19. The case standing thus,
suppose, as I said, that we are now for the first time seeking unto
what religion we shall deliver up our souls, for it to cleanse and
renew them; without doubt we must begin with the Catholic Church.
For by this time there are more Christians, than if the Jews and
idolaters be added together. But of these same Christians, whereas
there are several heresies, and all wish to appear Catholics, and
call all others besides themselves heretics, there is one
356Church, as all allow: if you consider the whole world,
more full filled in number; but, as they who know affirm, more pure
also in truth than all the rest. But the question of truth is
another; but, what is enough for such as are in search, there is
one Catholic, to which different heresies give different names
whereas they themselves are called each by names of their own,
which they dare not deny. From which may be understood, by judgment
of umpires who are hindered by no favor, to which is to be assigned
the name Catholic, which all covet. But, that no one may suppose
that it is to be made matter of over garrulous or unnecessary
discussion, this is at any rate one, in which human laws themselves
also are in a certain way Christian. I do not wish any prejudgment
to be formed from this fact, but I account it a most favorable
commencement for enquiry. For we are not to fear lest the true
worship of God; resting on no strength of its own, seem to need to
be supported by them whom it ought to support: but, at any rate, it
is perfect happiness, if the truth may be there found, where it is
most safe both to search for it and to hold it: in case it cannot,
then at length, at whatever risk, we must go and search some other
where.