a new and brilliant star, which disappeared again after about 
eighteen months, so in BC. 7 and 6, the exactly singular conjunctions were followed 
by the appearance of a new star after the triple conjunction, and that this was 
the star of <scripRef id="iv.vi-p45.2" passage="Matthew 2:2" parsed="|Matt|2|2|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Matt.2.2">Matthew 2:2</scripRef>.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p46">Now the visit of the Magi obviously did not occur until 
more than forty days after the birth of Jesus,<note n="88" id="iv.vi-p46.1">The ceremony in Jerusalem, <scripRef id="iv.vi-p46.2" passage="Luke 2:22" parsed="|Luke|2|22|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.2.22">Luke 2:22</scripRef>, could not have 
taken place after the visit of the Magi, for the flight into Egypt must have 
followed immediately on the visit.</note> 
and may probably be placed during the winter of BC. 6-5. Kepler’s theory involves 
that they appeared before Herod at this time, and informed him of the reason of 
their coming. Herod thereupon consulted the Jewish priests, and heard from them 
that the King was to be born in Bethlehem. He also questioned the Magi privately, 
and learned the exact facts with regard to the appearance 
of the star, and doubtless also with regard to the whole phenomenon in the heavens. 
He would learn from the Magi that the fateful conjunction first occurred in May 
of the year BC. 7. Then he sent the Magi away to Bethlehem, and awaited news of 
their discovery. When they did not return, he ordered all children under two years 
of age in Bethlehem to be killed. The King might have been born at any time after 
the first conjunction occurred; and that was at least eighteen months ago. Therefore, 
in order to make sure, the order included every child under two.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p47">Now about this time, as Josephus mentions,<note n="89" id="iv.vi-p47.1"><i>Ant. Jud</i>., 17., 2, 4.</note> 
Herod was troubled by a prophecy that the power was about to pass away from him 
and from his family; and the Pharisees, from favor to the wife of Pheroras (who 
promised to pay their fine), predicted that the succession would come to her and 
her children. Obviously, the second part of the prophecy was pure invention, due 
to partisanship; but the first part was almost certainly connected with the Jews’ 
deep-seated belief in the coming of a new King, the Messiah. Lewin (whose arrangement 
of the events in the last three years of Herod’s life seems very good) places this 
event in BC. 6; Schuerer dates it in 7. One or the other must be right. Herod put 
to death the ringleaders of the Pharisees, with two of his own personal attendants, 
and also all those of his own household that had associated themselves with the 
prediction of the Pharisees.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p48">There occurred therefore a number of deaths among the family 
and attendants of Herod in connection with the belief in the coming of a new King.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p49">Now Macrobius, a pagan writer about AD. 400, says that 
when the news was brought to Augustus that Herod, King of the Jews, had ordered 
children under two years of age in Syria to be slain, and that among them was a 
son of Herod’s, the Emperor remarked, “It is better to be Herod’s pig than his son”.<note n="90" id="iv.vi-p49.1">Augustus must have uttered the witticism 
in Greek: the pun (<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vi-p49.2">ὗν ἢυἱόν</span>) is lost in Latin or English: see Macrobius,
<i>Sat</i>., 2., 4.</note> 
It is not probable that Macrobius was indebted to a Christian writer for this story;<note n="91" id="iv.vi-p49.3">(1) The pagans of that time were 
strongly prejudiced against Christians and not likely to quote them. (2) A Christian 
author would have spoken about Palestine, not about Syria.</note> and, therefore, probably the story of the Massacre of the Infants 
was recorded in some pagan source. The execution of the conspirators in Herod’s 
household perhaps occurred about the same time; but among them there is not likely 
to have been a son of Herod’s. Only a few months before, however, Herod had put 
to death two of his sons, and the remark of Augustus may have been prompted by hearing 
successively of so many barbarities, the execution of two sons, of a number of infants, 
and of several of his own family and personal attendants.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p50">While all these statements furnish only vague presumptions, 
yet they certainly tend to show that much was going on of a remarkable character 
about BC. 7-6, and they fit in well with both Luke and Matthew. If the narratives 
of these two writers are true, they throw much light on Josephus and Macrobius, 
and receive illustration and confirmation from them.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p51">But that which is most certain is that our non-Christian 
authorities are most meager and fragmentary. It is the extreme of uncritical and 
unscholarly procedure to condemn the Christian authorities because they tell some 
things which are not mentioned in any non-Christian source.</p>

<hr />
<p class="center" id="iv.vi-p52"><b>NOTE 1</b></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p53">The fifteenth year of Tiberius. There are various ways 
of counting the years of an emperor’s reign; and doubt often exists which way is 
intended, when a date is given.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p54">Luke might reckon the years of an emperor as beginning 
always from the anniversary of the day on which power was conferred on him. That 
mode of reckoning seems to have been always used by the emperors of the first century. 
In that case the fifteenth year of Tiberius’s rule in the provinces began near the 
end of AD. 25, on the anniversary of the day when he originally received collegiate 
authority in the provinces. But that method was rarely, if ever, used by the general 
public or by historians in the East.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p55">There was, however, a different method which was usually 
employed by many historians and chronologists, and was officially used by the emperors 
of the second and third centuries. The first year of the emperor was estimated to 
run from the day on which he assumed power to the conclusion of the current year; 
then the second year of the emperor began on the first day of the following current 
year.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p56">If that reckoning was followed by Luke, we should have 
to inquire what system of years he followed, whether he counted the years as beginning 
on the Roman system from 1st January, or on the most 
usual Greek system in the Aegean lands from 23rd September, or on a common Syrian 
system from 18th April.<note n="92" id="iv.vi-p56.1">See below, Note 2.</note> 
On these three systems the fifteenth year of Tiberius might begin either 1st January, 
BC. 25, or 23rd September, 25, or 18th April, 25.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p57">But according to every system it will be found that the 
first Passover of Jesus’ teaching was the Passover of AD. 26: the only difference 
which they make to the reckoning is that John’s preaching might be made to begin 
a little earlier on some than on other systems.</p>
<p class="center" id="iv.vi-p58"><b>NOTE 2</b></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p59">It is unfortunate that, in his admirable article on the 
“Chronology of the New Testament,” Mr. C. H. Turner sometimes disregards the principle 
admitted by most of the recent chronologists — that when any event was taken as 
an era, the years were not reckoned beginning from that day, but the year 1 was 
reckoned as the current year within which the event occurred, as for example in 
the Asian year beginning 23rd September, the year 1 of the Actian era was the year
<i>ending </i>22nd September, B. C. 31, although the battle of Actium was fought 
as late as 2nd September, 31 (so that the year 1 of this era came to an end three 
weeks after it began). This principle has been proved repeatedly in the last few 
years, and many difficulties, formerly found in reckoning ancient dates, disappear 
as soon as it is applied. Mr. Turner follows the old method, that the year 1 runs 
for twelve months from the epoch-making event (<i>e.g</i>., that the first year 
of Herod’s reign lasted for 365 days from the day of his accession, and so on). 
Thus he is beset by the difficulties that result from it: <i>e.g</i>., he declares 
that Josephus contradicts himself when he says that Antigonus died “on the day of 
the Great Fast in the consulship of Agrippa and Gallus (BC. 37), twenty-seven years 
to a day since the entry of Pompey into Jerusalem in the consulship of Antonius 
and Cicero (BC. 63)”. Josephus, indeed, has admitted not a few faults and slips 
into his historical works; but it is surely going too far to say that the two reckonings 
given in this sentence contradict one another. There is no contradiction, if one 
counts like Josephus. According to Mr. Turner’s reckoning, the lapse of twenty-seven 
years after (<i>circa</i>) 30th September, 63, brings us to 30th September, 36, but it brought Josephus only to 30th September, 37; and 
his two statements (made side by side in his text) agree exactly.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p60">According to Niese in<i> Hermes</i>, 1893, p. 208 ff., 
Josephus in reckoning the years under the Roman emperors employed a solar year of 
the Julian type, but reckoned according to a Ty1ian (and perhaps common Syrian) 
method so that the year began from I Xanthicus, 18th April. Josephus also, as Niese 
holds, in order to avoid making the last year of one emperor coincide with the first 
year of his successor, reckoned the final year of each emperor as continuing, to 
the end of the current year, and made the first year of his successor begin only 
on 18th April following his accession. This was necessary if the years of the emperors 
were to be used in a continuous chronological system. In this way, the year 1 of 
Tiberius began on 18th April, AD. 15, and the year 22 continued to run till 17th 
April, AD. 37 (though the reign really lasted from 19th August, A.D. 14, to 16th 
March, AD. 37, <i>i.e</i>., twenty-two years, six months, twenty-eight days). 
Similarly, the year 1 of Nero began only on 18th April, AD. 55, full six months 
after he really began to reign.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p61">Mr, Turner points out that Eusebius followed a similar 
(but not identical) method, counting the years of every emperor from the September 
after his succession.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p62">Orosius either employed a reckoning of this character or 
was misled by some authority who did so; and hence he makes the tenth year of Claudius 
include an event that happened in 51, and we must suppose that he means the fourth 
year of Claudius to be AD. 45, and the ninth, AD. 50 (see <i>St. Paul the Traveller</i>, 
pp. 68, 254, where I did not perceive what was the explanation of Orosius’s statements 
and called them errors).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p63">But it is clear that Josephus did not employ this kind 
of reckoning for the Jewish rulers before Christ. It is more probable that he used 
either the Jewish sacred year beginning 1st Nisan (usually some time in March) or 
the Roman year beginning 1st January. For our purposes it will make no difference 
which system we follow (though there are, of course, many cases in which it might 
make the difference of a year); and as it will be simpler to use the Roman and modern 
reckoning from 1st January, we shall show the dates on that system.</p>

<div style="margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align:justify; margin-top:9pt" id="iv.vi-p63.1">
<p class="continue" id="iv.vi-p64"><b>1.</b> Herod’s reign <i>de jure </i>began from a decree 
of the Senate passed in the consulship of Domitius and Pollio BC. 40, 
during the 184th Olympiad which ended at midsummer in that year. Year 
1 of Herod’s reign <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vi-p64.1">de jure</span> ended on 31st December BC.. 40: year 
37 of Herod’s reign <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vi-p64.2">de jure</span> ended 
on 31st December, BC. 4.</p>
</div>

<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p65">(If the decree was passed at a Senate meeting of 1st January 
or 1st February, and the Jewish reckoning from 1st Nisan be followed, the years 
of Herod’s reign would all be carried back one year, so that the year 37 would end 
on 18th April, BC 4; but it is improbable that the decree was passed at these first 
two Senate meetings.) Herod died in the thirty seventh year of his reign <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vi-p65.1">de jure</span>, 
i.e., in the year BC. 4, immediately before the Passover, and perhaps (as Lewin 
reckons) on 1st April.</p>

<div style="margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align:justify; margin-top:9pt" id="iv.vi-p65.2">
<p class="continue" id="iv.vi-p66"><b>2.</b> 
Pompey entered Jerusalem on the Great Fast about the end of September, 
BC. 63. In reckoning from this event, year 1 is the year ending 31st 
December, BC. 63; year 27 is the year ending 31st December, BC. 37; 
Herod succeeded as <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vi-p66.1">de facto</span> king on the same fast day, twenty-seven 
years after Pompey entered Jerusalem, <i>i.e</i>., about the end of 
September, BC. 37, in which year the consuls were Agrippa and Gallus. 
Year 1 of Herod’s reign <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vi-p66.2">de facto</span> ended 31st December, BC. 37; 
year 18 of Herod’s reign <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vi-p66.3">de facto</span> ended 31st December, BC. 29;  
year 34 of Herod’s reign <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vi-p66.4">de facto</span> ended 31st December, BC. 4.</p>
</div>

<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p67">Herod died in the year 34 of his reign <i>de facto</i>,
<i>i.e</i>., in the year BC. 4. This agrees exactly with the previous result.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p68">Now the Temple began to be built in the eighteenth year 
of Herod, i. e.,BC. 20. In reckoning from this event (<scripRef id="iv.vi-p68.1" passage="John 2:20" parsed="|John|2|20|0|0" osisRef="Bible:John.2.20">John 
2:20</scripRef>), the Jews would presumably count according to 
their own system of sacred years beginning 1st Nisan. There is therefore a doubt 
what was the first year of the building of the Temple. If the building began in 
January-March, BC. 20, the first year would end at 1st Nisan 20, and would begin 
from 1st Nisan, BC. 21; but if the building began in April or later, the first year 
would end at 1st Nisan in BC. 19. We take the latter as more probable. Then the 
year 1 of the building of the Temple begins on 1st Nisan, BC. 20; year 46 of the 
building of the Temple begins on 1st Nisan, AD. 26.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p69">The Jews disputing with Jesus at the Passover in the middle 
of Nisan AD. 26 would therefore on their system of reckoning call it the 46th year. 
“Forty and six years has this temple been in course of building (and is still building).”<note n="93" id="iv.vi-p69.1">See Mr. Turner on his p. 405.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p70">It is apparent how many uncertainties are caused in ancient 
chronology, through the variety of systems of reckoning the year, and other variations 
in different cities. We have not indicated nearly all such causes of doubt. For 
example, as M. Clermont Ganneau says, the Seleucid era was reckoned from 1st October, 
BC. 312, but the era of Damascus was reckoned from 23rd March of the same year.</p>
<p class="center" id="iv.vi-p71"><b>NOTE 3</b></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p72">A different explanation of Luke’s chronology may be approved 
by some, and it therefore deserves a place here. I am not aware that it has been 
advocated; but in all probability it has found some supporters, like every other 
possible view on this subject.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p73">It is founded on the theory — which some think highly probable 
— that Luke considered the teaching of Jesus to have extended only over a little 
more than twelve months, beginning shortly before the Passover in one year and ending 
with the Passover of the following year. On that theory one might interpret the 
fifteenth year of Tiberius’s reign in the usual way, from his assumption of power 
after the death of Augustus, 19th August, AD. 14. If, as many historians did, Luke 
reckoned the first year of Tiberius to end on 31st December, AD. 14, and the fifteenth 
year to begin 1st January, AD. 28, the baptism of Jesus would have to be placed 
early in that year, and the crucifixion at the Passover of 29. If, on the other 
hand, he reckoned the first year of Tiberius from 19th August, AD. 14, to 18th August, 
AD. 15, then the baptism of Jesus would have to be placed early in 29, and the crucifixion 
in AD. 30; but we have already set aside this supposition as less probable.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p74">According to this method of explanation it would be necessary 
to suppose that in <scripRef passage="Luke 3:23" id="iv.vi-p74.1" parsed="|Luke|3|23|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.3.23">3:23</scripRef> Luke depended on an excellent authority, who knew both the 
correct age when Jesus began his teaching and the fact that the teaching lasted 
three years and a few months; but in <scripRef passage="Luke 3:1-2" id="iv.vi-p74.2" parsed="|Luke|3|1|3|2" osisRef="Bible:Luke.3.1-Luke.3.2">3:1-2</scripRef> 
he depended on his own reckoning, founded on his false impression that the teaching 
lasted only one year and a few months. The fact would 
remain clear and certain that the crucifixion took place in AD. 29, and the teaching 
really began in the early spring of 26 (exactly as we have placed them).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vi-p75">There seems to us to be no necessity for supposing this 
partial error on Luke’s part.</p>

</div2>

      <div2 title="Chapter 11. Quirinius the Governor of Syria" progress="83.36%" id="iv.vii" prev="iv.vi" next="v">

<h3 id="iv.vii-p0.1">CHAPTER 11 <br />
QUIRINIUS THE GOVERNOR OF SYRIA</h3>

<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p1">WE come now to the last serious difficulty in Luke’s account 
of the “First Enrollment”. He says that it occurred while Quirinius was administering 
Syria.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p2">The famous administration of Syria by Quirinius lasted 
from about AD. 6 to 9; and during that time occurred the” Great Enrollment” and 
valuation of property in Palestine.<note n="94" id="iv.vii-p2.1"><scripRef id="iv.vii-p2.2" passage="Acts 5:37" parsed="|Acts|5|37|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.5.37">Acts 5:37</scripRef>; Josephus, <i>Ant. Jud</i>., 17., 13; 18., 1, 1.</note> 
Obviously the incidents described by Luke are irreconcilable with that date.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p3">There was found near Tibur (Tivoli) in AD. 1764 a fragment 
of marble with part of an inscription, which is now preserved in the Lateran Museum 
of Christian Antiquities, as one of the important monuments bearing on the history 
of Christianity. The inscription records the career and honors of a Roman official 
who lived in the reign of Augustus, and survived that emperor. He conquered a nation; 
he was rewarded with two <i>Supplicationes</i> and 
the <i>Ornamenta Triumphalia</i>, <i>i.e.</i>, he gorgeous dress of a triumphing 
general, with ivory scepter and chariot, <i>etc</i>.; he governed Asia as proconsul; 
and he twice governed Syria as <i>legatus</i> of the divine Augustus.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p4">Though the name has perished, yet these indications are 
sufficient to show with practical certainty (as all the highest authorities are 
agreed — Mommsen, Borghesi, de Rossi, Henzen, Dessau, and others), that the officer 
who achieved this splendid career was Publius Sulpicius Quirinius. His government 
of Syria, AD. 6-9, was therefore his second tenure of that office. He had administered 
Syria at some previous time. Is not this earlier administration the occasion to 
which Luke refers?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p5">Here again, however, we are confronted with a serious difficulty. 
The supreme authority on the subject, Mommsen, considers that the most probable 
date for Quirinius’s first government of Syria is about BC. 3-1; but the question 
is involved in serious doubts, which Mommsen fully acknowledges. That time is doubly 
inconsistent with Luke: Herod was dead before it, and it is inconsistent with the 
whole argument of the preceding pages that the enrollment 
should have been postponed so long after the periodic year BC. 9.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p6">Again, Luke does not specify exactly what was the Roman 
office which Quirinius held at the time when this first enrollment was made. The 
Greek word which he uses <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vii-p6.1">ἡγεμονεύοντος τῆς Συρίας Κυρηνίου</span> occurs elsewhere in his History, indicating 
the office of procurator (<scripRef id="iv.vii-p6.2" passage="Luke 3:1" parsed="|Luke|3|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.3.1">Luke 3:1</scripRef>; 
so <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vii-p6.3">ἡγεμών</span>,
<scripRef id="iv.vii-p6.4" passage="Acts 23:24, 26, 33" parsed="|Acts|23|24|0|0;|Acts|23|26|0|0;|Acts|23|33|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.23.24 Bible:Acts.23.26 Bible:Acts.23.33">Acts 23:24, 26, 33</scripRef>; <scripRef id="iv.vii-p6.5" passage="Acts 24:1, 10" parsed="|Acts|24|1|0|0;|Acts|24|10|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.24.1 Bible:Acts.24.10">Acts 24:1, 10</scripRef>  
and <scripRef id="iv.vii-p6.6" passage="Acts 26:30" parsed="|Acts|26|30|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.26.30">Acts 26:30</scripRef>) and the noun connected with it is even used (<scripRef id="iv.vii-p6.7" passage="Luke 3:1" parsed="|Luke|3|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Luke.3.1">Luke 3:1</scripRef>) 
to indicate the supreme authority exercised by the reigning Emperor in a province.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p7">Hence the word, as employed by Luke, might be applied to 
any Roman official holding a leading and authoritative position in the province 
of Syria. It might quite naturally denote some special mission of a high and authoritative 
nature; and many excellent authorities have argued that Quirinius was dispatched 
to Syria on some such mission, and that Luke, in assigning the date, mentions him 
in preference to the regular governor.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p8">We find, then, that uncertainty reigns both as to the date 
of Quirinius’s first governorship, and as to whether Luke called him governor or 
intended to indicate that he held a special mission in Syria.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p9">Let us now scrutinize closely the evidence bearing on the 
career of Quirinius. We shall find that, as in so many other cases, a firm grasp 
of the clue that Luke offers us will guide us safely through a peculiarly entangled 
problem, and will illuminate a most obscure page of history. The difficulties of 
the case are due to the contempt in which Luke’s testimony has been held by the 
historians and one school of theologians, and the timorous and faltering belief 
of others.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p10">The only certain dates in the life of Quirinius are his 
consulship in BC. 12, his second government of Syria beginning in AD. 6, his prosecution 
of his former wife, Domitia Lepida, in AD. 20, and his death and public funeral 
in AD. 21. It is certain that during the eighteen years’ interval between his consulship, 
BC. 12, and his second Syrian administration, AD. 6, the following important events 
in his career occurred.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p11"><b>1.</b> He held office in 
Syria, and carried on war with the Homonadenses, a tribe in the inner mountainous 
district lying between Phrygia, Cilicia and Lycaonia: he gained in this war successes 
which were judged so important that two solemn acts of thanksgiving to the gods 
(<span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p11.1">supplicationes</span>) in Rome were decreed, and the decorations of a triumphing 
general were awarded to him. The two <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p11.2">supplicationes</span> were probably awarded 
for victories in two successive years, for a <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p11.3">supplicatio</span> was the compliment 
awarded for a successful campaign, and it is hardly probable that two such compliments 
would be paid to a general in one year for a single war against one tribe. Moreover, 
taking into consideration the difficult character of the country where the war occurred, 
the distance from Syria, the strength of the tribe which had successfully defied 
the armies of King Amyntas, and the stubborn resistance likely to be offered at 
point after point and town after town in their large territory, it is quite natural 
that two campaigns might be required for the whole operations. It is, however, not 
wholly impossible that two specially brilliant victories may have been gained in 
one year over the tribe, and that each was thought worthy of a <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p11.4">supplicatio</span>.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p12"><b>2.</b> Quirinius governed 
Asia after his first administration of Syria. This was usually an annual office, 
and the probability therefore is that in his case also it lasted only one year. 
The exact date is uncertain. We know with great probability that</p>
<div style="margin-left:.75in" id="iv.vii-p12.1">
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p13">Asinius Gallus governed Asia in BC. 6-5.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p14">Cn. Lentulus Augur governed Asia in BC. 2-1, also BC. 1-AD. 1<note n="95" id="iv.vii-p14.1">Lentulus was in office in Asia on 10th 
May, BC. 1, and therefore, as Mommsen says, governed during the year 
2-1 (<i>Res Gestae D. Aug.,</i> p. 170). But, as Waddington sees (<i>Fastes d’Asie,</i> 
p. 101), Lentulus seems to have been still in office on 12th August, and therefore 
probably ruled Asia also in the year 1 BC. — 1 AD.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p15">M. Plautius Silvanus governed Asia in AD. 1-2.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p16">Marcius Censorinus governed Asia in AD. 2-3.</p>
</div>

<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p17">Further, Quirinius was probably in Armenia in AD. 3, as 
tutor of Gaius Caesar. There are therefore open for Quirinius’s tenure of the proconsulship 
of Asia only the years BC. 5-4, or 4-3, or 3-2, or AD. 4-5, or 5-6.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p18">Again, as M. Waddington, the supreme authority on the subject, 
points out, the normal interval between the consulship and the proconsulate of Asia 
during Augustus’s reign was five or six years. The only long interval known in that 
period is twelve years, viz., in the case of Cn. Lentulus Augur, who was consul 
BC. 14 and proconsul of Asia BC. 2. It is therefore not probable that Quirinius’s 
proconsulate was postponed over such a long interval as sixteen years (BC. 12 to 
AD. 4). We therefore conclude that he was probably governor of Asia some years between 
BC. 5 and 2, and at latest BC. 3-2. Now, his Syrian administration was earlier, 
and therefore BC. 4-3 is the latest that he can have spent in Syria.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p19">Thus already we find ourselves led to a different opinion 
from Mommsen’s theory.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p20"><b>3. </b>When Lollius, the 
tutor of Augustus’s young grandson Gaius Caesar, who was charged with the arrangement 
of the Armenian difficulties, died in AD. 2, Quirinius was selected as his successor, 
obviously on the ground of his great experience in Eastern service. Thereafter he 
must have spent AD. 3 in Armenia, and probably remained in company with Gaius 
until the latter, coming back towards Italy wounded and ill, died on the Lycian 
coast on 21st February, AD. 4.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p21">Zumpt, however, argued that Quirinius was sent to Armenia 
with Gaius Caesar in BC. 1; and that afterwards Lollius took his place. We follow 
Mommsen; but it is obvious how difficult and slippery the whole career of Quirinius 
is, and how slow we should be to condemn Luke for an error in regard to him.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p22"><b>4.</b> Quirinius married 
Domitia Lepida at some unknown date. He afterwards divorced her, and accused her 
of attempting to poison him in A. D. 20. Suetonius mentions, as a fact which roused 
general sympathy for Domitia, that the accusation was brought in the twentieth year 
after. We ask, “After what?” Common-sense shows Mommsen and others to be right 
in understanding “the twentieth year after the marriage”; we therefore reject the 
other interpretation “the twentieth year after the divorce”.<note n="96" id="iv.vii-p22.1">Mr. Furneaux takes the latter sense in his admirable edition of Tacitus, <i>Annals</i>, 3., 23, and so apparently 
does Nipperdey also; and it must be acknowledged that Suetonius’s expression suits that. Sense and the historical facts, however, show it to be impossible.</note> 
Mommsen supposes that the marriage was contracted in AD. 4, when Quirinius returned 
from his honorable duties in Armenia, and that Suetonius makes a great exaggeration 
when he speaks of the twentieth year. But in such an obscure subject it is surely 
best to follow the few authorities whom we have, unless they are proved to be inconsistent 
with known facts. Suetonius is a good authority. Can we not justify him to some 
extent?</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p23">Domitia Lepida had been betrothed to Augustus’s elder grandson, 
Lucius Caesar, and on his premature death was married to Quirinius. Now Lucius died 
on 20th August, AD. 2. But the Romans of that period showed the minimum of delicacy 
in respect of marriages. As soon as the betrothed husband of a wealthy and noble 
heiress died, the place was open to reward some of Augustus’s trusted servants; 
and no long delay is likely to have occurred in giving her a substitute for Lucius. 
It is probable that she was married to Quirinius in the autumn of AD. 2, and thus 
the accusation was brought against her in the nineteenth year (according to Roman 
methods of counting) from her marriage. In round numbers the populace would talk 
of “the twentieth year,” and thus Suetonius’s expression is justified; he professes 
to be reporting the common talk about the trial.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p24">We conclude, then, that Quirinius was in Rome in the autumn 
of AD. 2; and was then honored with this grand marriage and the post of guardian 
to the future emperor, Gaius Caesar. But such honors as this imply that his career 
in preceding years had been very distinguished. Thus we become still more firmly 
convinced that his pro-consulate in Asia was past as well as his government of 
Syria, and that these positions, with the experience in Oriental affairs acquired 
in them, marked out Quirinius as the proper person to guide the inexperienced Gaius 
Caesar, and to set right the muddle which had been produced by the headstrong and 
ill-regulated conduct of Lollius, the previous guardian of the young prince.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p25">These lines of reasoning make it most probable that the 
two years during which Quirinius was administering Syria and conquering the Homonadenses 
cannot have been later than BC. 5-3, and may have been earlier.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p26">The same result follows from the consideration that the 
punishment of the Homonadenses is not likely to have been postponed so late as the 
years BC. 3-2. The presence of a tribe of barbarians, hostile and victorious, on 
the frontier of the Roman provinces Galatia and Pamphylia, and adjoining the dependent 
kingdom of Cilicia Tracheia governed by Archelaos, must have been a source of constant 
danger. We know that about BC. 6 the pacification of the mountainous Pisidian districts 
in the south of the Galatic province was proceeding, and the system of military 
roads was being constructed;<note n="97" id="iv.vii-p26.1">See my <i>Church in the Roman Empire,</i> p. 32; C. I. L., 3., No. 6974.</note> 
and this operation was probably coincident with or even subsequent to the war against 
the Homonadenses.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p27">But here we find ourselves face to face with the difficulty 
which has determined Professor Mommsen to place the first Syrian government of Quirinius 
in BC. 3-1. Quinctilius Varus governed Syria for at least three years, 7-4 BC.: 
this is rendered quite certain by dated coins of Syrian Antioch struck in his name,<note n="98" id="iv.vii-p27.1">See Note 1 at the end of Chapter 11.</note> 
and by the statement of Tacitus that he was governing Syria during the disturbances 
that followed on the death of Herod.<note n="99" id="iv.vii-p27.2">Probably about 1st April, BC. 4.</note> 
Sentius Saturninus certainly governed Syria 9-7 BC., and Josephus says that he was 
succeeded by Quinctilius Varus.<note n="100" id="iv.vii-p27.3"><i>Ant. Jud.,</i> 17., 5, 2.</note> 
There seems therefore no room for Quirinius’s administration of Syria until we come 
down as late as BC. 3; yet we have already seen that other lines of argument prompt 
us to place his Syrian government earlier than that year.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p28">In this difficulty I see no outlet in any direction, whether 
favorable or unfavorable to Luke, except in the supposition that the foreign relations 
of Syria, with the command of its armies, were entrusted for a time to Quirinius, 
with a view to his conducting the difficult and responsible war against the Homonadenses, 
while the internal administration of the province was left to Saturninus or to Varus 
(according to the period when we place the mission of Quirinius). This extraordinary 
command of Quirinius lasted for at least two years, and had come to an end before 
the death of Herod in BC. 4, for we know on the authority of Tacitus that the disturbances 
arising in Palestine on that event were put down by Varus; and this trouble, as 
belonging to the foreign relations of the Province, would on our hypothesis have 
been dealt with by Quirinius, if he had been still in office.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p29">The question will be put, and must be answered, whether 
such a temporary division of duties in the Province is in accordance with the Roman 
Imperial practice. Such a theory is not permissible, unless it is defended by analogous 
cases and by natural probability. The theory was first suggested to my mind by the 
analogous case of the African administration, which from the time of Caligula onwards 
was divided in such a way, that the military power, and with it the foreign policy 
of the Province, was controlled by a Lieutenant of Augustus,<note n="101" id="iv.vii-p29.1"><span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p29.2">Legatus Augusti pro praetore.</span></note> 
while the internal affairs of the Province were left to the ordinary governor, a 
Proconsul.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p30">Almost simultaneously with my papers on the subject there 
appeared a memoir by Monsieur R. S. Bour,<note n="102" id="iv.vii-p30.1">See Note 2 at the end of Chapter 11.</note> 
in which he quotes some other analogies to justify this view. He points out that 
Vespasian conducted the war in Palestine, while Mucianus was governor of Syria, 
from which Palestine was dependent. Tacitus<note n="103" id="iv.vii-p30.2"><i>Hist., </i>1., 10.</note> 
styles Vespasian dux, which is not a strictly official title, but exactly describes 
his actual duty. He was a Lieutenant of the reigning Emperor Nero,<note n="104" id="iv.vii-p30.3"><span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p30.4">Legatus Augusti pro praetore.</span></note> 
holding precisely the same title and technical rank as Mucianus. We suppose that 
Quirinius stood in exactly the same relation to Varus as Vespasian in regard to 
Mucianus. Quirinius was a special Lieutenant of Augustus, who conducted the war 
against the Homonadenses, while Varus administered the ordinary affairs of Syria. 
The duties of Quirinius might be described by calling him dux in Latin, and the 
Greek equivalent is necessarily and correctly
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vii-p30.5">ἡγεμών</span>, 
as Luke has it.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p31">Again, Corbulo commanded the armies of Syria in the war 
against Parthia and Armenia, while Ummidius Quadratus<note n="105" id="iv.vii-p31.1">He was unfit for the war, Mommsen,
<i>Rom. Gesch.,</i> 5., 382 f. Corbulo governed Syria for a time after Quadratus; but the burden apparently was too great, and Gallus was appointed.</note> 
and Cestius Gallus were governors of Syria. Josephus speaks of Gallus, but never 
mentions the name of Corbulo. We suppose that Quirinius stood in the same relative 
position as Corbulo, and Josephus preserves the same silence about both.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p32">The chief difference between the view which M. Bour holds 
and the theory which we advocate is that he distinguishes this position which Quirinius 
held in BC. 7-6 from the first governorship of Syria, which, like Mommsen, he places 
after BC. 4. This makes the unnecessary complication that Quirinius first commanded 
the Syrian armies, then after two or three years governed Syria, and then once more 
governed Syria. But M. Bour does not observe that even on the first occasion Quirinius 
was <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p32.1">legatus Augusti;</span> and it appears quite correct 
to say that in AD. 6-9 he as <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p32.2">legatus Divi Alugusti 
iterum Syria obtinuit</span>, even if he had not been again governor of Syria 
after BC. 7-6.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p33">Moreover, in the inscription recording the career of (probably) 
Quirinius, there is no possible space to insert a distinct government of Syria between 
his successes against the Homonadenses and his second governorship. The inscription 
clearly implies that the Homonadenses were conquered in his first Syrian administration.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p34">It is a matter of secondary importance that M. Bour supposes 
Saturninus to have ruled Syria while the enrollment of Palestine was going on, and 
yet acknowledges that this occurred in BC. 7 or 6. As we have seen, Varus came to 
govern Syria in the summer of BC. 7.<note n="106" id="iv.vii-p34.1">M. Bour also finds an allusion to 
the universal enrollment in a phrase of the <i>Monumentum Ancyranum</i> where 
the restored text was <span lang="LA" id="iv.vii-p34.2"><i>omnium prov</i>[ <i>inciarum censure egi or statum 
ordinavi</i>]</span>; but he has not remarked that the recovered Greek translation 
proves the sense and words to have been <span lang="LA" id="iv.vii-p34.3"><i>omnium prov</i>[<i> inciarum Populi 
Romani</i>]… <i>fines auxi.</i></span></note></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p35">The conclusion of the whole argument is this.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p36">About BC. 8-5, Augustus made a great effort to pacify the 
dangerous and troublesome mountaineers of Taurus, to prevent the continual plundering 
Which they practiced on the peaceable provinces to which they were neighbors, Asia, 
Galatia and Syria-Cilicia, and to avenge the death of the Roman tributary King 
of Galatia, Amyntas, in BC. 25. On the one hand the governor of Galatia, on the 
other hand the governor of Syria, were both required in this work. Part of the mountaineers’ 
country was nominally part of the Province Galatia, having been formerly in the 
kingdom of Amyntas (which had been transformed into the Province Galatia). But Galatia 
did not contain an army; and the administration of Syria-Cilicia had always to 
intervene, when Roman troops were needed during that period on the eastern Roman 
frontiers.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p37">In BC. 6 the first great step and foundation of the Roman 
organization was in process of being carried out among the western and northern 
mountaineers by Cornutus Aquila, governor of Galatia. A military road system was 
built among them, and a series of garrison-cities (<span lang="LA" id="iv.vii-p37.1">Coloniae</span>) was founded, Olbasa, 
Comama, Cremna, Parlais and Lystra. These fortresses were connected by the Imperial 
roads<note n="107" id="iv.vii-p37.2"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vii-p37.3">βασιλικαὶ ὁδοί</span>,<i> 
Church in Rom. Emp.</i>, p. 32; Lanckoronski,<i> Stadte Pamphyliens,</i> 2., p. 203.</note> 
with the governing center of Southern Galatia, the great Colonia Caesarea Antiocheia 
in Southern Phrygia adjoining Pisidia.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p38">About the same time the military operations from the side 
of Syria were carried out. Josephus tells so much about Saturninus, as to make it 
clear that he was not engaged in an arduous and difficult war far away in the Taurus 
mountains, south from Iconium and Lystra. Either the war was later than his time, 
or it was conducted by a distinct official. As to the official’s name there is no 
doubt. Strabo<note n="108" id="iv.vii-p38.1">Strabo, p. 569. His account certainly 
suggests both that the revenge was not delayed so late as Mommsen’s view implies, 
and that a good deal of time was needed to carry out all the operations involved, 
the foundation of new cities, the transference of population, <i>etc</i>.</note> 
tells us that it was Quirinius who conquered the Homonadenses and revenged the death 
of Amyntas. The period is, on the whole, likely to coincide with the connected operations 
of Cornutus Aquila on the north-western side.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p39">Accordingly, the probability is that in BC. 7, when Varus 
came to govern Syria, Augustus perceived that the internal affairs of the province 
would require all the energy of the regular governor, and sent at the same time 
a special officer with the usual title, Lieutenant of Augustus, to administer the 
military resources of the province, and specially to conduct the war against the 
Homonadenses and any other foreign relations that demanded military intervention. 
Moreover, Varus had no experience in war; and an experienced officer was needed. 
Thus, Quirinius conducted the war pretty certainly in BC. 6, perhaps in 7 and 6, 
perhaps in 6 and 5.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p40">The first periodic enrollment of Syria was made under Saturninus 
in BC. 8-7. The enrollment of Palestine was delayed by the causes described until 
the late summer or autumn of BC. 6. At that time, Varus was controlling the internal 
affairs of Syria, while Quirinius was commanding its armies and directing its foreign 
policy.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p41">Tertullian, finding that the first periodic enrollment 
in Syria was made under Saturninus, inferred too hastily that the enrollment in 
Palestine was made under that governor. With full consciousness and intention, he 
corrects Luke’s statement, and declares that Christ was born during the census taken 
by Sentius Saturninus. Luke, more accurately, says that the enrollment of Palestine 
was made while Quirinius was acting as leader (<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vii-p41.1">ἡγεμών</span>) 
in Syria.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p42">The question will perhaps be put whether Luke could rightly 
describe the authority of Quirinius by the words “holding the <i>Hegemonia </i>of 
Syria”. The preceding exposition leaves no doubt on this point. The usage of Luke 
shows that he regards <i>Hegemonia </i>in the provinces as the attribute both 
of the Emperor and of the officers to whom the Emperor delegates his power. Now 
that is quite true in point of fact. The Emperor primarily held the supreme authority 
in Syria (which was one of the Imperatorial provinces, as distinguished from those 
which were administered by the Senate through the agency of its officers, entitled 
Proconsuls). But the Emperor could not himself be present in Syria or in Palestine, 
hence he delegated to substitutes, or Lieutenants, the exercise of his authority 
in the various provinces which were under his own direct power. These substitutes, 
when of senatorial rank, bore the title <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p42.1">Legatus Augusti pro praetore</span>, and 
when of equestrian rank the title <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p42.2">Procurator cum jure gladii</span>; but both <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p42.3">Legati</span> 
and <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="iv.vii-p42.4">Procuratores</span> are called by Luke
<i>Hegemones</i>, as exercising the Hegemonia that 
belongs to the Emperor. Now Quirinius was exercising this delegated Hegemonia over 
the armies of the Province Syria, and it seems quite in keeping with Luke’s brief 
pregnant style to say that he held the Hegemonia of Syria.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p43">But why did Luke not name Varus, the ordinary governor, 
in place of dating by the extraordinary officer? If he had had regard to the susceptibilities 
of modern scholars, and the extreme dearth of knowledge about the period, which 
was to exist 1800 years after he wrote, he would certainly have named Varus. But 
he was writing for readers who could as easily find out about Quirinius as about 
Varus, and he had no regard for us of the nineteenth century. Quirinius ruled for 
a shorter time than Varus, and he controlled the foreign relations of the province, 
hence he furnished the best means of dating.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p44">But why did Luke not distinguish clearly between this enrollment 
and the later enrollment of A. D. 7, which was held by Quirinius in Syria and in 
Palestine? We answer that he does distinguish, accurately and clearly. He tells 
that this was the first enrollment of the series, but the moderns are determined 
to misunderstand him. They insist that Luke confused the use of comparative and 
superlative in Greek, and that we cannot take the full force of the word “first” 
as “first of many”. They go on to put many other stumbling-blocks in the way, but 
none of these cause any difficulty if we hold fast to the fundamental principle 
that Luke was a great historian who wrote good Greek of the first century kind.
</p>
<p class="center" id="iv.vii-p45"><b>NOTE 1</b></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p46">Quinctilius Varus, governor of Syria. The exact date is 
shown by the coins of Antioch, which bear the numbers <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vii-p46.1">κε</span>,
<span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vii-p46.2">κςʹ</span>, <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vii-p46.3">κζʹ</span> 
of the Actian era, accompanied by the name of Varus. Now the battle of Actium was 
fought on 2nd September, 31. When such an event was taken as an era, the years were 
not (as was formerly assumed by many authorities) made to begin from the anniversary 
of the event. The years went on as before; but the current year in which the event 
occurred was reckoned the year 1. Hence, in countries where the Greek year common 
in the Aegean lands, beginning at the autumn equinox, was employed, the year 1 of 
the Actian era was BC. 32-31 (beginning 24th September, 32).</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p47">But that system could not be the one which was employed 
in reckoning the Actian years at Antioch, for the year 26 in that case would end 
in the autumn of BC. 6. Now, coins of the Actian year 26 mention the twelfth consulship 
of Augustus, which did not begin till 1st January, BC. 5; similarly coins of the year 29 (ending on that system in autumn 
BC. 3) mentioned the thirteenth consulship of Augustus, which did not begin until 
1st January, BC. 2.</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p48">The Actian years in Antioch were therefore reckoned by 
a system in which the years began before 2nd September. It is probable that the 
year which was sometimes used in Syria, beginning on 18th April, may have been employed 
also in Antioch. But whatever the exact day of New Year was, the following table 
shows the system of Actian years in Antioch: —</p>
<div style="margin-left:.75in" id="iv.vii-p48.1">
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p49">Actian year <span style="text-align:right; letter-spacing:5pt" id="iv.vii-p49.1"> </span>1 ended in spring (perhaps 17 th April), BC. 30</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p50">Actian year 25 ended in spring (perhaps 17 th April), BC. 6</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p51">Actian year 27 ended in spring (perhaps 17 th April), BC. 4</p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p52">Actian year 29 ended in spring (perhaps 17 th April), BC. 2</p>
</div>

<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p53">Varus, therefore, came to Syria at such a time that coins 
marked 25 were struck after his arrival, <i>i.e</i>., he arrived probably soon after 
midsummer of that year, <i>i.e.</i>, July to September, BC. 7. He remained in Syria 
until at least the midsummer of BC. 4, some months after the death of Herod.
</p>
<p class="center" id="iv.vii-p54"><b>NOTE 2</b></p>
<p class="normal" id="iv.vii-p55">The theory has also been advanced that Quirinius was one 
of a number of commissioners, appointed by Augustus to hold the enrollment throughout 
the Roman world, Quirinius being the commissioner for Syria and Palestine. In this 
capacity, also, Quirinius would be a delegate exercising the Emperor’s authority, 
Legattts Augusti; and therefore he might rightly be said by Luke <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="iv.vii-p55.1">ἡγεμονεύειν 
τῆς Συρίας</span>
This theory is possible; it offends against no principle of Roman procedure or of 
language. It may be the truth. But, on the whole, it seems to have less in its favor 
than the one which has been advocated in the text. M. R. S. Bour<note n="109" id="iv.vii-p55.2"><i>L’Inscription de Quirinius et 
le Recensement de St. Luc,</i> Rome, 1897: a treatise crowned by the <i>Pontificia 
Accademia di Archeologia</i>. This skillful argument was presented to the Academy 
in Dec., 1806, and published in the late summer or autumn of 1897. It refers 
in a concluding note to my papers on the same subject in <i>Expositor</i>, April and June, 1897.</note> 
judges of it exactly as I have done. It was advocated in the summer of 1897 by Signor 
O. Marucchi in the Italian review <i>Bessarione</i>.</p>


</div2>
</div1>

    <div1 title="Part 3. Some Associated Questions" progress="91.74%" id="v" prev="iv.vii" next="v.i">
<h1 id="v-p0.1">PART 3 <br />
SOME ASSOCIATED QUESTIONS</h1>

      <div2 title="Chapter 12. Some Associated Questions" progress="91.75%" id="v.i" prev="v" next="vi">
<h3 id="v.i-p0.1">CHAPTER 12 <br />
SOME ASSOCIATED QUESTIONS</h3>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p1">A BRIEF reference to some of the other difficulties, which 
have been found in Luke’s references to matters of contemporary history, will form 
a fitting conclusion to this study.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p2">In some cases all that is wanted to solve the difficulty 
is proper understanding of Luke’s words. That, for example, is the case with
<scripRef id="v.i-p2.1" passage="Acts 11:28" parsed="|Acts|11|28|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.11.28">Acts 11:28</scripRef>, where the 
statement, that in the days of Claudius there was famine over all the world, has 
been misinterpreted to imply that harvests failed and a famine ensued in every part 
of the whole world at exactly the same time, which would be an obvious exaggeration, 
and therefore not entirely trustworthy: it would be quite in the rhetorical style 
of Tacitus or Juvenal, not in the simple and true manner of Luke.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p3">But, as all the commentators have pointed out, Suetonius, 
Dion Cassius, Tacitus and Eusebius mention scarcity occurring at different times 
in widely scattered parts of the Roman world during that reign; and an inscription 
has been interpreted (though not with certainty) as referring to a famine in Asia 
Minor some years before AD. 56.<note n="110" id="v.i-p3.1"><i>St. Paul the Traveller</i>, p. 48 f.</note> 
At no period in Roman history are so many allusions to widespread famine found as 
under Claudius. Luke refers to what must then have been an accepted belief, that 
at some time or other during the reign of Claudius every part of the Roman world 
suffered from famine.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p4">A much more difficult case occurs in 
<scripRef id="v.i-p4.1" passage="Acts 5:36-37" parsed="|Acts|5|36|5|37" osisRef="Bible:Acts.5.36-Acts.5.37">Acts 5:36-37</scripRef>, where Gamaliel 
in addressing the Sanhedrin says: “Before these days rose up Theudas, giving himself 
out to be somebody, to whom a number of men, about 400, joined themselves, who was 
slain, and all, as many as obeyed him, were dispersed and came to naught. And after 
this man rose up <i>Judas the</i> <i>Galilean 
in the days of ‘the enrollment’ and caused people to revolt</i> under his leadership: 
he also perished; and all, as many as obeyed him, were scattered abroad.”</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p5">Now Josephus describes “a certain magician, named Theudas, 
who, while Fadus was Procurator of Judea, persuaded most of the people <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="v.i-p5.1">τὸν 
πλεῖστον ὄχλον</span> to take up their property and follow 
him to the river Jordan; for he told them 
he was a prophet, and he said that he would
divide the river by his command and afford them easy 
passage through it; and he deceived many by 
telling them this. Fadus, however, did not permit them to profit by their folly, but sent a squadron 
of cavalry against them, which falling unexpectedly 
upon them, slew many of them and captured
many alive. And they took Theudas himself alive and cut off his head and brought it to Jerusalem "(<i>Ant 
Ju</i>d., 20., 5, 1).</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p6">In the following paragraph Josephus describes what happened 
under the government of Tiberius Alexander, the successor of Fadus; and, among other 
things, he tells that “the sons of <i>Judas the Galilean</i> were slain, <i>viz.,</i> that Judas who <i>caused the people to revolt</i> from the 
Romans when <i>Quirinius was making the valuation</i> 
of Judea”.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p7">It is pointed out that in two successive paragraphs Josephus 
speaks first of Theudas and then of Judas, dating the latter under Quirinius; and 
that in two successive verses Luke speaks first of Theudas and then of Judas, dating 
the latter at the great enrollment (<i>i.e</i>., under Quirinius). From this the 
inference is drawn that Luke, reading hurriedly and carelessly the passage of Josephus, 
falsely inferred that Theudas, who is mentioned first, was the elder; and they point 
to the analogy, between the two accounts of Judas,<note n="111" id="v.i-p7.1"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="v.i-p7.2">ἐν ταῖς ἡμέραις τῆς ἀπογραφῆς καὶ ἀπέστησε 
λαὸν ὀπί σω αὐτοῦ </span>in Luke, and <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="v.i-p7.3">τὸν λαὸν ἁπὸ 
ἀποστήσαντος Κυρινίου τῆς 
Ἰουδαίς τιμητεύοντος</span> in Josephus.</note> 
as evidence that Luke borrowed from Josephus.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p8">Finally, since Josephus’s Theudas rose and fell several 
years after Gamaliel is supposed to have delivered his speech, they infer that Luke 
had no authority for the words which he puts into Gamaliel’s mouth, but freely invented 
the whole according to a common practice among ancient historians. Luke, as they 
say, constructed a suitable speech for Gamaliel out of his own scrappy and inaccurate 
reading, and thus made Gamaliel describe an event that had not yet occurred, supposing 
it to have taken place before AD. 6.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p9">Without doubt, if this theory is correct, we must throw 
up our whole case as hopeless. The blunder attributed to Luke is so ingeniously 
many-sided as to destroy his credit in various directions. It shows that he invented 
his speeches without authority; that he was incapable of reading two short paragraphs 
of Greek without misunderstanding them; that, even when he had a good authority 
before him, he could not report his information without introducing a portentous 
blunder; that he was so ignorant of Judean history as to think that an event which 
Josephus dates under Fadus could be, in the first place, older than Gamaliel’s speech 
(delivered soon after AD. 29 or 30), and, in the second place, older than the great 
enrollment. The most wretched old chronicler, in the worst and most ignorant Byzantine 
time, has not succeeded in doing anything so bad as that. To find a parallel instance 
of ignorance and stupidity, where knowledge is professed and must be expected, one 
must come down to modern times and look in the papers of rejected candidates in 
a “pass” examination, who have vainly tried, with the minimum of care and work, 
to delude the examiner into the belief that they know enough to be permitted to 
scrape through the test.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p10">But is not this too gross a blunder? Is it credible that 
a person who was so shockingly ignorant and inaccurate should aspire to be a historian? 
The aspirations of men are usually Founded on the conscious possession of some qualifications 
for success. Luke evidently aimed — and probably was the first to aim — at connecting 
the story of the development of Christianity with the course of general Imperial 
history. Surely he would not have aimed at doing so, unless he possessed a certain 
moderate knowledge of that history. In his preface he declares that his motive for 
writing his work was that he was in possession of such exceptionally excellent information, 
gained from first-rate authorities. But only the grossest incapacity and ignorance 
combined could have enabled him to succeed in attaining so colossal a blunder.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p11">The theory seems to me incredible, irrational, and psychologically 
impossible. It is irreconcilable with the known facts and the character of Luke’s 
History; and I am confident that if it had been stated about any writer who was 
not a Christian, it would have been universally treated with the contempt that it 
merits. It is the sort of fancy that brands its originator and its believer as either 
lacking the critical faculty or blinded by prejudice.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p12">Moreover, the theory is founded on an accidental peculiarity 
of order in the text of Josephus, and presupposes that Luke was indebted entirely 
to one passage of Josephus for his knowledge of Theudas and Judas. He could hardly 
have read any additional authority without acquiring some more correct idea as to 
the time when Theudas lived.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p13">It is not here the place to discuss the question whether 
Luke had read Josephus. As Dr. Sanday<note n="112" id="v.i-p13.1"><i>Bampton Lectures</i>, 1893, p. 278.</note> 
says, the assumption that he used the <i>Jewish Antiquities</i> “rests on little 
more than the fact that both writers relate or allude to the same events, though 
the differences between them are really more marked than the resemblances”. He adds 
that “Schuerer<note n="113" id="v.i-p13.2"><i>Lucas und Josephus in Zeitschr. 
f. krit. Theologie,</i> 1876, p. 574 ff. Josephus’s great work on the Jewish 
Antiquities was written about AD. 93-94.</note> 
sums up the controversy by saying that either Luke had taken no notice of Josephus 
at all, which he thinks the simpler and more probable supposition, or at once forgot 
everything that he had read”. The latter opinion is that of a scholar who believes 
Luke to have written after Josephus. We hold Luke to have written before him.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p14">In truth there is between Luke and Josephus the minimum 
of resemblance and the maximum of discrepancy possible between two authorities writing 
about the same period, and both (as we believe) enjoying access to excellent authorities.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p15">Moreover, it is clear, on the recognized principles of 
critical study, that Luke used some other authority and was not indebted to Josephus 
alone; for he mentions the exact number of persons who followed Theudas, <i>viz</i>., 400, whereas Josephus would lead one to believe that Theudas 
had a very much larger following.<note n="114" id="v.i-p15.1"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="v.i-p15.2">πείθει τὸν πλεῖστον 
ὄχλον . . . ἕπεσθα</span> are his words.</note> 
Thus Luke had other means of learning the date of Theudas. It may be answered that 
Luke invented the number, and designedly or through incapacity varied from the account 
that Josephus gives. To that no reply need be given: they who say so will be ready 
to declare that Luke, who could read Josephus and suppose the procurator Fadus to 
be older than the great enrollment, was equally capable of reading any number of 
additional authorities without profiting by them!</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p16">We cannot, it is true, tell who was the Theudas to whom 
Gamaliel refers. The period is very obscure; Josephus is practically our only authority. 
He does not allude, or profess to allude, to every 
little disturbance on the banks of the Jordan. There is no real difficulty in believing 
that more than one impostor may have borne or taken the name Theudas; that one Theudas, 
amid the troubles that followed the death of Herod the Great (a period about which 
we have no information except that there were great troubles, calling for the presence 
of a Roman army from the Province Syria), or at some earlier time, pretended to 
be somebody, and found 400 followers; and that another Theudas, about AD. 44-46, 
called himself a prophet, and led after him a great part of the Jewish people.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p17">The result is, at present, disappointing. We have to leave 
the difficulty unsolved. We must hope for the discovery of further evidence. Meantime, 
no one who finds Luke to be a trustworthy historian in the rest of his History will 
see any difficulty in this passage.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p18">But there is good cause to look forward confidently to 
the progress of discovery. The advance in knowledge, due to the increased activity 
in searching, has been immense during recent years. The whole essay, which has been 
here set before the public, is founded on one discovery; and after it was print 
it has been confirmed by a new find.<note n="115" id="v.i-p18.1">See Preface.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p19">We may suitably conclude the essay with another discovery, 
slight in itself, but significant of the general trend of advancing knowledge.<note n="116" id="v.i-p19.1">The following paragraphs are shortened 
and modified (but without altering the opinions stated) from an article in the <i>Expositor</i>, September, 1896.</note></p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p20">The reference in <scripRef id="v.i-p20.1" passage="Acts 10:1" parsed="|Acts|10|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.10.1">Acts 10:1</scripRef> to an Italic Cohort (of which Cornelius was a centurion) 
has caused some difficulty and discussion in recent years. Some excellent scholars 
have entertained the suspicion that this detail is an anachronism, caused by the 
intrusion of circumstances that were true at a later time into this early period. 
It is established by an inscription that an Italic Cohort was stationed in Syria 
at a considerably later time; and the theory is that Luke, knowing that such a Cohort 
was there at the time when he wrote, either incorrectly added this detail to the 
story which he learned about Cornelius, or in some other way manipulated or invented 
the story. What reason he had for so treating the story, and how precisely he treated 
it, the theory does not state. It simply casts discredit in a vague way on the story, 
accusing it of containing a false detail.<note n="117" id="v.i-p20.2"><span lang="DE" id="v.i-p20.3"><i>Steht . . . unter dem Verdacht, Verhaltnisse einer spateren Zeit 
in eine fruhere zuruck verlegt zu haben.</i></span></note></p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p21">Among non-theologians, Professor Mommsen pronounces no 
judgment, but avoids making any positive suggestion about the Cohort, in his illuminative 
paper in the <i>Sitzungsberichte</i> of the Berlin Academy, 1895, p. 503.<note n="118" id="v.i-p21.1"><span lang="DE" id="v.i-p21.2"><i>Mit Sicherheit vermoegen wir weder 
diese cohors </i>Augusta (<scripRef id="v.i-p21.3" passage="Acts 27:1" parsed="|Acts|27|1|0|0" osisRef="Bible:Acts.27.1">Acts 27:1</scripRef>)
<i>noch die </i><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="v.i-p21.4">σπεῖρα Ἰταλική</span> . . . 
<i>zu identificieren.</i></span></note> Marquardt, in the work from which all study must always begin in these subjects,
<i>Romische Staatsverwaltung</i>, 2., p. 467, note 5, accepts the words of Acts 
as an ordinary authority, quoting them along with other references to an Italic 
Cohort. A recent discovery confirms the position taken by Marquardt, and will probably 
be held by most scholars as a sufficient proof that, in our present state of knowledge, 
the suspicion that has been entertained about the reference is contrary to the balance 
of evidence.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p22">Dr. Bormann<note n="119" id="v.i-p22.1"><i>Archaol. Epigr. Mittheil. aus Oesterreich,</i> 1895, p. 218.</note> 
publishes an inscription found recently at Carnuntum, one of the great military 
stations in Pannonia, on the south bank of the Danube, a little below Vienna. It 
is the epitaph of a young soldier, Proculus, a subordinate officer (<i>optio</i>) 
in the second Italic Cohort, who died at Carnuntum while engaged on detached service 
from the Syrian army (as an officer in a corps of archers from Syria, temporarily 
sent on special service and encamped at Carnuntum).<note n="120" id="v.i-p22.2"><i>Ex vexil. sagit. exer. Syriaci,</i> 
where Bormann’s completion of the abbreviations seems beyond question <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="v.i-p22.3">ex 
vexillariis sagittariis exercitus Syriaci.</span></note> 
Proculus was born at Philadelphia (doubtless the city of that name beyond Jordan, 
the old Rabbath-Ammon), and his father bore the Syrian name Rabilus.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p23">As to the date of this epitaph, Bormann and Domaszewski, 
two of the highest authorities, have come independently to the same conclusion. 
The epitaph was found with a group of others, stamped by criteria derived both from 
nomenclature, and from inscriptional and alphabetical character, as belonging to 
the period of the early emperors. This group belongs to all older cemetery, which 
was in use before AD. 73, when a new camp near Carnuntum was built for the soldiers 
stationed there. Further, the service on which these Syrian soldiers had come to 
Carnuntum can be dated with the highest probability.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p24">In AD. 69, Syrian detachments to the number of 13,000 men 
swelled the army which Mucianus, governor of Syria, led westwards to support Vespasian 
in his struggle against Vitellius. But before Mucianus arrived on the scene, the 
armies of Pannonia and Moesia had declared for Vespasian, marched into Italy, and 
finished the contest. Their departure had left the northern frontier undefended 
against the barbarians, Dacians, Germans, <i>etc.</i>, 
beyond the Danube. As Tacitus mentions, the Dacians showed signs of invading Moesia, 
and Mucianus dispatched the Sixth Legion<note n="121" id="v.i-p24.1">This Legion, called. Ferrata, was 
enrolled by Augustus and stationed in Syria. It formed part of Mucianus’s army 
in AD. 69; and it remained in Judea at least as late as the third century.</note> 
to guard against them on the Lower Danube. Tacitus does not say anything about the 
Upper Danube; but there also the danger was so obvious, that an experienced governor 
like Mucianus could hardly fail to send a guard thither also; for the words of Tacitus 
(<i>Hist.,</i> 3., 46) show that he was fully alive to the danger all along the 
northern frontier. In this way we may conclude that part of the detachments came 
to Carnuntum; and there Proculus died, perhaps in AD. 70. The Syrian armies were 
evidently soon sent back to the East, where the Sixth Legion is shortly afterwards 
mentioned as engaged in operations in the northern parts of Syria in 73.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p25">There was therefore an Italic Cohort stationed in Syria 
in AD. 69. It was recruited from Syria,<note n="122" id="v.i-p25.1">Proculus was in his seventh year 
of service when he died, and had probably enlisted in AD. 64 (when he was nineteen years old).</note> 
and therefore, according to the principle laid down by Mommsen, it belonged to the 
eastern Roman armies. It is therefore in every way probable that an Italic Cohort 
was stationed in the Province Syria, as Dr. Bormann has observed, about AD. 40, 
when Cornelius is mentioned as “a centurion of the Cohort called Italic,” resident 
in Caesarea (the Roman governmental center of Palestine).</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p26">This discovery, it is true, does not prove conclusively 
that the Italic Cohort, which had been stationed in Syria before AD. 69, was there 
as early as about AD. 40. It is not beyond the range of possibility that the Cohort 
might have been sent to Syria between 40 and 69. Movements of troops from province 
to province were not rare, and the Italic Cohort might have been moved in that interval. 
But, in general, the movements were caused by military requirements which can be 
ascertained. As Marquardt says of Syria, “the same Legions remained for centuries 
in the province,” and they were divided between many different stations, not massed 
in single centers: for example, detachments of the Third Legion called Gallica, 
can be traced in Sidon, Beirut, Aera in the district Auranitis, and Phaena in Trachonitis. 
The whole burden of proof, therefore, rests with those who maintain that a Cohort 
which was in Syria before 69 was not there in 40. There is a strong probability 
that Luke is right when he alludes to that Cohort as part of the Syrian garrison 
about AD. 40.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p27">A series of arguments have been advanced to buttress this 
assumption that Luke when he spoke of an Italic Cohort in Syria about 40 was guilty 
of an anachronism.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p28">It is pointed out, in the first place, that between AD. 
41 and 44, during which period Judea was formed into a dependent kingdom ruled by 
Herod Agrippa, a Roman Cohort would not be stationed in Caesarea. If this were certain, 
it would merely confirm the view taken by many scholars that the incident of Cornelius 
occurred earlier than 41. But as a matter of fact we know far too little of the 
relations between the rule of Agrippa and the provincial administration to be sure 
that a centurion would not be resident in Caesarea during his short reign. There 
is nothing more obscure than the precise terms on which the numerous dependent kingdoms 
in Asia Minor and Syria were administered. It is practically certain that these 
subject kingdoms were tributary from the first, even when they had never before 
been subject to Rome; and even Herod the Great’s action was controlled by Rome in 
many important respects, and his subjects took an oath to be faithful to the Romans. 
But the Judean kingdom of Agrippa, as it existed in AD. 41-44, had long been actually 
part of a Roman province; and there is great probability that it might retain certain 
relations with the provincial government, and that officers of the provincial soldiery 
might be kept resident in the capital, Caesarea, to maintain these relations. There 
is much that might be said on this point; but it is not necessary for our main purpose. 
Moreover, the whole subject is so obscure that a scholar who aims simply at understanding 
the subject will at present refrain from any dogmatic statement about it, and will 
certainly be very slow to condemn an ancient author for inaccuracy, because he does 
not confirm the modern scholar’s hasty conjecture. All that need be said is that 
at present we find the argument so devoid of force that it hardly even affords any 
presumption in favor of a date for the incident of Cornelius earlier than AD. 41.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p29">In the next place it has been argued that even between 
AD. 6 and 41, when Judea was part of the Province Syria, and when Roman auxiliary 
troops were stationed both at Caesarea and at Jerusalem, an Italic Cohort cannot 
have been stationed at Caesarea. This assertion is based on a series of conjectures 
as to the Roman forces stationed in Judea during these years. It is fortunately 
unnecessary for me to discuss these conjectures: I need only point out</p>

<div style="margin-left:10%; margin-right:10%; text-align:justify; margin-top:9pt" id="v.i-p29.1">
<p class="continue" id="v.i-p30"><b>(1)</b> that 
they are in direct contradiction to the principles previously laid down 
by Mommsen, the supreme authority on the subject;<note n="123" id="v.i-p30.1">See Mommsen in <i>Hermes</i>, 19., p. 217.</note></p>
<p class="continue" id="v.i-p31"><b>(2)</b> that 
Mommsen has now considered them and judged them to be “erroneous in 
every respect”.<note n="124" id="v.i-p31.1"><span lang="DE" id="v.i-p31.2"><i>In jeder Hinsicht verfehlt</i></span>, Mommsen in <i>Berlin. Akad. Sitz. </i>1895, p. 501.</note></p>

</div>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p32">But, further, even supposing that these conjectures were 
strong enough to support the conclusion that the Italic Cohort was not stationed 
in Caesarea, we know far too little to justify the inference that a centurion of 
that Cohort could not be on duty there, detached from his Cohort on special service. 
The entire subject of detachment-service is most obscure; and. we are very far 
from being able to say with certainty that the presence of an auxiliary centurion<note n="125" id="v.i-p32.1">Auxiliary centurions, being of lower 
rank than legionary, were not employed as <span lang="LA" style="font-style:italic" id="v.i-p32.2">frumentarii</span> (like Julius in
<scripRef passage="Acts 27:1-44" id="v.i-p32.3" parsed="|Acts|27|1|27|44" osisRef="Bible:Acts.27.1-Acts.27.44">Acts 27.</scripRef>); but there 
were other ways of detached service.</note> in Caesarea is impossible, unless the Cohort in which he was an officer was stationed 
there.</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p33">Since the question of the Roman troops in Palestine is 
so full of difficulties, that it is hardly possible to make any assertion in the 
matter, what judgment should be pronounced on the light-heartedness which suspects 
Luke of inaccuracy, because he does not conform to the conjectures which some distinguished 
German professor sets forth? It is a matter of interest to observe how slow some 
very learned New Testament scholars are to appreciate the principle, which is regarded 
as fundamental by the historical and antiquarian students, that no conjecture which 
is not founded on clear evidence has any right even to be propounded, if it contradicts 
the direct statement of an ancient authority. Much less ought the ancient authority 
to be discredited because he disagrees with a loose and disputed modern conjecture.
</p>
<p class="normal" id="v.i-p34">The episode of Cornelius in Acts is characterized by that 
vagueness and want of direct, incisive statement of details, which Luke shows in 
handling the early history of the Church in Palestine. He was not at home in the 
province of Syria, and the Jewish people in particular he neither understood nor 
liked. If the narrative of Cornelius showed the same mastery of facts and surroundings 
as is apparent in Philippi or Ephesus or Cyprus or Athens, we should find it far 
more instructive than it is as to the way in which an officer of the Roman army 
of occupation lived. Was he resident in a private house? How was he in such close 
relations with the Jews throughout Palestine? Many questions suggest themselves, 
pressing for an answer, which I cannot give. But the tendency of discovery distinctly 
is, in this as in other cases, to confirm the trustworthiness of the general situation.</p>
</div2>


</div1>

    <div1 title="Appendix: Specimens of Documents" progress="98.72%" id="vi" prev="v.i" next="vi.i">
<h1 id="vi-p0.1">APPENDIX<br />
SPECIMENS OF DOCUMENTS</h1>

<h2 id="vi-p0.3">APPENDIX: DOCUMENTS</h2>

      <div2 title="The Inscription of Quirinius (Lapis Tiburtinus)" progress="98.73%" id="vi.i" prev="vi" next="vi.ii">
<h3 id="vi.i-p0.1">THE INSCRIPTION OF QUIRINIUS <br />
(LAPIS TIBURTINUS)</h3>
<p style="text-align:center; color:blue; line-height:125%" id="vi.i-p1">GEM <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.1">·</span>
QVA <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.2">·</span> 
REDACTA <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.3">·</span> INPOI <br />
AVGVSTI <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.5">·</span> POPVLIQVE 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.6">·</span> ROMANI 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.7">·</span> SENATV <br />
SVPPLICATIONES <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.9">·</span> BINAS <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.10">·</span> 
OB SVPPLICATIONES <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.11">·</span> RES <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.12">·</span> PROSP <br />
IPSI <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.14">·</span> ORNAMENTA <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.15">·</span> TRIVMPI <br />
PRO <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.17">·</span> CONSVL SVPPLICATIONES <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.18">·</span> 
ASIAM <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.19">·</span> PROVINCIAM 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.20">·</span> OP <br />
DIVI <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.22">·</span> 
AVGVSTI SVPPLICATIONES <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.23">·</span> ITERVM <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.24">·</span> SYRIAM 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.25">·</span> ET <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.i-p1.26">·</span> PH</p>


<p class="center" id="vi.i-p2">The following restoration is often doubtful: —</p>
<p style="font-weight:bold" id="vi.i-p3"><i>P. Sulpicius P. F. Quirinius cos., datus rector Gaio 
Caesari Divi Augusti nepot........................................................................ 
Pr., pro consule Cretam et Cyrenas provinciam optinens Marmaridas et Garamantas subegit........................................................................................................................ Legatus pro praetore Divi Augusti Syriacas legiones optinens bellum gessit cum gente 
Homonadensium quae interfecerat Amyntam Galatarum re</i><span style="color:blue" id="vi.i-p3.1">gem, qua redacta 
in pot</span><i>estatem Imp. Caesaris </i><span style="color:blue" id="vi.i-p3.2">Augusti Populique 
Romani, Senatus </span><i>dis immortalibus </i><span style="color:blue" id="vi.i-p3.3">supplicationes 
binas ob res prosp</span><i>ere ab eo gestas, et </i><span style="color:blue" id="vi.i-p3.4">ipsi 
ornamenta triumph </span><i>alia decrevit</i></p>
<p style="font-weight:bold" id="vi.i-p4"><span style="color:blue" id="vi.i-p4.1">Proconsul Asiam provinciam op</span><i>tinuit, legatus pr. pr. </i> 
<span style="color:blue" id="vi.i-p4.2">Divi Augusti iterum Syriam et Ph</span><i>oenicen provinciam optinens 
regnum Archelai in provinciae formam redegit.</i></p>

</div2>

      <div2 title="The Inscription of Aemilius Secundus (Lapis Venetus)" progress="99.11%" id="vi.ii" prev="vi.i" next="vi.iii">

<h3 id="vi.ii-p0.1">THE INSCRIPTION OF AEMILIUS SECUNDUS <br />
(LAPIS VENETUS) </h3>

<p style="text-align:center; color:blue; font-weight:bold; line-height:150%" id="vi.ii-p1"><span style="font-size:medium" id="vi.ii-p1.1">Q 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.2">·</span> A E M I L I V S .
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.3">·</span> Q . <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.4">·</span> F <br />
P A L <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.6">·</span> S E C V N D V S</span> <i>i n </i><br />
<span style="font-size:medium" id="vi.ii-p1.8"><i>C</i> ^ S T R I S <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.9">·</span> D I V I <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.10">·</span> A V G .</span> 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.11">·</span> <i>S u b </i><br />
P <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.13">·</span> S V L P I <i>c</i> 
I O <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.14">·</span> Q V I R I N I O  <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.15">·</span> L E <i>G a u g</i> . <br />
<sup>5 </sup>C <i>a</i> E S A R I S  <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.17">·</span> S Y R I A E 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.18">·</span> H O N O R I <br />
B V S <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.20">·</span> D E C O R A T V S 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.21">·</span> P R a E F E C T <br />
C O H O R T <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.23">·</span> A V G 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.24">·</span> <span style="font-size:medium" id="vi.ii-p1.25">I</span> 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.26">·</span> P R <i>a</i> E F <br />
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.28">·</span> C O H O R T  
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.29">· </span>I I <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.30">·</span> C L A S S I C A E 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.31">·</span> I D E M <br />
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.33">·</span> I V S S V <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.34">·</span> Q V I R I N I 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.35">·</span> C E N S V M <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.36">·</span> E G <span style="font-size:medium" id="vi.ii-p1.37">I</span> <br />
<sup>1  </sup>A P A M E N A E <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.39">·</span> C I V I 
T A T I S <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.40">·</span> M I L <br />
L I V M <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.42">·</span> H O M I 
N <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.43">·</span> C <span style="font-size:medium" id="vi.ii-p1.44">I</span> V I V M 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.45">·</span> C X V I I <br />
<span style="font-size:medium" id="vi.ii-p1.47">I </span>D E M <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.48">·</span> 
M I S S V <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.49">·</span> Q V I R I N I <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.50">·</span> 
A D V E R S V S <br />
I T V R A E O S <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.52">·</span> I N 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.53">·</span> L I B A N O <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.54">·</span> M O N T E 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.55">·</span> <br />
C A S T E L L V M <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.57">·</span> E O R V M <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.58">·</span> 
C E P I <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.59">·</span> E T 
<span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.60">·</span> A N <span style="font-size:medium" id="vi.ii-p1.61">T</span> E <br />
<sup>1 5 </sup>M <span style="font-size:medium" id="vi.ii-p1.63">I </span>L I T I E M <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.64">·</span> 
P R A E F E C T <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.65">·</span> F A B R V M <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.66">·</span> <br />
D E L A T V S <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.68">·</span> A <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.69">·</span> 
D V O B V S <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.70">·</span> C O S <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.71">·</span> 
A D <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.72">·</span> A E <br />
R A R I V M <span style="letter-spacing:24pt" id="vi.ii-p1.74"> </span>E T <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.75">·</span> 
I N <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.76">·</span> C O L O N I A <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.77">·</span> <br />
Q V A E S T O R <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.79">·</span> A E D I L <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.80">·</span> 
I I <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.81">·</span> D V V M V I R <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p1.82">·</span> I I <br />
P O N T I F E X S</p>
<p style="text-align:center; color:blue; font-weight:bold; line-height:150%" id="vi.ii-p2"><sup>2  </sup>I BI <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.1">·</span> 
P OS IT I <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.2">·</span> S VN T <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.3">·</span> 
Q <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.4">·</span> A EM IL I VS <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.5">·</span> 
Q <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.6">·</span> F <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.7">·</span> P AL <br />
S EC VN D VS <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.9">·</span> F <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.10">·</span> 
E T <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.11">·</span> A EM IL I A <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.12">·</span> 
C H<span style="font-size:medium" id="vi.ii-p2.13">I</span> A <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.14">·</span> L IB <br />
H <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.16">·</span> M <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.17">·</span> 
A M P L I V S <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.18">·</span> H <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.19">·</span> 
N <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.ii-p2.20">·</span> S</p>

</div2>

      <div2 title="The Italic Cohort Inscription (Lapis Carnuntensis" progress="99.46%" id="vi.iii" prev="vi.ii" next="vi.iv">
<h3 id="vi.iii-p0.1">THE ITALIC COHORT INSCRIPTION <br />
(LAPIS CARNUNTENSIS) </h3>
<p style="text-align:center; color:blue; font-weight:bold; line-height:150%" id="vi.iii-p1">P R O C V L V S <br />
R A B I L I <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.2">·</span> F <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.3">·</span> C O L <br />
P H I L A D E L <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.5">·</span> M I L <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.6">·</span> <br />
O P T I O <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.8">·</span> C O H <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.9">·</span>I I <br />
I T A L I C <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.11">·</span> C <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.12">·</span> R <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.13">·</span> F <br />
T I N I <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.15">·</span> E X <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.16">·</span> 
V E X I L <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.17">·</span>S A <br />
G I T <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.19">·</span> E X E R <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.20">·</span>S Y R I A C I <br />
S T I P <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.22">·</span> V I I <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.23">·</span> 
V I X I T <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.24">·</span> A N <br />
X X V I <br />
A P V L E I V S <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.27">·</span> F R A T E <br />
F <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.29">·</span> C <span style="font-size:x-large; color:red" id="vi.iii-p1.30">·</span></p>

<p style="text-align:center; line-height:125%" id="vi.iii-p2"><i>Proculus Rabili f (ilius) Col( lina) <br />
Philadel( phia) mil( es) optio<br />
coh( ortis) II Italic( ae) c( ivium) <br />
R( omanorurn centuria) F[ aus] tini, <br />
ex vexil( lariis?) sagit( tariis?) <br />
exer( citus) Syriaci stip( endiorum)<br />
VII; vixit an( nos) XXVI. Apuleius<br />
frate( r) f( aciundum) c( uravit).</i></p>

</div2>

      <div2 title="Rating Paper: ’Απογραφη" progress="99.65%" id="vi.iv" prev="vi.iii" next="vii">
<h3 id="vi.iv-p0.1">RATING PAPER: <span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="vi.iv-p0.2">Ἀπογραφή</span></h3>
<p style="margin-left:20%; color:blue; font-weight:bold; line-height:150%" id="vi.iv-p1"><span lang="EL" class="Greek" id="vi.iv-p1.1">Μητροδώρωι ἐπιμελητῆΙ <br />
παρὰ Ἀπύγχιος Ἰναρώτιος <br />
ἑλληνομεμφίτης <sup>sic</sup> Ἀπογράφομαι <br />
κατὰ τὸ ἐκτεθὲν πρόσταγμα <br />
τὴν ὑπάρχυσάν <sup>sic</sup> μοι οἰκίαν <br />
καὶ αὐλὴ <sup>sic</sup> ἐν τῶν Ἑλληνίωι ἐν τόπωι Ἰμενσθὼτ <br />
ἱερῶι, ἧς μέτρα τῆς μὲν οἰκίας π(ήχεις) κα ἐπὶ π(ήχεις) ιγ <br />
τῆς δὲ αὐλῆς π(ήχεις) δ ἐπὶ π(ήχεις) [. . .], <br />
γείτονες πρὸς νότον οἰκία Ταυψάιτος <br />
Φανῶτος, πρὸς βορρᾶν Πάσιτος ἁριάνιος <br />
καὶ ὁδὸς ἀνὰ μέσον, πρὸς λίβα <br />
σιτοποεῖόν μου καὶ ὁδὸς ἀνὰ μέσον, <br />
πρὸς ἀπηλιώτην Ποκαὺς Πετεπτ. ν. ος. <br />
Ταύτην οὖν τιμῶμαι (παχμῶν) δʹ (=400). <br />
Καὶ ἄλλην οἰκίαν, ἐν ᾖ σιτοποιοῦσιν <br />
καὶ αὐλὴ, <sup>sic</sup> ὧν μέτρα τῆς μὲν οἰκίας <br />
μέτρα π(ήχεις) κα ἐπὶ π(ήχεις) 
ιγ, καὶ τῆς αὐλῆς π(ήχεις) δ <br />
ἐπι π(ήχεις) ιγ, γείτονες Ὀννῶφρις Ὥρου οἰκίας, <br />
πρὸς βορρᾶν Πάσιτος τοῦ Ἁριάνοις καὶ ὁδὸς <br />
ἀνὰ μέσον, πρὸς λίβα Νεφεργήριος <br />
Παχράτου, πρὸς ἀπηλιώτην ἡ προγεγραμένη <sup>sic</sup> <br />
οἰκία καὶ ὁδὸς ἀνὰ μέσον. Ταύην οὖν <br />
τιμῶμαι χαλκοῦ (δραχμῶν) βʹ (=2000)<br />
<span style="letter-spacing:40pt" id="vi.iv-p1.25"> </span> / τά(λαντον) α.</span></p>

</div2></div1>

    <!-- added reason="AutoIndexing" -->
    <div1 title="Indexes" id="vii" prev="vi.iv" next="vii.i">
      <h1 id="vii-p0.1">Indexes</h1>

      <div2 title="Index of Scripture References" id="vii.i" prev="vii" next="vii.ii">
        <h2 id="vii.i-p0.1">Index of Scripture References</h2>
        <insertIndex type="scripRef" id="vii.i-p0.2" />

<!-- added reason="insertIndex" class="scripRef" -->
<!-- Start of automatically inserted scripRef index -->
<div class="Index">
<p class="bbook">Judges</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Judg&amp;scrCh=11&amp;scrV=12#iii.iv-p22.7">11:12</a> </p>
<p class="bbook">2 Samuel</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=2Sam&amp;scrCh=16&amp;scrV=10#iii.iv-p22.4">16:10</a> </p>
<p class="bbook">1 Kings</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=1Kgs&amp;scrCh=17&amp;scrV=18#iii.iv-p22.5">17:18</a> </p>
<p class="bbook">2 Chronicles</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=2Chr&amp;scrCh=35&amp;scrV=21#iii.iv-p22.6">35:21</a> </p>
<p class="bbook">Matthew</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=2#iv.vi-p45.2">2:2</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=6#iv.i-p8.1">2:6</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=23#iv.i-p8.2">2:23</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p21.2">4:1-11</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=15#iv.vi-p21.3">4:15</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=6&amp;scrV=3#iii.iv-p21.4">6:3-4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=9&amp;scrV=10#iii.iii-p36.1">9:10</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=12&amp;scrV=46#iii.iv-p21.1">12:46</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=13&amp;scrV=56#iii.iv-p21.2">13:56-57</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=15&amp;scrV=24#iii.iii-p38.1">15:24</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=17&amp;scrV=19#iii.iv-p22.3">17:19</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=19&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p36.7">19:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=26&amp;scrV=6#iii.iv-p40.1">26:6-13</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Matt&amp;scrCh=28&amp;scrV=19#iii.iii-p38.4">28:19</a> </p>
<p class="bbook">Mark</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Mark&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=9#iv.i-p1.1">1:9</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Mark&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=1#iii.iii-p15.2">2:1-4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Mark&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=1#iii.iii-p16.1">2:1-4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Mark&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=2#iii.iii-p23.1">2:2-4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Mark&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=15#iii.iii-p36.2">2:15</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Mark&amp;scrCh=3&amp;scrV=33#iii.iv-p21.3">3:33-3</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Mark&amp;scrCh=10&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p36.6">10:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Mark&amp;scrCh=14&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p19.4">14:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Mark&amp;scrCh=14&amp;scrV=3#iii.iv-p40.2">14:3-9</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Mark&amp;scrCh=16&amp;scrV=15#iii.iii-p38.5">16:15</a> </p>
<p class="bbook">Luke</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=1#iii.iv-p18.1">1:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=1#iv.v-p34.3">1:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=1#iii.iv-p25.1">1:1-4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=1#iii.iv-p25.4">1:1-4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p19.1">1:1-80</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=4#iii.iii-p30.3">1:4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=4#iii.iv-p25.2">1:4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=5#iii.iv-p25.3">1:5</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=5#iv.i-p22.1">1:5</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=24#iii.iv-p4.1">1:24</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=36#iii.iv-p4.3">1:36</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=41#iii.iv-p4.2">1:41</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=41#iii.iv-p4.4">1:41</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=65#iii.iv-p6.1">1:65-66</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=80#iii.iv-p9.1">1:80</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=80#iii.iv-p27.1">1:80</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=1#iv.ii-p1.1">2:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=1#iv.ii-p4.2">2:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=1#ii-p1.1">2:1-4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=1#iv.ii-p2.1">2:1-4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=1#iii.ii-p42.1">2:1-52</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=2#iv.ii-p21.1">2:2</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=3#iv.v-p35.1">2:3</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=4#iv.i-p22.2">2:4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=19#iii.iv-p3.2">2:19</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=22#iv.vi-p46.2">2:22</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=39#iv.i-p11.2">2:39</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=40#iii.iv-p9.2">2:40</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=40#iii.iv-p14.1">2:40</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=40#iii.iv-p28.1">2:40</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=51#iii.iv-p3.3">2:51</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=52#iii.iv-p29.1">2:52</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=3&amp;scrV=1#iv.vii-p6.2">3:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=3&amp;scrV=1#iv.vii-p6.7">3:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=3&amp;scrV=1#iv.i-p22.3">3:1-2</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=3&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p1.3">3:1-2</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=3&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p74.2">3:1-2</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=3&amp;scrV=1#iii.ii-p42.2">3:1-38</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=3&amp;scrV=21#iv.vi-p20.1">3:21</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=3&amp;scrV=23#iv.vi-p1.1">3:23</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=3&amp;scrV=23#iv.vi-p20.2">3:23</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=3&amp;scrV=23#iv.vi-p74.1">3:23</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p20.3">4:1-13</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p21.1">4:1-13</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=13#iv.vi-p34.2">4:13</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=14#iv.vi-p20.4">4:14-15</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=16#iv.vi-p2.1">4:16-30</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=16#iv.vi-p20.5">4:16-30</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=25#iii.iii-p37.2">4:25-27</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=25#iii.iii-p38.2">4:25-27</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=31#iv.vi-p20.6">4:31</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=31#iv.vi-p22.1">4:31</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=31#iv.vi-p34.3">4:31</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=31#iv.vi-p24.1">4:31-9:50</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=42#iv.vi-p22.2">4:42</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=44#iv.vi-p23.1">4:44</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p23.2">5:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p35.2">5:1-39</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=12#iv.vi-p23.3">5:12</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=16#iv.vi-p22.3">5:16</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=17#iii.iii-p15.1">5:17-20</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=17#iii.iii-p18.1">5:17-20</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=18#iii.iii-p23.2">5:18-19</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=20#iii.iii-p29.1">5:20</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=27#iv.vi-p22.4">5:27</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=29#iii.iii-p36.3">5:29</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=6&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p22.5">6:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=6&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p35.3">6:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=6&amp;scrV=10#iv.vi-p22.19">6:10</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=6&amp;scrV=12#iv.vi-p22.6">6:12</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=6&amp;scrV=17#iv.vi-p22.7">6:17</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=6&amp;scrV=39#iv.vi-p22.18">6:39</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=7&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p22.8">7:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=7&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p22.9">7:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=7&amp;scrV=18#iv.vi-p22.10">7:18-20</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=7&amp;scrV=34#iii.iii-p36.4">7:34</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=7&amp;scrV=36#iii.iv-p33.1">7:36</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=7&amp;scrV=36#iii.iv-p33.3">7:36-38</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=7&amp;scrV=36#iii.iv-p40.3">7:36-50</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=8&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p22.11">8:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=8&amp;scrV=2#iii.iv-p32.1">8:2</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=8&amp;scrV=22#iv.vi-p22.12">8:22</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=8&amp;scrV=26#iv.vi-p22.13">8:26</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=8&amp;scrV=31#iv.vi-p26.6">8:31</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=8&amp;scrV=38#iv.vi-p22.14">8:38</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=9&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p36.2">9:1-62</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=9&amp;scrV=2#iii.iii-p23.3">9:2</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=9&amp;scrV=10#iv.vi-p22.15">9:10</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=9&amp;scrV=28#iv.vi-p22.16">9:28</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=9&amp;scrV=37#iv.vi-p22.17">9:37</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=9&amp;scrV=51#iv.vi-p26.1">9:51</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=9&amp;scrV=51#iv.vi-p36.4">9:51</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=9&amp;scrV=51#iv.vi-p28.1">9:51-19:28</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=9&amp;scrV=52#iii.iii-p37.3">9:52-56</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=10&amp;scrV=33#iii.iii-p37.4">10:33</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=10&amp;scrV=38#iii.iv-p34.1">10:38</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=10&amp;scrV=38#iii.iv-p40.6">10:38</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=10&amp;scrV=38#iv.vi-p26.2">10:38</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=10&amp;scrV=38#iv.vi-p30.1">10:38</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=10&amp;scrV=38#iv.vi-p30.2">10:38</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=11&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p26.3">11:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=11&amp;scrV=27#iii.iv-p23.1">11:27</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=11&amp;scrV=27#iii.iv-p36.2">11:27</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=13&amp;scrV=22#iv.vi-p26.4">13:22</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=15&amp;scrV=11#iii.iii-p37.5">15:11-12</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=17&amp;scrV=11#iv.vi-p26.5">17:11</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=17&amp;scrV=11#iv.vi-p36.5">17:11</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=17&amp;scrV=16#iii.iii-p37.6">17:16-18</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=18&amp;scrV=10#iii.iii-p36.5">18:10</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=18&amp;scrV=10#iii.iii-p37.7">18:10-12</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=18&amp;scrV=35#iv.vi-p26.7">18:35</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=19&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p26.8">19:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=19&amp;scrV=5#iii.iii-p37.8">19:5</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=19&amp;scrV=9#iii.iii-p37.8">19:9</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=19&amp;scrV=11#iv.vi-p26.9">19:11</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=19&amp;scrV=28#iv.vi-p26.10">19:28</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=23&amp;scrV=2#iii.iii-p33.1">23:2</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=23&amp;scrV=27#iii.iv-p35.1">23:27</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=23&amp;scrV=29#iii.iv-p36.1">23:29</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=23&amp;scrV=56#iii.iv-p35.1">23:56</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Luke&amp;scrCh=24&amp;scrV=47#iii.iii-p38.3">24:47</a> </p>
<p class="bbook">John</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=45#iv.i-p1.2">1:45</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=45#iv.i-p2.1">1:45</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=4#iii.iv-p22.1">2:4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=4#iv.i-p11.1">2:4-5</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=13#iv.vi-p34.1">2:13</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=20#iv.vi-p34.4">2:20</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=20#iv.vi-p68.1">2:20</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p35.1">5:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p41.1">5:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=6&amp;scrV=4#iv.vi-p36.1">6:4</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=7&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p36.3">7:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=7&amp;scrV=40#iv.i-p3.1">7:40-41</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=7&amp;scrV=41#iv.i-p5.1">7:41</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=11&amp;scrV=2#iii.iv-p40.5">11:2</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=12&amp;scrV=1#iv.vi-p19.3">12:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=12&amp;scrV=1#iii.iv-p40.4">12:1-9</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=John&amp;scrCh=18&amp;scrV=30#iii.iii-p33.2">18:30</a> </p>
<p class="bbook">Acts</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=1#iv.i-p41.1">1:1-80</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=14#iii.iv-p23.2">1:14</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=1#iv.i-p41.2">2:1-52</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=4&amp;scrV=6#iii.i-p2.2">4:6</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=36#v.i-p4.1">5:36-37</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=37#iv.i-p28.1">5:37</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=37#iv.ii-p21.2">5:37</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=5&amp;scrV=37#iv.vii-p2.2">5:37</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=10&amp;scrV=1#v.i-p20.1">10:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=10&amp;scrV=38#iv.i-p1.3">10:38</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=11&amp;scrV=28#v.i-p2.1">11:28</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=13&amp;scrV=3#iv.v-p34.1">13:3</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=13&amp;scrV=9#iii.iii-p8.2">13:9</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=14&amp;scrV=0#iii.iii-p23.4">14</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=15&amp;scrV=0#iii.i-p23.1">15</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=18&amp;scrV=17#iv.v-p34.2">18:17</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=18&amp;scrV=18#iii.iii-p13.1">18:18</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=23&amp;scrV=24#iv.vii-p6.4">23:24</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=23&amp;scrV=26#iii.iii-p30.4">23:26</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=23&amp;scrV=26#iv.vii-p6.4">23:26</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=23&amp;scrV=33#iv.vii-p6.4">23:33</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=24&amp;scrV=1#iv.vii-p6.5">24:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=24&amp;scrV=3#iii.iii-p30.5">24:3</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=24&amp;scrV=10#iv.vii-p6.5">24:10</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=26&amp;scrV=25#iii.iii-p30.6">26:25</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=26&amp;scrV=30#iv.vii-p6.6">26:30</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=27&amp;scrV=1#v.i-p21.3">27:1</a>  
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Acts&amp;scrCh=27&amp;scrV=1#v.i-p32.3">27:1-44</a> </p>
<p class="bbook">Romans</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Rom&amp;scrCh=1&amp;scrV=3#iv.i-p4.1">1:3</a> </p>
<p class="bbook">2 Timothy</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=2Tim&amp;scrCh=2&amp;scrV=8#iv.i-p4.2">2:8</a> </p>
<p class="bbook">Revelation</p>
 <p class="bref">
 <a class="TOC" href="?scrBook=Rev&amp;scrCh=22&amp;scrV=8#iii.i-p2.3">22:8</a> </p>
</div>
<!-- End of scripRef index -->
<!-- /added -->


      </div2>

      <div2 title="Greek Words and Phrases" id="vii.ii" prev="vii.i" next="vii.iii">
        <h2 id="vii.ii-p0.1">Index of Greek Words and Phrases</h2>
        <div class="Greek" id="vii.ii-p0.2">
          <insertIndex type="foreign" lang="EL" id="vii.ii-p0.3" />

<!-- added reason="insertIndex" class="foreign" -->
<!-- Start of automatically inserted foreign index -->
<div class="Index">
<ul class="Index1">
 <li><span class="Greek"> γύναι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iv-p22.10">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek"> παρηκολουθηκότι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.i-p15.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἀνέβη: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p16.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἀνατάξασθαι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iv-p18.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἀπ᾽ ἀρχῆς: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.i-p20.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἀπογράφεσθαι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p17.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἀπογράφεσθαι πᾶσαν τὴν οἰκουμένην: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p15.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἀπογράφομαι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iii-p28.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἀπογράψασθαι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p16.4">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἀπογραφὴ κατ᾽ οἰκίαν: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iii-p28.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἄνδρες: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iv-p5.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἄνωθεν: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.i-p15.2">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.i-p15.4">2</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.i-p20.3">3</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">Ἀπογραφὴ: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iv-p5.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">Ἀπογραφή: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#vi.iv-p0.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἐκ τοῦ προύπτου εἰς τὸ πολεμεῖν τε καὶ βλάπτειν ἐπηρμένοι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.v-p30.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἐν μέσῳ τῆς ἐκκλησίας: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p46.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἐν ταῖς ἡμέραις τῆς ἀπογραφῆς καὶ ἀπέστησε λαὸν ὀπί σω αὐτοῦ : 
  <a class="TOC" href="#v.i-p7.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἐπορεύοντο: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p17.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἑορτὴ: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p41.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἠὲ σοὶ αὐτῇ: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iv-p22.11">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἡ ἑορτή: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p41.4">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἡγεμών: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p6.3">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p30.5">2</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p41.1">3</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἡγεμονία: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p4.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἡγεμονεύειν τῆς Συρίας: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p55.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἡγεμονεύοντος τῆς Συρίας Κυρηνίου: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p6.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἣ: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iv-p22.12">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iv-p22.14">2</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ἵνα ἐπιγνῷς . . . τὴν ἀσφάλειαν: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.i-p20.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ὅτε πρῶτον ἐκέλευσαν ἀπογραφὰς γενέσθαι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p24.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ὗν ἢυἱόν: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p49.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">ὥστε ἀπογραφῆναι πᾶσαν τὴν ὑπ᾽ αὐτὸν γενομένην γῆν καὶ ἣν πρώην εἶχον Ῥωμαῖοι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p16.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">Αὐγοῦστος: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iv-p5.4">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">Μητροδώρωι ἐπιμελητῆΙ παρὰ Ἀπύγχιος Ἰναρώτιος ἑλληνομεμφίτης sic: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#vi.iv-p1.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">αὐλῆς: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p46.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">βασιλικαὶ ὁδοί: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p37.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">διὰ τῶν κεράμων: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p27.4">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">κέραμος: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p27.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">καὶ: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iv-p22.13">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">καθὼς παρέδοσαν οἱ αὐτόπται: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.i-p24.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">καθεξῆς σοι γράψαι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.i-p19.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">κε: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p46.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">κζʹ: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p46.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">κράτιστε: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p42.4">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">κράτιστε Βάσσε: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p42.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">κράτιστος: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p30.2">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p42.1">2</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p43.2">3</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">κςʹ: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p46.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">οἰκουμένη: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p4.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">πάλαι χρώμενος αὐτῷ φίλῳ, νῦν ὑπηκόῳ χρήσεται: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.v-p8.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">παντὸς γοῦν τοῦ Ἰουδᾶικοῦ βεβαιώσαντος δι᾽ ὅρκων ἦ μὴν εὐνοησειν Καίσαρι . . . οἵδε οὐκ ὤμοσαν: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.v-p11.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">παρηκολουθηκότι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.i-p16.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">παρηκολουθηκότι ἄνωθεν πᾶσιν ἀκριβῶς: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.i-p15.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">πείθει τὸν πλεῖστον ὄχλον . . . ἕπεσθα: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#v.i-p15.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">προσεκτήσαντο: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p9.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">σπεῖρα Ἰταλική: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#v.i-p21.4">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">συμπάσης χώρας τῆς ὑπὸ Ῥωμαίοις: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p9.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">τὰ τούτων: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p9.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">τί ἐμοὶ καὶ σοί, γύναι: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iv-p22.2">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">τί ἐμοί: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iv-p22.9">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">τὸν λαὸν ἁπὸ ἀποστήσαντος Κυρινίου τῆς Ἰουδαίς τιμητεύοντος: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#v.i-p7.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">τὸν πλεῖστον ὄχλον: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#v.i-p5.1">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">τῶν κατὰ τὴν ἐπαρχίαν ἡγεμόνων : 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.v-p20.3">1</a></span></li>
 <li><span class="Greek">φίλτατε: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p42.5">1</a></span></li>
</ul>
</div>
<!-- End of foreign index -->
<!-- /added -->

        </div>
      </div2>

      <div2 title="Latin Words and Phrases" id="vii.iii" prev="vii.ii" next="vii.iv">
        <h2 id="vii.iii-p0.1">Index of Latin Words and Phrases</h2>
        <insertIndex type="foreign" lang="LA" id="vii.iii-p0.2" />

<!-- added reason="insertIndex" class="foreign" -->
<!-- Start of automatically inserted foreign index -->
<div class="Index">
<ul class="Index1">
 <li>Collega Imperii: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p8.1">1</a></li>
 <li>Coloniae: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p37.1">1</a></li>
 <li>De uis enim instrumentis saecularia probari necesse est: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iv-p9.2">1</a></li>
 <li>Legati: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p42.3">1</a></li>
 <li>Legatus Augusti pro praetore: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p42.1">1</a></li>
 <li>Legatus Augusti pro praetore.: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p29.2">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p30.4">2</a></li>
 <li>Procurator cum jure gladii: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p42.2">1</a></li>
 <li>Procuratores: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p42.4">1</a></li>
 <li>a silentio: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iii-p8.2">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iii-p9.1">2</a></li>
 <li>anni Augustorum: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iii-p5.1">1</a></li>
 <li>atrium: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p21.2">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p25.1">2</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p25.3">3</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p26.2">4</a></li>
 <li>aula: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p26.4">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p26.7">2</a></li>
 <li>breviarium totius imperii: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iii-p13.3">1</a></li>
 <li>cives Romani: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iv-p18.1">1</a></li>
 <li>cives Romant: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iv-p7.1">1</a></li>
 <li>de facto: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p66.1">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p66.2">2</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p66.3">3</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p66.4">4</a></li>
 <li>de jure: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p64.1">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p64.2">2</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vi-p65.1">3</a></li>
 <li>ex vexillariis sagittariis exercitus Syriaci.: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#v.i-p22.3">1</a></li>
 <li>frumentarii: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#v.i-p32.2">1</a></li>
 <li>impluvium: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p21.1">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p25.2">2</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p26.3">3</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p27.5">4</a></li>
 <li>lacunae: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iii-p8.1">1</a></li>
 <li>legatus Augusti;: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p32.1">1</a></li>
 <li>legatus Divi Alugusti iterum Syria obtinuit: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p32.2">1</a></li>
 <li>libellus: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iii-p13.2">1</a></li>
 <li>minutiae: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.v-p43.1">1</a></li>
 <li>omnium prov: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p34.2">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p34.3">2</a></li>
 <li>optimus: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p43.1">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p44.1">2</a></li>
 <li>peristylium: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iii.iii-p26.6">1</a></li>
 <li>rationes imperii: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iii-p13.1">1</a></li>
 <li>reductio ad absurdum: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.ii-p23.1">1</a></li>
 <li>supplicatio: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p11.3">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p11.4">2</a></li>
 <li>supplicationes: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p11.1">1</a>
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.vii-p11.2">2</a></li>
 <li>tribunicia potestas: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iii-p19.1">1</a></li>
 <li>tributum capitis: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.iii-p32.1">1</a></li>
</ul>
</div>
<!-- End of foreign index -->
<!-- /added -->

      </div2>

      <div2 title="German Words and Phrases" id="vii.iv" prev="vii.iii" next="toc">
        <h2 id="vii.iv-p0.1">Index of German Words and Phrases</h2>
        <insertIndex type="foreign" lang="DE" id="vii.iv-p0.2" />

<!-- added reason="insertIndex" class="foreign" -->
<!-- Start of automatically inserted foreign index -->
<div class="Index">
<ul class="Index1">
 <li>Dichtung und Wahrheit: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.i-p16.1">1</a></li>
 <li>Ein allgemeiner Reichscensus war dazu weder nothig noch zweckmassig: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#iv.i-p18.2">1</a></li>
 <li>In jeder Hinsicht verfehlt: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#v.i-p31.2">1</a></li>
 <li>Mit Sicherheit vermoegen wir weder diese cohors : 
  <a class="TOC" href="#v.i-p21.2">1</a></li>
 <li>Steht . . . unter dem Verdacht, Verhaltnisse einer spateren Zeit in eine fruhere zuruck verlegt zu haben.: 
  <a class="TOC" href="#v.i-p20.3">1</a></li>
</ul>
</div>
<!-- End of foreign index -->
<!-- /added -->

      </div2>
    </div1>
    <!-- /added -->

  </ThML.body>
</ThML>
